4 ms·
Linux Foundation spends just 3.4% of its money on Linux
- kragen 5y agoWhat would be great would be if the other 96.6% was being spent on creating havens for free software to be safe from patent and copyright law. Project support and community infrastructure is pretty nice, though. And that's 68.8% of the total. But if it's true that it's support for projects like Open3D that undermine Linux, that's not cool.
- Shadonototra 5y agoLooks like a poorly managed foundation..
- Out_of_Characte 5y agoWhy is this the first time i'm hearing about this? When did this start? I think there's an underlying reason why people are hesitant to donate money to a cause because if even a software foundation predicated on open source and transparency can't get money into the hands of open source projects then publicly funded donations are a really bad bet for making the world a better place.
- cinntaile 5y agoThis is a bit ridiculous. It's called the Linux Foundation, not the Linux Kernel Foundation. The Linux Foundation is for the open source community in general hence why not all money ends up being used for coding the kernel. It's not even being used just for open source code, it is no secret at all that the open source community is more than just code. They spend 6 million usd on the linux kernel. Just because you throw more money at a problem doesn't mean the end result will turn out better.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y ago> This is a bit ridiculous. It's called the Linux Foundation, not the Linux Kernel Foundation. Linux is a kernel. If they mean the "Linux-Adjacent Open Source Software Foundation", then call it that.
- Out_of_Characte 5y agoWhen you call something the Linux foundation I would expect money to go to projects involving linux. I would have no issues if they grant money to anything that remotely involves linux. The sheer amount of open source developers that are barely receiving donations trough their own sourcing is staggering. every week I can find posts on HN about marketing your projects and the struggles of advertising or improving their project. The philosophy of building free and open source software and merit shall grant you monetisation is completely dead to me. There's no way human group dynamic would sustain this if the Linux foundation with their 177 million is enough to cause such a divergence from any semblance of this core idea.
- sigmonsays 5y agoi feel like words no longer have merit. How can you continue to call yourself "The linux foundation" and contribute so little?
- rhinoceraptor 5y agoThis is like saying it's ridiculous for the Apache foundation to call itself such, when they support hundreds of other OSS projects and initiatives, instead of just the Apache web server.
- g42gregory 5y agoWow. I totally did not see this coming. Obviously, they have more money than they know what do with. And they don’t need any more of it.
- jimis 5y agoTheir financial report appears to be quite opaque and closed, as opposed to the Linux project and community.
- mrtweetyhack 5y agoWe all know that money goes into CEO pocket
- gorwell 5y agoLooks like they on the same path as academia. Which ceded to a parasitic administrative class eating all the resources with made up bullshit jobs for the overproduced elite.
- caspper69 5y agoUnfortunately, the same is true of a lot of charities as well.
- karagenit 5y agoI don't know much about academia, but is that really a fair assessment of the Linux foundation? Most charities are considered "good" if they spend less than 25% of revenue on admin overhead, and the article says the Linux foundation spends only 7.8%.
- 131012 5y agoI wonder if the biggest section, Project Support, is actually used to... well... finance projects that make Linux better. Most of the criticism I hear about Linux is definitely not about the Kernel, but about its ecosystem. Drivers, high quality utility programs, etc. I agree with the fact that it should be explained, but I definitely do not think the conspirational/rational-right-wingism/omgwokes tone is so pertinent.
- p_l 5y agoLots of projects that drive adoption of linux in new environments (even if I have issues with Automotive Linux), also projects that even if they are supported on other platforms, are considerable drivers of Linux usage (the cloud projects - including k8s - AgStack, etc.)
- cool_dude85 5y agoGood trick here. The article starts about how only 3.4% is spent on kernel development, which is a fair complaint. Then the author picks some other stuff totally unrelated to the spending breakout to complain about, including diversity efforts, for which there are no spending breakouts. Spending on these may be 1/100th of a percent for all we know, but the author claims at the end that despite not having spending breakdowns, that this is a fair description of the Linux Foundation, based on their annual report: “The Linux Foundation is dedicated to social justice activism, climate change, and vaccine passports… while occasionally using Open Source software.”
