3 ms·
> Because there are competing storage solutions and the question is if hydrogen is actually "sensible here? So build the competing storage solution. Except yo
by dragontamer 5y ago
> Because there are competing storage solutions and the question is if hydrogen is actually "sensible here?
So build the competing storage solution.
Except you can't. Because we all know that Li-ion is a dirty mineral to mine and extract, and that worldwide production of it is incredibly limited. And you know it.
So to meet our needs of expanding energy storage, the use of steel and concrete to store hydrogen is more scalable and cheaper to build out.
> I'm mostly pointing out that hydrogen is (currently at least) a very inefficient method of storage, on top of being an actively dangerous and problematic one.
And I'm pointing out that Li-ion is effectively impossible with our current means of production. So there's no point arguing for it as its being deployed as quickly as humanly possible.
--------
Li-ion is growing too slowly as an industry. Its not going to work, and expansion is going to be incredibly dirty. The critical components of Li-ion are quite dirty (Cobalt, Li-ion, etc. etc.), especially compared to steel and concrete.
- ben_w 5y agoI have no reason to believe battery production is limited by anything other than (1) demand and (2) the time required to build the battery factories; growth in production looks like it might be in the exponential part of a sigmoid right now. This isn’t to say lithium is the last word in storage (I’d be surprised and disappointed if it was), but I don’t think you should be claiming it can’t solve our problems. My personal preference is an antipodal power grid, which works out much cheaper if considered in isolation, but: (1) even with the political will that will take an annoyingly long to mine the resources for, and (2) mobile storage needs outweigh static needs by so much that (in the long term) a power grid can be stabilised by the batteries the car industry is waiting to recycle into new batteries.