4 ms·
>Often the question that should be asked is "why aren't you doing the things you know you should do?" Why is there a "should"? Is there a unique and universal
by DeathArrow 5y ago
>Often the question that should be asked is "why aren't you doing the things you know you should do?"
Why is there a "should"? Is there a unique and universal way to determine what someone should do? Given the same situation two different people can act in two different ways. Is there a rule implying that one is right and the other is wrong?
- marginalia_nu 5y agoBy this I mean acting according to your own judgement. It's not an objective should, but a subjective one. Moral incontinence is a problem most people will struggle a lot more with than convoluted scenarios involving trolleys.
- solveit 5y agoNothing of the sort is implied. Everyone can have their own should (or not, as the case may be). But if you know you should do something, presumably you're past such useless philosophising. I know I should be nicer to the people I love, and > Why is there a "should"? Is there a unique and universal way to determine what someone should do? Given the same situation two different people can act in two different ways. Is there a rule implying that one is right and the other is wrong? strikes me as a rather obtuse response to that.
- nefitty 5y agoIn case someone reading this thread has never encountered this stance, I sincerely hold the belief that there are objective moral truths that we can discover with our senses and intuition.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoWhat is the ends and purpose of these moral truths?
- chaoskanzlerin 5y ago...work?
- nefitty 5y agoThey're ends in themselves.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoThat is the meaning of life question that has been asked since the day the universe became conscious in the form of human kind.
- janto 5y agoFrom a game theory perspective, morality encapsulates behaviour that is viable over multiple interactions across long stretches of time.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoRight, the question is then, why should we want behaviour that is viable over multiple interactions across long stretches of time?
- nefitty 5y agoYour question is big. The answer I've landed on is little. We're just little furry wiggly wombly tubes struggling against the inevitable pressures of entropy. This is true down to the most basic molecule than can replicate. Objective moral truths stem from that. The unending dance with entropy. To be the belle of the ball, we also harness that entropic randomness and turn it into dances that are even more powerful. I feel the urge to thrive and grow and improve. I find myself sympathetic to the expressions of that drive from all life. That is a priori, that emergent empathy that many of us are capable of. I see a neighbor crying, a homeless man sleeping rough, a fearful stranger, and I say to myself, "There but for the grace of God, go I." But I don't stop there, because I see my puppy, I see a bird in the sky, I see a crushed mollusk, a writhing worm, "There but for the grace of God, go I." We're many faces, but still, we're all dancing with the entropy. Next is the question, "Will this action increase or decrease the entropy in the universe? To the many faces, is this the action of an ally or an enemy?" Finally, we realize we could superheat everything into crystals and reduce entropy that way. The last vital factor is the synthesis of order and disorder: complexity. These are the fun dances. Art. Learning. Creation. So, to find objective moral truths, our sieve consists of The Golden Rule, "Am I fucking things up more?" and "Am I making things more awesome?"
- peoplefromibiza 5y ago> Is there a rule implying that one is right and the other is wrong? most of the time, yes! We are not living in a void, we live in societies, complex societies. with lots of rules, dos and donts, should and shouldn't.