3 ms·
“ A given curbside-dining setup might make gaining access to a nearby building a bit harder for the fire department than it would be if a car or SUV were parked
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
“ A given curbside-dining setup might make gaining access to a nearby building a bit harder for the fire department than it would be if a car or SUV were parked in the same spot. “
Imagine thinking this with a straight face.
How could it be harder to move civilians and a wooden plank compared to a locked SUV? Aha
- starkd 5y agoFrankly, I'm more alarmed about the "alfresco dining". Who really wants to eat in the nude ???
- dang 5y agoPlease don't do this here.
- BostonEnginerd 5y agoTo be fair, many of the outdoor eating spaces are 8-10ft wide, 20+ feet long and have substantial structure like roofs. An SUV is probably be easier to tow out of the way.
- wolverine876 5y ago> How could it be harder to move civilians and a wooden plank compared to a locked SUV? A lot of outdoor dining is much larger and more obstructive than a wooden plank. I see entire structures, planters, electrical power, heat lamps and fire 'pits', etc. > Imagine thinking this with a straight face. If we approach unfamiliar ideas curiously, we can imagine part of factual reality that is outside our conceptions: people know things we don't and have legitimate motives we haven't considered. I know almost nothing about outdoor dining; it would be interesting to hear from a restauranteur and city planner.
- JamesBarney 5y agoQuestion. We've now had outdoor dining for the past year. What do you think the chances are that this regulation significantly moved the amount of fire damage or number of fire related deaths that occurred?
- wolverine876 5y agoI strongly disagree that we can guess without expertise. I'm not even sure the sample size is big enough: We could eliminate fire regulations in skyscrapers, and probably, over a year, it would cause no damage. Fire regulations are catastrophe insurance.
- JamesBarney 5y agoHow much do you think it changes the risk of death? Last year ~800 ppl died of fire in commercial buildings. What would that number have been if outdoor dining was allowed everything?
- ineedasername 5y agoThere are more issues caused by fires thann just deaths. Non lethal injuries come to mind, along with lost livelihoods and other economic damage. And there's more than just fires to think about. You're choosing one narrow slice of potential consequences and presenting your opinion on that basis. I'm not even sure I disagree with you, but it's hard to tell because you're coming at the issue in this way.
- wolverine876 5y agoSo using the fire code, ~800 people died last year (where? what data?). What is your argument for not using it?
- ineedasername 5y agoNo data from this year can be considered representantive of what the actual trend would look like under normal circumstances. Not least of why is that none of these new structure have had much time to age and wear out to the point of causing structural issues. You might be right and there's little or no safety issues to worry about, but the data needed to assess that opinion doesn't exist yet.
- wolverine876 5y ago
- netizen-936824 5y ago>If we approach unfamiliar ideas curiously, we can imagine part of factual reality that is outside our conceptions: people know things we don't and have legitimate motives we haven't considered. This is an extremely healthy mindset, I'm glad to see it here. I only hope this way of thinking can spread.
- thereisnospork 5y ago>If we approach unfamiliar ideas curiously, we can imagine part of factual reality that is outside our conceptions: people know things we don't and have legitimate motives we haven't considered. I know almost nothing about outdoor dining; it would be interesting to hear from a restauranteur and city planner. He has a point though: treating every idea 'curiously' will kill an endevour by a thousand cuts.[0] To the point, attempting to apply these standards retrospectively would result in a very different and much worse current day. For starters most of San Francisco would still be part of the bay. I can't even imagine the horror and outrage at proposing to fill in the bay to increase the footprint of downtown? And yet considering we aren't chomping at the bit to return SF to nature I can't help feel society has decided it was the right thing to do. [0]How does outdoor dining affect the patterns of migratory birds? Better fund a study. For each restaurant, so the individual facts. Are you a 'bird advocate' who thinks the aforementioned study was a sham? Sharpen your legal pencils because the state is very interested to hear and debate your case. I really wish this sort of thing was hyperbole.
- wolverine876 5y ago> He has a point though: treating every idea 'curiously' will kill an endevour by a thousand cuts. That is a strawperson, and not related to curiosity. Curiosity is what I described above (at least by my definition). I don't see what that has to do with your examples. > To the point, attempting to apply these standards retrospectively would result in a very different and much worse current day. For starters most of San Francisco would still be part of the bay. What standards are we applying retrospectively? Outdoor dining rules would cause SF to remain part of the bay? > [0]How does outdoor dining affect the patterns of migratory birds? Better fund a study. For each restaurant, so the individual facts. Are you a 'bird advocate' who thinks the aforementioned study was a sham? Sharpen your legal pencils because the state is very interested to hear and debate your case. / I really wish this sort of thing was hyperbole. Can you provide actual evidence of it happening in reality?
