3 ms·
For a lot of people, it's not about how hard or how smart one works. It's about the support networks that kick in when you screw up or when bad luck befalls yo
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
For a lot of people, it's not about how hard or how smart one works.
It's about the support networks that kick in when you screw up or when bad luck befalls you. Lots of middle class kids (like mine) get multiple chances to try and fail. Their parents' wealth and social connections gets to work and cushions their landing, and like Silicon Valley folk, they get to try again.
The children of working class families do not have anything close to this level of support when things go wrong. They make a mistake, or just suffer some bad luck, and they are completely screwed. Yes, everyone can get up and try again, but the difficulty of doing this from zero with no support is routinely underestimated by people (like me and my kids) who've never had to do it.
- WalterBright 5y agoAll those immigrants streaming over the border with nothing manage to do it. Nobody said it was easy, but it is possible.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoYou've got data on how many southern-border-crossing immigrants make it into the US middle class? I couldn't find any. Most immigrants in the US do not "stream over the border", more are arriving from Asian countries than Latin American countries. Those that arrive by air from another country typically have more than "nothing" on arrival.
- WalterBright 5y agoSo, for example, all those news stories about DACA immigrants are fake news? "With the granting of work authorization and the imminent threat of deportation removed, DACA recipients have experienced pronounced upward mobility in their socioeconomic status." https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/research/deferred-action-childhood-arrivals-daca-overview https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/research/deferred...
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI think most people recognize that a life growing up in the USA followed by the legal right to work and live here is a fairly huge step up in socioeconomic status from where most DACA-covered folk would have been had they not come to the USA. But TFA was about socioeonomic mobility within the USA, not comparisons with Mexico, Peru or Bolivia. The success of a specific subgroup [0] of undocumented immigrants at moving upwards doesn't refute the general mobility findings cited in TFA, nor does it prove or disprove that their success is about smart work vs hard work vs adversity support. And I didn't mean to imply that neither hard nor smart work play a role in any upward social mobility, but rather that many people forget the role played by adversity support (and it's not a small role). [0] According the article you cite, DACA covers 832,881 people, which is about 11% of the total undocumented immigrant population in the US at present (and if tales about an uncontrolled wave were correct, even less).
- WalterBright 5y agoI'm not refuting the TFA. I am refuting the notion that people in American cannot move upwards. There is no group more disadvantaged than immigrants, who arrive with nothing, have no support structure, are discriminated against, and often don't even know the language. Yet they can and do succeed, as the DACA cohort shows.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoNothing in the TFA or anyone's comments (dangerously broad, I know) said that people could NOT move upwards. It said that upward mobility is significantly lower in the USA than many other western industrial democracies, and also significantly lower than most Americans think it is.