7 ms·
Adventures of putting 16 GB RAM in a motherboard that doesn’t support it (2019)
- webdoodle 5y agoSomewhat related, I had an older Asus core 2 board, that would accept 16gb of ram, but would only work on 64 bit OS's. However, even with a 64 bit OS, the onboard NIC would fail to work. So I added a NIC to the PCI bus, and it also wouldn't work. I could only get a USB dongle NIC to work. Really weird, and never solved why it was doing this.
- znpy 5y agoThis post is so interesting, and someody already has archived that page: https://archive.md/p9uxC https://archive.md/p9uxC
- MayeulC 5y agoDoes someone know what's happening with these PCI mappings? Is this memory-mapped by an address decoder on the motherboard (or north/south bridge)? Or is it a hint to the OS that they should map it here? Maybe the PCI I/Os are really there, hardwired on the motherboard, but use a higher impedance, though that would be very hacky. Or maybe they're mapped from that address, and the highest bits do not count, as address decoding is only performed on the lower bits? With physical memory shadowing parts of the physical address space? Or maybe this is just virtual address space shenanigans? In that case, how does the OS figure how to talk to PCI or the RAM based on the provided mappings? I might be able to find that information by looking at the specifications and whatever ACPI docs I can find, but if someone already knows how it works, I'd really appreciate a few pointers.
- stuff4ben 5y agoI love posts like this! I remember back in the day having to cut motherboard traces on my Amiga 500 to get Fat Agnus to recognize 1MB of chip RAM. A pure BIOS/bootloader hack is far less risky!
- egberts1 5y agotoo bad that there is no Github/Gitlab or some git repository to help us peons check and test for potential overexpansion of our beloved PC motherboards.
- nayuki 5y agoI had an easier experience along these lines. The Lenovo ThinkPad X220's official technical specifications say it only supports 8 GiB of RAM. But many forum posts across the web confirm that people used 2 slots of 8 GiB = 16 GiB with no problem (e.g. https://www.reddit.com/r/thinkpad/comments/6rdra2/does_the_x220_support_max_8_gb_or_16_gb_ram/ https://www.reddit.com/r/thinkpad/comments/6rdra2/does_the_x... ). Sure enough, I tried it and it worked.
- olliej 5y agoHaha, many many years ago I had a 486 motherboard, and through lots of sailing I was able to save to afford 2 8mb simms. I plugged them in and it reporter... 12Mb :-D
- ddingus 5y agoI had a 5Mb 386 system for a while. Often, a program requiring 8Mb of RAM would work, just poorly on more than 4.
- piyh 5y agoI really appreciate writeups like this because it gives me insight into lower level systems that I previously did not know existed.
- exikyut 5y agoI'm also always looking for additional low-level understanding. What's tricky is figuring out how to pace it so it's not overwhelming. Like, my favorite thing is that circuit boards have wobbly traces on them around high-speed interfaces (RAM, PCI, etc) so all the bits in parallel signals arrive at the same time. The clock speeds are specced right up at the edges of the speed electrons can stably flow at. And this sort of thing is awesome, but like... quite a fair bit beyond the point I'm practically able to engage at. I guess I'm trying to figure out how to leap without missing anything lol :D which is impossible now I phrase it like that...
- oauea 5y ago> In order for the document to help me, I clearly needed to find the four error parameters that used to be displayed with the blue screen on older versions of Windows. Windows 10 hides all the information by default, but I discovered that it’s possible to re-enable display of the extra error information by adding an entry to your registry. It's still baffling how microsoft completely broke bluescreens by hiding any useful info.
- barrkel 5y agoThe missing contents are also in the system eventlog entry, but that presumes that you can reboot to see it.
- grishka 5y agoIt's part of the deplorable ongoing effort by the IT industry as a whole to dumb everything down as much as possible.
- userbinator 5y agoNot sure if it's "IT industry as a whole", or Microsoft, because if I'm trying to do tech support for someone, I definitely want that extra information.
- kube-system 5y agoBlue screens got a bad reputation because the people they were most often presented to had no idea how to consume the information. Presenting the right information to the right people is also important.
- grishka 5y agoEveryone knows that a blue screen means that the OS crashed. Maybe they should be more helpful instead? Like, you know, actually show a human-readable description of the error, so the person who sees it knows where to start troubleshooting. Something like "kernel-mode driver for device X performed an invalid memory operation, please try updating it or report this to its developer" instead of "PAGE_FAULT_IN_NONPAGED_AREA".