- josteink 5y ago> Spending on these may be 1/100th of a percent for all we know Might be. But it still gets 5-10x more attention in the report itself which hints at the Linux Foundation’s priorities, and most likely spending. I say it’s a fair complaint.
- p_l 5y agoHave you considered that it might be at insistence of the major sponsors that should language is used in the report?
- bradleybuda 5y agoThis is outrage porn trying to push an anti-diversity, anti-inclusion agenda. The Linux Foundation supports literally thousands of open source projects that are not the Linux Kernel, most notably Kubernetes. This is in the report that the blog post author linked but willfully didn't bother to read. The actual report (PDF): https://www.linuxfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2021_LF_Annual_Report_120721c.pdf https://www.linuxfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2021_LF_A...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- eadmund 5y agoThat anyone finds terms like 'whitespace,' 'whitelist' and 'blacklist' problematic is an outrage. They are not racist, they have nothing to do with race (look up their histories!) and a charity should not spend even a single penny of its donors' money on trying to forbid their use. Folks should be outraged at this misuse of their donations.
- dimitar 5y agoThe donors to LF, or at least where the money comes from are big tech corporations like Microsoft who likely insisted on inclusive language.
- cgriswald 5y ago> Folks should be outraged at this misuse of their donations. This is tantamount to telling other people how to spend their own money.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't take HN threads further into flamewar. This one is particularly repetitive and predictable. Not what HN is for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- eadmund 5y ago
- ameminator 5y agoEDIT: After reading the report[0], I have to retract this comment. This article really is taking things out of proportion. ~55% of donations go to other open source project support, a combined 20% goes to community training, tooling and events. It seems only 7% goes to admin and while only 3% of funding directly goes to the Linux kernel, it seems this grossly misrepresents the Linux Foundation's contribution to open source. While I also have issues with the "Diversity Olympics" that most American companies seem to play on, I am re-assured after reading the full report. I also understand that DIE initiatives are "intellectually fashionable" even if the fundamental morality of DIE is questionable, but I can't have too many complaints if the core mission is not put in jeopardy - which I really can't conclude from the report. I am leaving the original comment up for reference [0] https://www.linuxfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2021_LF_Annual_Report_120721c.pdf https://www.linuxfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2021_LF_A... Original comment: What a travesty. Honestly, I don't even know which organization I can support if even the Linux Foundation isn't contributing its money open source technical excellence. I guess directly supporting open source developers is one way, but now there is the question of who to fund. Is funding for open source and/or charitable software a lost cause? Do we have to just accept that open-source software is fundamentally a volunteer effort, and will never allow a person to eat or pay rent?
- josteink 5y ago> I guess directly supporting open source developers is one way, but now there is the question of who to fund. Personally I sponsor projects which I consider somewhat niche/non-mainstream, but which I myself reap great benefits from every day. It’s probably nowhere near enough to put food on anyone’s table, but at least it’s directed at people I find deserving, for things I care about, and for better or worse, it’s better than nothing.
- p_l 5y agoArguably a lot of the "flagship" projects in the report impact the sponsors of Linux Foundation a lot.
- caslon 5y agoThis is a terrible article by an author who makes a living off of clickbait headlines. 3.4% of its money goes to Linux kernel development. This is because they really don't have to hire kernel developers. Other companies do that for them. There are a handful of kernel developers employed by the Linux Foundation, but there doesn't need to be a lot, because there are already enough kernel developers hired by every other major corporation on the planet. GKH at one point said the entire reason the book Linux Device Drivers hasn't been updated since Linux 2.6 is because they already have enough kernel developers. If you look at the graphs, 68.8% of their expenditures are on project support and infrastructure, separately from the 3.4% going to the kernel. The LF is responsible for a lot. It's not just the kernel; there are thousands of things in Linux's ecosystem.
- mnd999 5y agoLinux is free, so no need to pay for it.
