3 ms·
Sure sure, but my point was really that all nitpicking aside, Open Source is everywhere. Given the opportunity, engineers everywhere will share their work with
by ajross 5y ago
Sure sure, but my point was really that all nitpicking aside, Open Source is everywhere. Given the opportunity, engineers everywhere will share their work with others and build on that shared work to do more stuff, then share it.
An argument from a frame of "Open Source only succeeded because ..." just seems obviously wrong to me. If not ITS then Unix. If not BSD then Linux. If not Mosaic then Chrome. If not gcc then clang. On and on. Opportunities for success are everywhere, nowhere is a critical path. Take any hero out of equation and there's someone else standing behind her to repeat the work.
- pjmlp 5y agoLinux only evolved beyond a hobby project, because IBM, Oracle, Compaq, Sun decided to cut down costs on their own UNIX (thus we are back again into corporations and their relation with FOSS), and yet many still have to reverse engineer hardware capabilities despite the big names involved in it. clang is the more recent example, it is becoming visible how it is lagging behind other compilers in C++20 support, not everything is landing upstream as it used to.
- DarylZero 5y agoAll of the commercial Unix vendors had as their fundamental technical goal user lock-in, while Linus had technical goal of performance + stability and maybe popularity.
- pjmlp 5y agoHad IBM and others not jumped in, it wouldn't have mattered.
- ajross 5y agoAgain, though, Linux needing that stuff[1] doesn't explain why BSD happened, which needed different stuff. clang needed other stuff still. But... they all got their stuff! It's a Jurassic Park point, really: life will find a way. Free software beat the world already, and it really strains logic to argue that that only happened because of a giant phonebook filled with special advantages for every individual piece. The much simpler theory is that it was clearly going to happen regardless. [1] In fact that's really not the way it happened anyway. Linux on whitebox PCs was dominant in the early internet world for pure cost reasons, long before any corporate names got behind it, and that leveraged it into datacenter environments where it became clear people were willing to pay real money. Red Hat's IPO was well in the past and Google had launched on custom Linux motherboards long, long before Oracle or IBM got serious about the OS.
- pjmlp 5y agoDominat where? We were all using Solaris, HP-UX and Aix boxes when real money was at play. In fact, after university during the 1990's (where we initially were on DG/UX), it was only in 2003 that I first used GNU/Linux in production as CERN was moving away from Solaris into Linux and the first alpha releases of Scientific Linux started to become available on the institut. And even there, most researchers were moving into Windows or OS X on their local workstations.