3 ms·
> Wind and Solar production are literally free though .. but the capex of your electrolysis plant isn't, and a giant pile of platinum electrodes that only get
by pjc50 5y ago
> Wind and Solar production are literally free though
.. but the capex of your electrolysis plant isn't, and a giant pile of platinum electrodes that only get used once a day isn't a great deal.
Fundamentally batteries and electrolysis are the same category of reaction - electrically driven redox. So you have three options:
- ions plate out as a solid on one of the electrodes ("battery"), or possibly a hot liquid (aluminium, molten salt batteries)
- change the ionization state of some liquid (flow batteries, e.g. vanadium chemistry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vanadium_redox_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vanadium_redox_battery )
- ions come off as a gas (hydrogen, but also e.g. chlorine if you electrolize salt water)
From there you have all sorts of detailed issues like "does this destroy the electrodes" and "is this annoying and/or dangerous to handle". I do wonder if someone should do a John D Clarke and just try all the most common ionic liquids.
- dragontamer 5y ago> From there you have all sorts of detailed issues like "does this destroy the electrodes" and "is this annoying and/or dangerous to handle". I do wonder if someone should do a John D Clarke and just try all the most common ionic liquids. Or we can build a bunch of different options and then see what works out 10 years from now? Like, we all know that Li-ion electrolyte is incredibly flammable, and that electricity serves as an incredibly good and efficient spark source. But we're building them out anyway to see how it works out in practice. https://www.technowize.com/fire-at-tesla-battery-site-in-australia-raises-concern-over-lithium-risk/ https://www.technowize.com/fire-at-tesla-battery-site-in-aus... Well, for one way or the other, it looks like we've accepted the fire risk. So "X might catch on fire" isn't exactly a strong argument to me anymore.
- pjc50 5y agoI don't mean the top two options - lithium vs hydrogen - I mean the top thousand options. Edison's nickel-iron never went away, for example; available all over the earth, never going to run out of them, not very flammable, just too dense for mobile usage. But not important for static installations. (A hybrid usage! A battery and an electrolyser? Of course most batteries with a water chemistry evolve some H2. https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20210223-the-battery-invented-120-years-too-soon https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20210223-the-battery-inve... ) I'd like to see the "we tried all the top 100 easiest positive ions with all the easiest 100 negative ions and here's how they work as battery chemistries."
- dragontamer 5y agoI think that is fair and I am largely of that opinion as well. I think redox flow is probably my favorite chemistry btw, and I'd like to see more redox flow experiments / test deployments. Gravity storage is my next favorite. Hydrogen doesn't even make top 3 for me as far as techs, but I'm open to it and have heard the arguments for it. I'm largely convinced H2 is a good idea that could work.
- ephbit 5y ago> .. but the capex of your electrolysis plant isn't, and a giant pile of platinum electrodes that only get used once a day isn't a great deal. Maybe there needs to be a shift of paradigm for the electrical grid? From: we need to use this renewable electricity when there's a huge surplus to generate hydrogen/methanol/... to store the energy for periods without sun & wind Towards: we just power the electrolyzers at full capacity full time (generating surpluses of chemically stored energy that is available long-term for longer periods without sun & wind). Even if it means, that in periods without sun & wind (when electricity demand and price is already high) more gas plants need to be turned on. Seems counterintuitive, yes ... but if the economic benefit of running the electrolyzers with a profit exceeds the economic downside of spending more on CO2 equivalent certificates ... it might be reasonable.