4 ms·
While I agree 110% with everything you've said here, I think we should be careful to not rule out the possibility that our sensation of "hearing" may involve pa
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
While I agree 110% with everything you've said here, I think we should be careful to not rule out the possibility that our sensation of "hearing" may involve parts of the body ouside the ear. For example, I think it's a long shot, but there is some vague possibility that supersonic frequencies may be detectable by other parts of the body. I would prefer to not be in the group laughed at in 110 years from now: "back in the 21st century, those idiots thought that we only experienced sound through our ears".
That said this product and audiophilia in general is just pure unadulterated BS.
- ganbatekudasai 5y agoYou've definitely got a point. But that ~20kHz figure to my knowledge was not just determined by "can the ear hear this" but by "can the person hear a difference". But yeah, theoretically, it's possible that all that science was only conducted with, say, headphones. Like with all things science, everything is only falsifiable, never 100% provable. But yeah, I think we're indeed on the same page, the claims that audiophiles make are often falsified already. Or make so little sense that it's akin to "eating an apple in the morning shifts Helium's absorption spectrum by a few nm". You can attempt (and succeed) to falsify that, but it's such a waste of time and energy...
- walrus01 5y ago> our sensation of "hearing" may involve parts of the body ouside the ear. It's definitely possible to tell the difference between the quality of audio from a shitty subwoofer ($50) vs something that costs $200... Not so much audio as perceived by eardrum but perceptible vibration felt by the body. The cheap one also is likely to rattle its own chassis and feet and vibrate on whatever floor you've placed it on.
- ganbatekudasai 5y agoAnd nobody is disputing that. As said, you want to focus on optimizing audio, optimize your room, your speakers, your headphones etc... there is solid and well understood math behind speaker and room acoustic models.
- walrus01 5y agoAbsolutely agreed... I'm in the market segment of having a $500 onkyo home theater receiver and a basic 5.1 speaker set (anything else would be a waste in a small condo living room), anything beyond that sees diminishing returns fairly quickly.
- Nextgrid 5y agoIt can very well be that the sensation of "hearing" includes the placebo effect - spending insane amounts of money on an audio system that you perceive to be superior will make you believe the sound quality is better. Of course, the answer here is proper education as opposed to selling overpriced snake oil.
- ganbatekudasai 5y agoGood point, I can totally imagine that this is what happens, and agree with what the answer should be.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoAnd the moment someone presents a scientific experiment to show a difference, I'll consider it. I don't need a mechanism, I don't need an explanation, just a control group and an experimental group of visually-identical equipment, double-blind procedure, and a statistically meaningful ability for the listener to tell which is which.