7 ms·
I am in favour of the term “Web4” to describe small, local, personal, private...
- dewiz 5y agoif anything I could agree with, the next web should adopt semver /s
- sergioisidoro 5y agoBut everyone knows you should always be backwards compatible and never go over main version 0. So we should be using Web0.1, Web0.2, etc. /s
- jazzyjackson 5y agoSo, Pied Piper? (In all seriousness the hyperdrives/hypercore protocol is very cool and I intend to try building my next web-builder on top of it. The OP writes it off too quickly: hypercore is append-only, but hyperdrives are more like bittorrent sync, which I'm very sad never took off, it worked perfectly for syncing large files between peers on a local wifi network, when google drive and dropbox were failing us)
- pmlnr 5y agoIt did take off. See Syncthing: https://syncthing.net/ https://syncthing.net/
- jazzyjackson 5y agoOh that's fantastic news, it's been at least 4 years since I looked for it, all I knew was that the bittorrent name got sold off and turned into some token.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoare distributed hash tables / magnet links and torrents counted as "cryptographic" ?
- Traubenfuchs 5y agopsssst, we don't talk about the torrent protocol anymore, it's either blockchain or go home
- selfhoster11 5y agoHashes are cryptography, so I say yes.
- dredmorbius 5y agoSome hashes are. There are non-cryptographic hashing functions. https://dadario.com.br/cryptographic-and-non-cryptographic-hash-functions/ https://dadario.com.br/cryptographic-and-non-cryptographic-h...
- selfhoster11 5y agoRight, I forgot about those. Good catch.
- yessirwhatever 5y ago[flagged]
- pmlnr 5y agoHow about no buzzwords, and instead, we just do things? Like https://indieweb.org https://indieweb.org ?
- rapnie 5y agoYou have buzzwords, and you have intuitively naming things to indicate they fall within the same category, especially when the name needs to communicate and inspire a particular vision. We need the latter, and while I really like indieweb, that doesn't cover it.
- selfhoster11 5y agoBuzzwords rally outsiders under our own banner. If it gets a useful change going, I'm happy to go with Web4. Besides, going with Web3+1 as the chosen name helps emphasize our belief: that Web4 will be an improvement over the current latest and greatest Web3.
- dredmorbius 5y agoPremptively claiming the namespace has certain advantages. Not that this is bulletproof, naturally: meme, crypto, hacker, ...
- axegon_ 5y agoThat might as well be web3 from where I'm sitting: web3 is trying to solve a problem most people don't have: they don't care about privacy or leaks even when they happen. Those of us lurking on HN maybe, but to everyone else this is a completely normal phenomenon, the same way the sun rises from the east.
- selfhoster11 5y agoWeb3 is a co-opted term, much like cryptobros co-opted the term "crypto" from the cryptography community. We need to choose a different term, and Web4 is not a bad one.
- axegon_ 5y agoI'm aware. What I'm trying to say is that neither 3 or 4 will become mainstream and will only become a party house for a few wildly optimistic and wildly diluted individuals, that is the evangelists and those believing that this will be the next big thing and will make them billionaires because they were the early adopters. We've seen that way too many times already.
- dredmorbius 5y agoWhat you're witnessing, and participating in, is the epistemic and rhetorical battle over that future.
- selfhoster11 5y agoI'm lending my own support to the term "Web4". I want to see this future happen, and something had to compete with "Web3" semantically. I might as well help.
- unixhero 5y agoSo selfhosting becomes web4? Damn every nerd hobby I've had, has always become mainstream. Ever since gaming on MSDOS and Amiga machines. Then MP3 files, Then IRC / Online Communities, then ... ... The list goes on. By the way /r/selfhosted and /r/homelab says hi
- aaaaaaaaaaab 5y agoOk, but can I scam people with it?
- fredley 5y agoThis is Web1, if anything.
- selfhoster11 5y agoWeb 1 was a fragile thing. The Information Superhighway is much more hostile these days, so we need nimble tanks (aka Web4) rather than cars with extra plate armour (Web1.0 with patches).
- Chris2048 5y agoBut on the other hand, how do we trust the developers of these protocols? I'm not really convinced by the "many eyes" argument since openssh vuln.