- thereisnospork 5y ago'Curiosity' is so often a dog whistle for BANANA. Apologies if you didn't intend it that way. But so often the 'lets explore the possibility of this' and 'lets study that' questions are weaponized -- There's always a reasonable sounding additional thing. That it takes months, and that there are even serious discussions and hand-wringing over something so simple as putting a few tables outside is itself absurd[0]. Heck, if the pandemic hadn't happened, would we even be able to have this conversation about possibly putting tables on sidewalks in SF(like is done in much of the civilized world)? or would there be too many things to be 'curious' about to (s) chance such a drastic social upheaval.(/s) The hypocrisy[1] of the current status quo is that we live in the benefit of decisions made in a far more carefree manner that would never pass muster today (e.g. filling in the SF bay.) >https://missionlocal.org/2018/06/the-strange-and-terrible-saga-of-san-franciscos-historic-laundromat-represents-the-worst-of-planning-and-development-in-this-town/ https://missionlocal.org/2018/06/the-strange-and-terrible-sa... [0]The endemic absurdity which makes it expensive to build, and by extension live in CA and the Bay Area. [1]Never mind anti-pragmatism. Landromat -> apartment, except it casts shadows on a school playground after school hours. >https://sfplanning.org/standards-bird-safe-buildings https://sfplanning.org/standards-bird-safe-buildings 'bird-safe building requirements >http://www2.oaklandnet.com/oakca1/groups/ceda/documents/webcontent/oak035749.pdf http://www2.oaklandnet.com/oakca1/groups/ceda/documents/webc... Some permitting requirements including treatment for migratory birds. I expect you can find some news of delays over lawsuits from environmental groups over things easily
- egh 5y agoHave you seen a car? Have you seen a parklet? If you had, you would understand perfectly well.
- jjulius 5y ago>How could it be harder to move civilians and a wooden plank compared to a locked SUV? Aha One is a locked SUV whose windows are designed to be broken easily and safely in case of emergencies, pop into neutral and push out of the way sort of quickly (depending on whether or not there's even enough time to do that, but I digress). This SUV has wheels whose direction you can adjust in order to to help maneuver the vehicle easily. The other is a structure often built considerably longer than even a few SUV lengths, weighed down so that guests and weather don't move it, and made out of material that is considerably less easy to break through in an emergency situation than the aforementioned tempered/laminated safety glass. Said structures may even contain even more hazards - eg, gas-powered heat lamps - than you would find in a traditional parking space. This structure is bulky and doesn't have wheels to help change the direction you want to move it in. >Imagine thinking this with a straight face. The irony...
- kevin_thibedeau 5y ago> pop into neutral Not doable in most modern cars without the key.
- handrous 5y agoReally? That's a development I wasn't aware of. I'd also assumed that was the easy answer to "it's an actual emergency and we need to move this SUV". They really lock the car from shifting into neutral without a key? [EDIT] The more I think about this the more it bothers me. Being able to shift even if the car is partially disabled—including, quite possibly, whatever's responsible for reading a modern electronic key—is really important for safety, and also for generally dealing with a disabled car after it's come to a stop, which can also be safety-related if you're trying to, say, get it off a busy highway. Especially being able to get into neutral. That there's any possible way that failures in not-strictly-necessary-for-shifting systems could block that seems crazy to me.
- jjulius 5y agoThey're not wrong, but they're also not entirely correct. Many vehicles have a panel beneath the wheel that has a release inside it for such a situation. It's just not easy/convenient. But playing devil's advocate, assuming that no modern car can be popped into neutral without a key, a car is still much more favorable than many parklets. You can easily break the glass to run firehouses through, or you can more easily run the hose over/under/around it because it's a smaller object than an outdoor dining space. Emergency crews can run between parked cars, but there often aren't any such opportunities in a 16-foot parklet.
- tqi 5y agoSee for yourself: https://sf.eater.com/2021/7/27/22595233/best-parklets-san-francisco https://sf.eater.com/2021/7/27/22595233/best-parklets-san-fr...
- logosmonkey 5y agoHuh, I wasn't aware these were even a thing. While many of them seem quite reasonable a few seem rather intrusive on the public space. The Palette one specifically makes me feel uncomfortable just looking at it, I feel like if I were walking down that sidewalk I would feel as though I were entering a private space.
- somewhereoutth 5y agoOf course this would be less of a problem if a) buildings weren't made of wood, and b) people didn't keep setting fire to them. (Source: SF resident for a few years - someone even burnt down my hardware store! As I was going there for a screwdriver!)
- kamray23 5y agoReally a big problem in Finland. Imagine having 6 centuries worth of churches slowly disappearing beacuse "church burning" seems to have become a common holiday activity.
- dang 5y agoCan you please review the site guidelines and stick to the rules when posting here? We'd appreciate it. Note these ones: "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith." "Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work." "Eschew flamebait." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mensetmanusman 5y agoSorry about that! Should have used more clear language :)
- 908B64B197 5y ago> Imagine thinking this with a straight face. I'm actually curious what the fire department itself has to say about it. Typically, they are the ones carrying fire code inspections.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoI wonder if they differ in opinion with the fire departments in the other cities where this isn’t an issue?
- 908B64B197 5y agoWhat I suspect is that the bureaucrats use fire safety as an excuse to justify their work; if a structure really is dangerous for fire safety the owner will get a visit from the fire department rather quickly as soon as they notice it.
- standardUser 5y agoThe incredible density of patios in Manhattan leads me to agree that this argument is nonsense.