> But this is a subset of the useful papers to be written, and in my experience a small one. Certainly. I never claimed otherwise. But bloaf's and lonesword s

> But this is a subset of the useful papers to be written, and in my experience a small one. Certainly. I never claimed otherwise. But bloaf's and lonesword seem to think such papers are of only superficial merit at best, and that detailed steps to reproduce the research are essential. I disagree with that viewpoint.