4 ms·
You're totally conflating relative and absolute wealth. Society is probably better off when the median absolute wealth increases, which will be achieved by mor
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
You're totally conflating relative and absolute wealth.
Society is probably better off when the median absolute wealth increases, which will be achieved by more people achieving higher wealth levels.
But as is becoming increasing clear (again), society is worse off when relative wealth distinctions grow (at least, if they grow too large).
If more people make it to $500k, the 5th quintile threshold will move up. That means that the gap between the bottom quintile and the top quintile will increase. We could choose to be happy that more people have made it to $500k, or we could choose to be upset that the gap between the lower 4 quintiles and the upper one has grown.
- LudwigNagasena 5y ago> But as is becoming increasing clear (again), society is worse off when relative wealth distinctions grow (at least, if they grow too large). Why is it clear?
- bawolff 5y agoEventually, if the wealth divide becomes too great and ossified, the logical thing for the poor to do is have a violent revolution (since there is no other way to advance their station in life). This sucks for basically everyone, rich or poor. I think we all have a selfish interest in making sure it doesn't come to that.
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoThis sounds like a very dishonest and bad faith argument. Would you defend a policy against immigration because it may lead to terrorism by nationalists, or would you rather try to solve the real problem? It seems that you don’t think that society is worse off as relative wealth inequality grows. Society is worse off when people who are mad for whatever reasons start to kill other people. And in any case we should note that it is not actual differences that rustle jimmies, but perceived differences.
- csallen 5y agoSure, but a big wealth divide does not imply ossification, it just means it's a longer path to get to the top. You can have a big divide and still have mobility.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoYou could have that, but the US just has a big divide and not much mobility, despite the folk tales that say we do.