4 ms·
I like this article, but there's another way of classifying that I also like: letter grades (remember those from school?) which uses hiring psychology a little
by AlbertCory 5y ago
I like this article, but there's another way of classifying that I also like: letter grades (remember those from school?) which uses hiring psychology a little more. In a successful startup, whom you hire makes or breaks you.
'A' players hire 'A' players.
'B' players hire 'C' players.
Independent of Revolutionary vs. Evolutionary, we have pure intelligence, education, and animal cunning. An 'A' player has all those, and moreover knows when a Revolutionary strategy is required, and when it's not.
A 'B' player tends to be Evolutionary, because it's safer, but occasionally he'll say "me, too!" to a Revolutionary if it seems to advance his career.
An 'A' player can recognize another one. That's all he or she wants to hire.
A 'B' player is bewildered and threatened by an 'A" player, and moreover, the 'A' player wants nothing to do with him. So he wants to hire someone who's safe and no threat to his tenuous position: the 'C' player.
After the startup is successful, the 'B' managers flood it with their resumes. They like a safe bet. Once they get in and start hiring their own, it's all over.
- wrnr 5y agoYou like putting people in boxes and therefor others must, just like you, put people in boxes. It must be hard to be autistic.
- dang 5y agoAttacking other users like this will get you banned here. Please don't do that again. If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting, we'd appreciate it.
- wrnr 5y agoSubstitute the variables A and B with jew and gentile, or black and white, and even white and black, and maybe you understand how hateful and retarded the original comment is.
- dang 5y agoWe need you (i.e. everyone here) to follow the rules regardless of how bad another comment is or you feel it is. Everyone always feels like the other person started it and did worse—this is more or less a hardwired perception, or at least difficult to extricate from. If people use that as a basis for how they respond to others, we're guaranteed a downward spiral. That's what we're trying to avoid in this forum, that's why we have the site guidelines, and that's why the guidelines don't depend on how other commenters are behaving. https://hn.algolia.com/?query=downward%20spiral%20by:dang&dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?query=downward%20spiral%20by:dang&da...
- groby_b 5y agoThat is, pardon the directness, bad pop psychology. If A players could recognize another one, our industry's hiring wouldn't be so incredibly broken. The idea that there are clear layers of engineering skill is... just plain wrong, and that's obvious to anyone who's worked on more than a few teams. It's a spectrum, and more, it's multidimensional. So is the idea that somehow people not in the top layer automatically hire worse people. I've worked with top skilled people (think "starting an entire new segment") who couldn't hire their way out of a wet paper bag. I've work with solid performers who weren't outstanding in any way, except they consistently hired excellent people. I've also worked with people who were mediocre performers by themselves, but who significantly accelerated any team they were on. Not by visible output, but by being clearly necessary "glue" that bound the team closer together and helped people to shine. I've seen superstars go to mediocre, and vice versa, just based on managers and or team they were on. If you can't think about people in more subtle ways than "A,B,C" or "Revolutionaries vs Evolutionaries", you are significantly shortchanging yourself and your team.
- AlbertCory 5y agoI don't think you really understand the power of simple metrics. Making an assumption (perhaps invalid) based on your submissions and comments, you seem to be in a line of work whose sales pitch is "Things are complex. You need to hire us to explain it all to you." Or maybe you've worked on games; it's hard to tell. Since you've alluded to your experiences: I've picked a startup based only on their business description, where I didn't know a single person, and it IPO'ed in about 18 months. Then the 'B' players flooded in, and some other unrelated stuff happened. What have you done?
- bsedlm 5y agoI think he's saying you cannot only rely on any particular simple metric (nor just a couple of them). I'd say you gotta use many metrics, the simpler they are the more metrics you'd need. simple metrics ignore the subtelties which can make or break.
- AlbertCory 5y ago
- willob33 5y agoAre you suggesting founders are A players? They’re the B players who suck up to wealth holders. Are there A players? Everyone gets a handout at some point. The ultra rich get one in the form of no taxes. An A player would surely just be a billionaire. Sure is easy being an A player when your handouts from decades ago earned a lot of interest. How are we still this oblivious? We spent the last decade making building these things this easy on purpose. Where is the A game in using the machine how it was intended?
- adolph 5y agoHow'd the the "'B' player" get a job in the first place? Does an "'A' player" have a half life at which they degrade to "'B' player?" Is the letterness of any basket of skills and traits context dependent so that an "'A' player" used car salesperson is a "'C' player" philosopher but the "'A player" philosopher recognize that person as a fellow "'A' player" but can't understand their lack of wisdom-love?
- drekk 5y agoWhat value do you find in inventing a caste system for engineers? Psychology already suffers from a replication crisis and pseudoscientific quackery; corporate psychology is even less broadly applicable to humans. People are not static; they're not just their genes, and they're not just a grade. You said you're an A player, why don't we compare your hiring to a random selection of hiring managers with similar experience in your field? My degree was in Integrative Neuroscience and I'd caution people against these "just so!" explanations. A good narrative is often more convincing than the correct one.
- ziggus 5y agoThis is the same kind of organizational naivete displayed by armchair middle-manager wannabes that think stack ranking is a great idea too. Once you start trying to codify potential or current employees into buckets delineated by simplistic and frankly silly metrics and not by the value they produce in a given set of domains and contexts, then you've already lost the game.
- AlbertCory 5y agoYou'll note, HN'ers, that I never said that I was an A player, nor that engineers can all be divided up into castes. You all seem to be extrapolating based on your own prejudices. It's just a (sometimes) useful way of thinking about top executives, who mostly can be assigned grades. Engineers are too complex to be divided that way. As for me: yes, some A players did decide I could be useful. I think I was, as an engineer, and they thought so too. On hiring people: the record was more mixed; some good and some not so great.