- bidder33 5y agohere is an example of where web3 would be good. in web2 your handle gets confiscated, in web3 you own it and have the keys https://twitter.com/nytimes/status/1470362934496923650 https://twitter.com/nytimes/status/1470362934496923650
- unbanned 5y agoI just call it my penis
- gvv 5y agoStopped reading at "far right money laundering"
- 3pt14159 5y agoThe thing that's funny about web3 is that it's going to absolutely turn into celebrities shilling to the rich. They've always done that, but now it's going to be extra cringy because it's going to be so blatant. The reason it's going to be shilling and not, you know, someone buying artwork that they care about is because data on computers is trivially copyable and, deep down, nobody cares about a photo or a song when it's just signed data. Even print photography is several orders of magnitude cheaper than painted art. So, ultimately, it's going to be a game of access peddling. And when people see that, the market will more or less collapse outside of possibly some minor edge cases where it really does work[0] and even if I'm not interested it, I'm semi-bullish on them at least in the medium term. [0] Games are the one place where scarcity makes sense. Strong, defined brands from companies with a history of not flooding the market or abandoning a product line could make out huge. Think Magic: The Gathering. Or the Star Wars universe and most players are not Jedi. Or Lord of the Rings and it's some extremely beautiful and intricate dwarven battle axe. The NFT makes it possible to move from rendition of a game to rendition. I'm not sure about the long term (~100+ years) here though.
- taurusnoises 5y agoYeah, wherever Naval goes or the alt-right, crypto, boys go is where I don't wanna go. Maybe that's just gonna have to be the un-Web....
- peanut_worm 5y agohow about we call it the internet and stop trying to confuse media outlets
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Kivutar 5y agoIt's the first time I read something this ridiculous on HN.
- vaylian 5y agoSometimes you got to fight absurdity with absurdity. May the flying spaghettimonster bless you with its noodly appendage.
- jazzyjackson 5y agothe append-only age
- grouphugs 5y agothis is a nazi, kill him
- blueflow 5y ago"far right money-laundering" ... what? Is this a new conspiracy theory I'm not aware of?
- brodo 5y agoDavid Golumbia has written a book called “The Politics of Bitcoin - Software as Right-Wing Extremism” which goes into the connection between cryptocurrency and far-right ideology. Here is an interview with him: https://overcast.fm/+ZpQA7ciS0 https://overcast.fm/+ZpQA7ciS0
- sol_invictus 5y agoAny US personnel dependent on the academic system writing about anything remotely political or social sciences related (i.e. anything mathematically unverifiable) cannot be trusted as any kind of authority (in the current era). The rabid left-wing student organizations will destroy their livelihood on the smallest whim if their stance is "wrong".
- Yizahi 5y agoThere was some recent news article about this. I think it is not unreasonable take, because obviously crypto is safer to use for fringe groups than Visa or Paypal. But I agree the wording is way too hysterical, that is a bad sign.
- samhw 5y agoI mean, 'money laundering' is a very different thing from 'using a different payment protocol because you've been banned from conventional ones'. I'm not at all right-wing, but it sets a dangerous precedent to establish 'acceptable' payment protocols run by the dominant monopolies, then ban people whom you don't like, and baselessly accuse them of 'money laundering' when they (obviously) go somewhere else.
- blueflow 5y agoI'm not from the anglosphere. Google does not spit out anything useful to me. What did happen? I still don't know what you are talking about.
- Yizahi 5y agoWeb4 is anything shorter than 500 symbols, structured in the unreadable mess of incomplete texts, without beginning or end.
- can16358p 5y agoSo, without financial or similar incentives given to people who host it, how does anyone expect a non-financial model work? Maybe that "proof of waste" is solving a real problem (though I'd also favor for a more environmentally friendly consensus algorithm)
- pornel 5y agoThe models we currently have: • p2p (like bittorrent) which shifts bandwidth costs to recipients. • Too cheap to care. For simple things like a blog, cost of hosting asymptotically approaches zero. • Subsidized by other business. Think why HN is free.
- selfhoster11 5y agoThe solution is to create a federated network of installations each serving a small community. Be it that this community is a school, a business, a family, or a group of 20 friends who all play on the same Minecraft server. They will want to run a community just for the sheer joy (or coordination benefits) of it, as long as we make it inexpensive to run and possible to operate by a power user rather than requiring an IT expert.
- ReleaseCandidat 5y agoThat's the easy part. In a peer-to-peer network every participant hosts content from others.
- can16358p 5y agoTechnically it's solved. Socially/economically, without incentives is hard to scale for it to be practically usable for the masses.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoVolunteer run organizations are way more fun and high quality than anything commercial. They of course do not scale, but therein lies the charm.