- marcodiego 5y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19573458 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19573458
- asdff 5y agoI still use a 2012 macbook, which was the last one where Apple graciously let you replace most of the parts including the RAM sticks yourself before soldering them to the logic board. According to official documentation this computer could have only been ordered with 2x2gb sticks, can only support an upgrade up to 2x4gb sticks, but here I am running 2x8gb sticks without having to do any fiddling, just plug and play. Unlike OP though, windows 10 over bootcamp is luckily able to pick up the 16gb just fine somehow.
- pronoiac 5y agoSame here! I'm bummed that Catalina, the last OS update to officially run on it, probably will hit EOL in 2022. I'll likely begrudgingly replace it, rather than look into workarounds to install newer versions, in an unsupported and slow way.
- neurostimulant 5y agoYou could install big sur using some patch if you don't mind the built in wifi card stopped working, but I heard you can swap the wifi card from later model and big sur would recognize it.
- asdff 5y agoWhy not just continue running catalina? I am still on mojave, no issues past EOL for me.
- charwalker 5y agoI've run 16gb in mine alongside that little dual core CPU. It works better than it did in 2012 thanks to a 60gb SSD too.
- grishka 5y agoI do wonder if that Mac Mini from 2011 I have but haven't used in a long time also secretly supports 16 GB. I upgraded it to 8 GB ages ago and the docs said that's as far as it goes.
- 5y ago
- benjaminpv 5y agoI was looking to Hackintosh an older Dell desktop I had squirreled away and in the process of gathering all the hardware every piece of documentation I found insisted that it topped out at 4GB. This was a late-era Core 2 so that seemed completely nonsensical to me (I don't think I ever owned a Core 2 that had less than 8) and, wouldn't you know it, 8GB worked perfectly fine. Funnily enough, like the article's author I also encountered a DSDT-related problem on that same system: if you were to dump the tables and recompile them with the standard Intel utility it straight up wouldn't work. Came to find out that there are apparently two compilers, one from Intel and another from MS and the MS one is super-lenient about accepting garbage. Eventually worked out that the logic in the stock tables was such that several features (HPET and sleep, iirc) just straight up don't work unless the OS identifies itself to ACPI as Vista (and not like Vista+, Vista exclusively). Such a pain.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoI ran into DSDT problems as well on my laptop running Linux. How did you figure it out? How do people reverse engineer this stuff? I managed to get all USB features working but this ACPI stuff eludes me.
- userbinator 5y agoRead the ACPI spec. Seriously. It's a commonly given answer especially in the Hackintosh scene, but I don't think there's a quicker or easier way than to actually understand what everything is about. On the other hand, it's funny to think that Hackintosh probably was responsible for motivating a lot of people to learn about ACPI and other complex low-level hardware details.
- egberts1 5y agoACPI spec is that final frontier for me that I am saving for my retirement year reading leisure. I just recently mastered Linux Intel DDIO for 100Gbps network card. And this is after BellCore SONET/ATM.
- toast0 5y agoI had some Dell Core 2 laptops that AFAIK were limited to 4G (well, less because it couldn't map anything above 4G so you wouldn't be able to access all the physical memory) by the Intel 945 chipset. If you had a 965 chipset you could do 8G apparently.
- ComputerGuru 5y agoThis was shared on HN [0] when it was first written in 2019 and it was heavily discussed (817 points, 178 comments). As soon as I saw the title I knew what post this was; I recall it very vividly and was more than happy to upvote it and then sit down to read it again! [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19573458 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19573458
- belval 5y agoMost of the time those limits are important for a specific feature of the motherboard that you might not be using. For example I recently put 64GB of RAM in a mobo that only supported 32. It didn't work at first and through trial and error I found out that XMP was the only thing with a hard 32GB requirement. Once disabled it booted fine with 64GB.
- walterbell 5y agoPresentations on open-source firmware, which can be used to extend the lifespan of older motherboards and devices. 2020-2021: https://vimeo.com/user128699411 https://vimeo.com/user128699411 2019: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCUVk2lv2h2VbP3Dx4k2axyA/videos https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCUVk2lv2h2VbP3Dx4k2axyA/vid...
