4 ms·
Dear author, "Web 3.0" isn't the metaverse. It was the Semantic Web. Web 3.0 was designed to give individual web publishers and consumers the capabilities tha
by echelon 5y ago
Dear author,
"Web 3.0" isn't the metaverse. It was the Semantic Web.
Web 3.0 was designed to give individual web publishers and consumers the capabilities that giants like Facebook and Google have.
Documents had structured data, marked up in rich RDF or Owl ontologies that could expose APIs for your data. You're probably familiar with RSS and Atom and the wonderful ecosystem of tools they had, but there were hundreds of RDF schemas. FOAF, for example, would let you publish and consume contact info, and even encode friends lists if you were interested. There were lots of these.
This was also at the time of peak Bittorrent/P2P, and we were really close to having schemas for sharing news and commentary in a P2P swarm. Imagine fully decentralized Reddit and Twitter (not federated!), where identities were anonymous by default, comments and upvotes were cryptographically signed and published, and you could curate your own peer group, interest graph, attention algorithm, and filtering. We were almost there.
Clients that operated on RDF schemas were also faster and less cludgy than HTML. We could write native code and GUIs to consume and publish this data, and we were close to evolving the HTML soup into something better.
Unfortunately, this is right at the time Google and Facebook had grown immensely from VC and ad money jet fuel. Academics and builders were distracted. People flocked to centralized platforms because it was easy and our tools were immature.
We were really close, but the tech cos got there first, got lock in, and then started messing with the commons.
Please don't forget that "web 3.0" wasn't crypto. It was more than about payment. It was a stack that gave you and I capabilities and potential that the giants have. It was a distributed knowledge graph that would have been a nirvana of innovation and sharing. But we got sidetracked, out engineered, and roadblocked.
Web 3.0 = Semantic Web.
We can still remember what it aspired to be, and we can still build it.
Never forget.
- selfhoster11 5y agoLet's face it. The term "Web 3" has been hijacked by cryptobros, as has been the very term "crypto".
- chaganated 5y agothe semantic web is philosophically bankrupt. schemas and curation lost to the algorithm, by a wide margin, and for a good reason. ontologies are infinite.
- streamofdigits 5y agothe algorithm is morally bankrupt. which is worse
- chaganated 5y agothe world doesn't care. whoever finds the needle quickest, cheapest, wins.
- echelon 5y agoYou can define an infinite number of hypothetical APIs in all different shapes and sizes, but you don't. You decide what you're building and move on, letting other people begin to use your work. Same with ontologies.
- chaganated 5y agoseasoned programmers struggle to figure out the "right" API for a single purpose, and still get it wrong. good luck figuring out the "right" API for the sum of human knowledge & our ever changing interpretations & interrelations of it.
- echelon 5y agoIt's not the sum of human knowledge, though. Any subset works. Your grammar can have five nouns and that can be enough for your use case.
- chaganated 5y agountil it isn't. then the semantic librarians have to re-classify everything. while an army of them spend months on their RDFs, OWLs, & re-taggings, a lone undergrad overtakes them in a week with a web scrape & word vectors. that, and people lie.