7 ms·
There is an excellent argument that IP law doesn't help society at large - that is why China is ignoring IP law. They need to grow their economy ASAP to protect
by roenxi 5y ago
There is an excellent argument that IP law doesn't help society at large - that is why China is ignoring IP law. They need to grow their economy ASAP to protect themselves from the United States military, and the strategy seems to involve technical dominance. They can't do that if they weigh themselves down with IP laws; they already have enough problems with innovation.
That observation is entirely consistent with the US wanting to be exceedingly careful about IP exfiltrating to China.
- defaultprimate 5y ago>protect themselves from the United States military Protect themselves from the US military how? When they start imperial subjugation campaigns...or? China's malicious aspirations are the only thing the US is concerned with.
- ethbr0 5y agoNeither China nor the US are, historically or currently, moral pillars for the just use of military power. It's clear enough to note that China has short-term aspirations of invading a sovereign state, and leave it at that.
- defaultprimate 5y agoOne actively cultivated a culture of establishing an absolutist surveillance state resulting in the death and torture of tens of millions, often at the hands of their own children, in the course of a decade or so, is currently participating in genocide, has institutionally striven to sustain an ethnostate, treats their population like cattle, and exercises extrajudicial imprisonment and execution against vast swaths of the population to preserve political power. There is no comparison of morality between the US and China. For all its faults and failures the US is unequivocally a more moral and just nation. Let's not just leave it at that. I won't let you deceptively downplay the egregious evil China is and has been responsible for. It's directly responsible for multiple events that when measured over the course of history, are the most insane human atrocities ever committed.
- tsimionescu 5y agoChina Oana monstrous regime to its own people, and has been exporting the technology and know-how for their monstrous treatment more and more. However, the US has killed many times more people in other countries, and brutalized countless nations - Vietnam, El Salvador, Nicaragua, Afghanistan, Iran, Irak, Cuba, Palestine, Cambodia and many others. They are both immoral, but i d different ways at different times, like all empires have been and forever will be, from the Romans to the Arabs to the Mongols to the French, Dutch, Belgians etc.
- BobbyJo 5y agoThere are lots of places where your argument is nonsense, but I feel like the most important thing to address is this: > However, the US has killed many times more people in other countries That's just inaccurate. The founding of the current communist regime resulted in more deaths within China's borders than all of the US's military campaigns (and espionage) since WW2 combined. I've seen it said a lot that the "US kills more!" So I wonder if that's just a talking point the CCP is trying to disseminate to distract from their current genocide.
- ethbr0 5y agoIt's hard to exceed the Great Leap Forward's 15-30M+. Even the Soviet Union's Holodomor is calculated around 6M.
- tsimionescu 5y agoI meant the US has killed more people abroad than China has killed abroad. So, if I were a citizen of China, I have many reasons to fear the Chinese government; if I were a citizen of the USA, I would not have much reason to fear the US government. But, if I am a citizen of, say, Lebanon, I have many more reasons to fear the USA than I have to fear China. I'm much more likely to be killed by the US government than the Chinese government.
- thereddaikon 5y ago
- oxymoran 5y ago“Protect themselves from the US military”. They wouldn’t need protection but for reneging on Hong Kong, threats to Taiwan, taking over Tibet, or their Ughyur re-education camps?