- IntelMiner 5y agoIt's a shame that getting modern machines with Coreboot compatibility are virtually impossible I'd absolutely pay extra for a Ryzen 5000 series motherboard that I could put Coreboot on Hopefully the Framework laptop pushes things in the right direction for mobile computing, they've at least stated an intent to add Coreboot support
- userbinator 5y agoMy experience has always been that "not supported" means anywhere from "physically impossible" (e.g. because there just isn't that many address bits) to "we won't help you because we haven't tested it". Some quick searching shows that others have managed to get that CPU to use 32GB of RAM: https://forums.overclockers.com.au/threads/p55-chipset-i5-750-takes-32gb-ram.1083529/ https://forums.overclockers.com.au/threads/p55-chipset-i5-75... I thought he would go as far as patching the BIOS itself, which would make it a "permanent" fix. In fact one of the projects I haven't gotten around to finishing is to patch the memory init code for an old Atom processor embedded motherboard to make it recognise more combinations of RAM modules; analysis of the BIOS and leaked sources shows that it was stupidly written as "if(512MB in slot 1 and 512MB in slot 2) ... else if(1GB in slot 1 and empty slot 2) else if(1GB in slot 1 and 1GB in slot 2) ...", when the memory controller can actually be set up generally to work with many more different configurations.
- ivraatiems 5y agoYour definition's right in the sense of what "not supported" allows the user to do. But the term also means "if you try this and it doesn't work, we're not responsible," and that's the key thing. Some companies (and programs, and programming languages, and so on) make it easy to do unsupported things. Some make it hard. None will accept liability for it. Hardware manufacturers are on the hook for so many potential problems, defects, misconfigurations and misuses that it makes sense from their perspective to support actively only those things they can guarantee will always work. Not things which the hardware can theoretically do but which might not always be the best idea, things that aren't possible now but might be in ten years, etc.
- rzzzt 5y ago"16 GB is not supported because the system has two slots and 8 GB sticks do not exist" ...yet.
- wkearney99 5y agoand marketing didn't want some penny-pinching customer to fixate on HOW MUCH? would the system cost if it actually had all that RAM.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- molticrystal 5y agoFor windows with test signing on it seems you may be able to replace the tables with your own generated ones similar to the OP's original attempt, but without the need to use grub. I have no idea the utility of this, considering it requires test signing and compared to the grub approach, but maybe it will come in handy to somebody someday. > To do this, rename the AML binary to acpitabl.dat and move it to %windir%\system32. At boot time, Windows replaces tables present in the ACPI firmware with those in acpitabl.dat. [0] [0] https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/drivers/bringup/generate-acpi-tables-by-using-acpigenfx https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/drivers/br...
- csdvrx 5y agoWhen you enable test signing (etc.) don't you then have the text overlay on top of the desktop wallpaper?
- ChrisArchitect 5y agoWhy did you share this? Some previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19573458 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19573458
- ChrisArchitect 5y ago(2019)
- Nux 5y agoI'm glad he did as I missed it before. Perfectly happy for items of interest to be reposted periodically, it makes sense.
- ChrisArchitect 5y agoJust asking why. Why submit it. There's nothing new on it. We're just repeating the same discussions had before that can be read on the previous discussion when it was new. Hence linking to the other discussion thread.
- Nux 5y agoAs I said above, what is new is "me", the audience, and imho that's reason enough. I will never start digging around like a mad man in the annals of HN for cool stuff to read, but if some good older piece makes the front page again, then that is good.
- kaliszad 5y agoYeah, one would expect, motherboards could have some heuristics to either: - have the best speed possible - have the highest capacity possible with the RAM available and finally - tell what is the problem if there is one (e.g. having no module in slot, having incompatible modules on channel) This cannot be so hard to do. See my recent adventures: https://twitter.com/KaliszAd/status/1462940387916582915 https://twitter.com/KaliszAd/status/1462940387916582915
- npteljes 5y agoVery nice adventure, and I love the fact that the open source ecosystem provided all the tools that OP could use to get ahead.
- bell-cot 5y agoMy n=1 - A Dell system, "16GB max memory" (Dell) vs. "32GB max memory" (web sites of some leading 3rd-party memory manufacturers). The latter seem to be correct. Both Windows 10 and the hardware self-tests in the Dell's BIOS fully support the extra memory.
- fuzzfactor 5y agoI've got an old HP business tower that only officially supports 4GB of DDR2 and has 4 slots. Works just fine on 800MHz using 4GB total. Needed to use 667MHz DIMMS so it would handle 8GB. Almost worked with 800 but was unstable.