5 ms·
Étoilé on Gnustep
- rbanffy 5y agoIt's fun to think that the NeXT ideas won in the end. OPENSTEP is now one of the leading desktop and mobile OSs and all it took for it to take off was a facelift and Apple's brand. That, and being renamed OSX. If we want an OS that can build on top of NeXT's legacy, macOS is the OS to track. Has anyone done some research on what parts of what SomethingKits would need to be implemented to be able to compile and run as much macOS open-source software currently in, say, GitHub?
- pjmlp 5y agoI wouldn't call 10% of market share leading desktop. And for iOS, there is very little NeXTSTEP on it, at least from the point of view of how OS components interacted with each other, it goes beyond of just using Objective-C frameworks. There is very little of Web Objects, Distributed Objects, Driver Kit, Plugins,... on iOS.
- soraminazuki 5y agoI think it's fair to call a 2nd ranking Desktop OS a leading desktop. > For desktop and laptop computers, Windows is the most used at 75%, followed by Apple's macOS at 16%, and Linux-based operating systems, including Google's Chrome OS, at 5% (thereof "desktop Linux" at 2.35%). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_syste...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- SeanLuke 5y agoNeXTSTEP was beautiful, clean, and elegant. How is it that the Gnustep pseudo-copies, such as Etoile, can be so ugly and inconsistent? Everything from nasty font choices to the inconsistent and weird spacing between widgets to the weird mishmash of UI styles. You'd think that the entire selling point (so to speak) of software like this is that it retains the elegance of NeXTSTEP, but no. For maybe two decades I'd argued that the fundamental problem with open source UIs is that there is no hegemon, no dictator who forces everyone to be consistent and to have good taste. Witness the incredible proliferation of awful X11 interface designs, window managers, toolkits, and platforms, and the still astonishing primitiveness and lack of proper interaction and interconnectivity between X applications. Instead you have a thousand flowers blooming, all nurtured by homebrew software developers who have no idea what they're doing designwise. NeXTSTEP, and of course MacOS, have had dictators and designers, and it shows. And when there is some powerful force in effect to keep everyone in line, open source UI software can more or less have this quality: witness Android under Google's, um, guidance. But Etoile is a great example, I think, of the no-hegemon effect. Even though they had a TEMPLATE of design elegance (NeXTSTEP), they still managed to make a failure of a UI product.
- schmorptron 5y agowanted to disagree, but then noticed that the open source Desktops I think look good all sort of operate under that umbrella, like Gnome and elementary all have very strict design guidelines.
- quadrifoliate 5y agoI think another problem is that there's no way, as far as I know, to disallow an app that doesn't stick to those guidelines. I mean, maybe the Gnome default applications can strictly stick to those, but what how do you ensure that third-party apps stick to the guidelines? Apple seems to have solved this with a combination of big community of enthusiasts and an App Store for macOS, and just the App Store for iOS. A major fear of Apple developers seems to be the prospect of their App being removed from the App Store for unclear reasons. It's hard to imagine a model where apps can remain FOSS but have the same sort of strict design guidelines.
- jfvinueza 5y agotaste is undervalued
- elinchrome 5y agoLooks really nice!
- pipeline_peak 5y agoI always found Etoile very attractive, but it is long dead. If you check the sites news page, the latest post is from 2014…..
- forlorn 5y agoNot 'dead' dead according to Github activity https://github.com/etoile/ https://github.com/etoile/
- batman-farts 5y agoDoes David Chisnall hang out around here? I remember reading some of the stuff he was publishing around the time Étoilé was active, and their ambitions for the polyglot LanguageKit and associated Smalltalk dialect seemed especially attractive. Somewhat similar to what GraalVM is doing these days.
- pjmlp 5y agoDavid Chisnall nowadays is busy with the CHERI project. https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/research/security/ctsrd/cheri/ https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/research/security/ctsrd/cheri/
- laurent123456 5y agoIt's surprising they emphasize that it's beautiful in the page title, when it's really anything but beautiful. Even the alignment of buttons and text seems random, and the dock bar looks quite ugly.
