5 ms·
For a company that demanded Flash be verboten because of the constant security threat, that's a whole lotta arbitrary code execution in webkit. Hey guys, you ca
by noduerme 5y ago
For a company that demanded Flash be verboten because of the constant security threat, that's a whole lotta arbitrary code execution in webkit. Hey guys, you can't run this VM in our browser. Tell you what, let's just make our browser do everything it does. We won't run into any problems, I mean, everything's sandboxed right?
- GhettoComputers 5y agoWhy doesn't this work, does their sandbox suck? Qubes os seems to do it fine.
- my123 5y agoQubes uses a VM (without GPU acceleration in most scenarios) as the isolation boundary. That has performance and usability downsides… The sandbox keeps being tightened each release.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoVM performance is excellent, and has been so for about a decade, heres a recent thread with VFIO for GPU passthrough and VM (basically performance difference is negligible). https://old.reddit.com/r/VFIO/comments/n3mjj3/native_vs_vm_benchmarks_using_passthrough_for_gpu/ https://old.reddit.com/r/VFIO/comments/n3mjj3/native_vs_vm_b...
- my123 5y ago> GPU passthrough That’s just not an option for a regular phone or laptop, which is most of Apple’s market. Don’t forget about the RAM pressure too.
- GhettoComputers 5y ago>That’s just not an option for a regular phone or laptop, which is most of Apple’s market. Lots of Macs have more than one video card. I disagree, I mentioned it since they make their own silicon, and can do virtual GPU, memory management for the browser would be an issue, but Apple doesn't care, they just use swap on the SSD and it would still be cool to have that as an option for single tabs. All web browsing is just a huge amount of javascript virtual machines, and they have custom hardware to run it faster, they might do it via hardware, all their sandboxing is just OS based, TouchID ran its own OS and took years to crack, and needs hardware tools to do so.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pram 5y agoFlash ran in Safari on MacOS until 2020.
- noduerme 5y agoSure. But it was dead by then. Apple led the charge to kill it, and the main argument given was that Flash was susceptible to past, present and future use-after-free attacks, like the Java VM or anything else that ran as a black box and managed its own memory. And now we're close to square one on that, which is a natural result of people wanting functionality in-browser that mirrors a desktop experience, including APIs that reach out beyond the sandbox. From Apple's point of view, Safari itself is probably one of their biggest liabilities. If they could eliminate browsing the open web completely, that would solve all these problems (except, obviously, whatever they miss in app store review).
- aspyct 5y agoFlash was a nightmare on mobile and made pretty much half of the internet unusable on a smartphone (yes, half. Remember those menus in flash?). It was also indeed full of security flaws that Adobe was suuuper slow to patch, if at all. Eye candy was their priority, not the web's wellbeing.
- GhettoComputers 5y ago>Eye candy was their priority, not the web's wellbeing. It was very easy to make stuff on it it was developer and artist friendly (still has lots of cool stuff that doesn't exist), it was a standard, but performance wise it sucked, and I would find it interesting for you to tell me what "web wellbeing" is. I would say that any analytics, advertising, and (my most controversial opinion) javascript is bad for web wellbeing. Every issue you leveraged against flash is the same with javascript.
- aspyct 5y agoI didn't say we're making good use of javascript either...