- a-dub 5y agoi see 7.8% overheads and the rest as program work which is actually pretty great for an ngo. this piece reads like someone opportunistically skimmed the annual report for provocative headlines to promote their own brand. skimming the toc for the annual report, i see loads of relevant linux support efforts that go beyond just the kernel. i'd buy this argument if actual kernel devs were complaining, not someone trying to build readership.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xd 5y agoMost of the spending seems to be indirect which isn't immediately obvious - but "Project Support" ties in with their objectives as laid out from wikipedia... I couldn't find a clear mission statement on their website. "The Linux Foundation (LF) is a non-profit technology consortium founded in 2000 as a merger between Open Source Development Labs and the Free Standards Group to standardize Linux, support its growth, and promote its commercial adoption. It also hosts and promotes the collaborative development of open source software projects. It is a major force in promoting diversity and inclusion in both Linux and the wider open source software community." [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linux_Foundation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linux_Foundation
- phendrenad2 5y agoIt's telling that the foundation that is supposed to shepherd Linux has found it unable to stay afloat without strapping other things like kubernetes and SBOM to the boat. There's an interesting discussion to be had there. And maybe someone will write a blog post about that. (Unfortunately, this one is full of anti-"woke" rhetoric, as is Lunduke's style these days)
- ohCh6zos 5y agoIt's a shame the Linux Foundation spends any money on things like 'inclusive' language efforts. They can do what they want, but I won't be supporting them.
- dimitar 5y agoThis is interesting and looked at the LF website to try to figure out what they do. The author seems to portray the LF as a political organisation, while to me it seems like a way for corporate donors to contribute help. I imagine most of the source code is contributed by employees of the member companies, volunteers/enthusiasts or "the community", and it is not the LFs business. About 60% of expenditure is "Project Support" (I included Linux project support here) which seems to be all kinds of non-code help to open source projects. I see Legal, Marketing, Community management, Training, Infrastructure, Creative/Design. Here is a description from the website: https://linuxfoundation.org/projects-support-programs/ https://linuxfoundation.org/projects-support-programs/ I grant you that it is vague, but I doubt there is much politics involved. A big open source project like Kubernetes probably needs all of that help. As a project grows bigger lots of non-code issues grow in importance. I think maintainers and code contributors would like not having to spend too much time dealing with WCAG on the flashy website, checking everyone's contributor agreements, vulnerability scans, paying for CI/CD, writing articles about the project, dealing with trolls in the community and moderation in their forums. Next is community infrastructure with 12%. No idea what that is but it might be LFX which looks neat: https://lfx.linuxfoundation.org https://lfx.linuxfoundation.org It seems to be a project management tool. I will lump together Community Tooling, Training and Events in their 20% category. Especially the Training and Events seem to also bring revenue - so students and attendees pay for that. Not sure what Tooling is exactly - could be LFX again. Then you have the last 8% which is Corporate operations, or their own Legal, Finance, etc. departments.
- cgriswald 5y agoHis arguments are all garbage. Easily the lamest article I've read on HN. For instance, he claims: > “Linux Kernel Support” is the lowest priority for The Linux Foundation. First, this implies that dollars spent equals priority. A lower priority project may need more dollars. The test of priority is which things take priority when dollar needs can't be met. It also assumes large donors have no say at all where there donations go and a million other things. Second, it ignores the fact that when someone says "Linux" they don't automatically mean only the kernel. It's true that some and perhaps most do and it is maybe even the correct view, but that's demonstrably not the view of the Linux Foundation. Even if it were, there's lots of argument to be made for supporting people who may support or work on the kernel now or in the future. Third, even though he admits he doesn't know how the financials break down, he somehow knows every project receives more than direct Linux kernel support. That's the best interpretation of his claim. The worst is that he's disingenuously lumping all projects together. Fourth, he ignores the fact that some of these supported Projects themselves support the Linux kernel.
- TheNexxuz 5y agoI found the article quite interesting and informative.
- trembonator 5y agoThere are very few Linux accreditation sources out there. Red Hat is the biggest player. Since the Linux Foundation has become a political venture, they will be treated as such.