- badsectoracula 5y agoTake a look at the date at the bottom right in the main screenshot[0]. For 2008 the style was quite good looking, though it had some issues, most likely since GNUstep didn't had theme support until they implemented it and like Etoile itself, it was never finished. It is possible that these were fixed later but... even in screenshots with GNUstep themes i see small glitches here and there. NesedahRik[1], which is based on Etoile's theme, does seem to have the least issues though. But if i was to use such a setup, i'd try my best to fix that icon alignment at the top left corner and add some space between it and the menu text :-P. [0] http://etoileos.com/uploads/screenshots/etoile-0.4-about-vs-melodie.png http://etoileos.com/uploads/screenshots/etoile-0.4-about-vs-... [1] https://github.com/gnustep/plugins-themes-nesedahrik https://github.com/gnustep/plugins-themes-nesedahrik
- cxr 5y ago> For 2008 the style was quite good looking Not really. It doesn't look good now, and it didn’t look good then. It's just not good-looking. For comparison, Leopard/Snow Leopard looked good in 2008, and it looks good now: <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Leopard_Desktop.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Leopard_Desktop.png> Among the things that I find really surprising in the computing industry is that everyone doesn't make things easy for themselves and agree to just rip off Cocoa. On the one hand, we hear every time that Electron or the Windows/.NET UI framework discussions come up that developers have no good choices for doing cross-platform UIs. Meanwhile, Cocoa's API is no more or less protected than the ones that Sun/Oracle went to war over. It's also extremely mature. So make it easy and just rip off Cocoa already. On the other hand, Apple have moved to flat, mobile-like UI. There's hardly a case to be upset, then, if someone were to show up with a lookalike of the old, decrepit Mac OS visual style—something like Aristo <https://www.cappuccino.dev/aristo/ https://www.cappuccino.dev/aristo/>. So make it easy and just rip off Cocoa already.
- jayp1418 5y agoBetter to look at https://hellosystem.github.io/docs/ https://hellosystem.github.io/docs/ Now as Etoile is not active last i checked
- linguae 5y agoThe key differences between helloSystem and Étoilé are their philosophies and underpinnings. My understanding of helloSystem is that it's primary concerns are ease-of-use and UI consistency. It's aiming for the ease-of-use of the classic Mac OS with the UI design and polish from the Tiger era of Mac OS X. I haven't tried it yet, but I've been keeping up with its progress and it looks very nice. helloSystem is not based on GNUstep or any other Apple-inspired APIs, however. Rather, it uses Qt as its GUI toolkit. Étoilé was an attempt to bring a refreshed desktop experience that is based on GNUstep yet isn't a reimplementation of the NEXTSTEP or Mac OS X user experiences (though there are heavy influences), introducing its own concepts of what makes an ideal desktop environment. In addition, Étoilé is very aware of the Xerox PARC influences of NeXT, being cognizant of the notion of NEXTSTEP being a pragmatic Smalltalk OS. With this in mind, Étoilé supports a Smalltalk dialect called Pragmatic Smalltalk, which is able to leverage Objective-C libraries and thus fully integrates with the rest of the Étoilé system, which makes it quite different from the experience of running Squeak or Pharo in a window on top of a host operating system and addresses one of the primary complaints some prospective Smalltalk programmers have about Squeak and Pharo. Pragmatic Smalltalk is built on top of Étoilé's LanguageKit, which allows for the development of dynamic programming languages that can interoperate with Objective-C. There's also an EMCAScript implementation built on top of LanguageKit. In my opinion, if Étoilé were still active, it would attract a different type of user from helloSystem. While both helloSystem and Étoilé are heavily inspired by the Mac, helloSystem is focused on recreating the Mac user experience, while Étoilé was focused on extending the NEXTSTEP/Mac OS X power user/developer experience.
- jayp1418 5y agoThanks for explaining.