- 5y ago
- mypastself 5y agoI know HN commenters can sometimes get a little too vitriolic about crypto, but this parody (including takes like “built by the same literal fascists who tried to do a coup”) is too much.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- skytreader 5y agoI don't care much for this "Web4" proposal (yet) but can we get our terminologies unified? AFAIK Web 2.0 is the era of user-generated content[1] and, IMO, was the most vibrant era of the internet. That's my "good old days" though I've witnessed the tail end of 1. Even if you're not at all a fan of that Web 2.0 era, what's with the overly-cynical characterization here? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_2.0 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_2.0 (and oh look, apparently Sir Tim Berners-Lee has also already defined what Web 3.0 is).
- selfhoster11 5y agoWeb 2.0 to me means the era when everything got centralised under a few social media providers. The early 2.0 era was definitely just 1.0 with additional collaborative/sharing energy injected into the system, but by the time we got halfway through, it become obvious that the walled gardens are encroaching on traditional 1.0 space and that Google has abandoned the "don't be evil" motto (which I took to be the bellwether of the changes to come).
- WastingMyTime89 5y agoWeb 2.0 was a loosely defined marketing term which was already extremely controversial when it was coined to promote conferences. Web 3.0 is even more loosely defined. These terms are purposefully devoid of substance so as to be applicable to as many things as possible. It’s probably going to be hard to get a unified understanding of what they mean.
- kreeben 5y agoBut these version numbers sure make us feel we're progressing towards something more refined, something that will soon cater to all of humanity's needs as opposed to just becoming better at tracking people, polarizing them and creating wealth for FAANG's and their mother.
- nixpulvis 5y agomy take fwiw: https://nixpulvis.com/ramblings/2018-08-11-web-shit-point-oh https://nixpulvis.com/ramblings/2018-08-11-web-shit-point-oh
- antihero 5y agoI know not what weapons world wide web 3 will be bought with, but world wide web 4 will be fought with sticks and stones.
- kamray23 5y agoweb4, also known as web1.0 in the past.
- selfhoster11 5y agoThere is a marked difference. Web 1.0 was still a very small community, and the importance of moderation and decentralisation was seen as lower. If we want to stay alive against megacorps and not get ripped apart from the inside while still facilitating large numbers of users, it helps to design these priorities in from the beginning. On a more technical level, Web1.0 was not as optionally capable as Web4 may be. Crypto strength vs TLS vs no encryption, rich documents vs Markdown vs no formatting, persistence vs not, these are all the choices we can make now. Whereas in Web1.0 you had to be ascetic, and in Web2.x you had to be resplendent, in Web4 you can choose your own adventure.
- bidder33 5y agowould love to see some concrete examples. because we tried building open networks and they get sybil attacked or spammed, and introducing a token to add cost to the transactions on p2p networks did seem to help their security. People dont seem to like the social aspects of that tokenisation, so whats the suggestion? Whats the next step? Is the future you see more like spotify or more like funkwhale or more like audius? How are you delivering it to the general population? How can we contribute? Those of us working in the web3/crypto space are interested in the same values as the poster has: local, personal, private, self owned, p2p, permissionless. We are looking for ways to work on those things and provide infrastructure for others to build on. It is increasingly clear that lots of people don't like the money/token/asset ideas of the crypto theyve seen. So do we just give up hacking on money? because i remember it was the deep distrust in existing money systems was why this all took off in the first place. Or is money just something sacred we aren't allowed to play with? is it morally wrong? Why is it that pictures of the Queen in my wallet on pieces of paper somehow the best form of money? wouldnt you rather trade pictures of dogs in space? One of those is way more fun and doesnt bow down to a culture of inherited power. Or is it just the mass speculation, and mania in the public which you dont like?(fuelled by abusive relationships with money and desperation to escape everyday life, which seems a bigger problem than crypto tbh). Is that because you are worried about the impact it has on the vulnerable? Could we try explore efforts in speculation-resistant currencies and trust networks like https://joincircles.net https://joincircles.net And one point id highlight is that efficiency is often over prioritised, and resilience is more important to the survival of a network. Hosting private local nodes will never be as efficient as datacenters, so is efficiency really your priority? If everyone used Mastodon would that be as efficient as Twitter? Make the system strong and resilient, then as efficient as possible given the first constraint. First you make something that can survive, then optimise it.
- xaduha 5y agoI'm all for rolling release Web. Looking for technological solutions to societal problems will lead nowhere.
- kristianpaul 5y agoWait, isn't that just called Self-hosted?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- meheleventyone 5y agoI'd say the difference could be primarily about ownership of your data and identity. So when you go to someone elses website you bring your data with you, auth through your own keys rather than them storing it for you. Think localStorage but hostable and shareable with granular permissions to data or WebAuthn but usable by normal people. There'd definitely be a bunch of companies helping the less technically inclined but the point is to make that a choice you can change as opposed to having all your life locked into three behemoths.