3 ms·
I hate this web3 bs as much as the next guy But, this seems more a list of people doing stupid shit with blockchain-y things, and not an argument against it as
by bawolff 5y ago
I hate this web3 bs as much as the next guy
But, this seems more a list of people doing stupid shit with blockchain-y things, and not an argument against it as a whole. That doesn't distinguish blockchain that much from other technologies (e.g. consider WWW during the hype of dot-com bubble).
I pretty much believe its all absolute bullshit, but picking some egregious examples, while amusing, doesn't really show that.
- antupis 5y agoThis pets.com was bullshit but selling pet supplies at online definitely is not.
- ojr 5y agostoring scarce jpegs is bullshit but decentralize storage definitely is not
- heyitsguay 5y agoIt's not bullshit but it's also not very useful compared to existing alternatives (compare latency, availability, and reliability), and it requires juuust enough technical knowledge to understand why that you can still build a convincing narrative about it for laypeople. Which you are incentivized to do when their buy-in makes you money.
- gowld 5y agopets.com was just a bit early, so the economy of scale didn't kick in. chewy.com made the same model work 20 years later, with 100x the potential userbase people comfortable shopping online.
- fab1an 5y agoMy mouse hovered over the downvote button given your language here, but I understand that web3 has become this insanely emotional issue, so here's a comment instead: for every moronic ponzi scheme in crypto, there's one community that will blow your mind with their creativity and spirit. They're out there. Just consider the possibility that not all of it is crap, and that parts of it will play a significant role in our future. Give it a chance and you might be very positively surprised about what you can find on it.
- not2b 5y agoCould you give some examples? I am skeptical, but am willing to admit I'm wrong if you can really point to a "community that will blow your mind with their creativity and spirit".
- WickyNilliams 5y agoThere's a funny parallel between conspiracy theorists "do your own research, there answers are out there" and crypto proponents "it's not all nonsense, if you look into it further, there's good stuff out there". And yet neither group are forthcoming enough to offer up the examples themselves. It feels like an invitation to indoctrinate yourself.
- bawolff 5y agoFTR: my opinion that its bullshit is based on an a lack of plausible usecases (other than the original bitcoin as a currency one). At best there are some things you can do with it that you can already do better with other tech. I could of course be wrong, and i would be very happy to be proved wrong. However so far i haven't seen anything to convince me otherwise.
- Kronosfear 5y agoIf such a community existed, you would have linked it as an example here. inb4 "Do your own research"
- sneak 5y ago> I hate this web3 bs as much as the next guy This is one of the narrative items I have a major issue with. The critics of cryptocurrencies in general seem to push the concept that only the insane, extremists, or shills would not hate these systems, and that all one has to do to hate it just like them is to read about it! That's not really borne out in reality. This is one of those "everybody knows" things that's actually a falsehood.
- bawolff 5y agoI mean, i would hope people read about it before forming an opinion one way or another. I have yet to encounter anything yet that has changed my mind. Might i be wrong? Of course. I've been wrong about other technologies, i might be wrong about this one (and i would be happy to be proved wrong. I'd love to have new technology that can do cool new things) As far as if "everybody knows", sure my opinion is not a universal one, but its not exactly an obscure one either.
- gowld 5y agoOK, I want to use a new web3 product. How do I know it's one of the good ones and not a scame?