3 ms·
As with TLS 1.3 itself, a big benefit is that the Inner encrypted Hello can't be inspected by whatever (inevitably poorly made and never updated) middleboxes ar
by tialaramex 5y ago
As with TLS 1.3 itself, a big benefit is that the Inner encrypted Hello can't be inspected by whatever (inevitably poorly made and never updated) middleboxes are on the route between client and server.
It isn't important to the Internet whether these middle boxes are put there by the Government of the People's Republic of China to promote Harmony, by your daughters $1000 per month private school to prevent her looking at "inappropriate" material (whether that's the 1619 project, TikTok, or porn) or your employer to dissuade employees from uploading PDFs of company secrets, the problem and the solution is the same from the Internet's point of view.
Did you know that TLS certificate compression is an obvious, trivial improvement to the rapidity of secured connections that could not be deployed for over a decade because until TLS 1.3 the Certificate message is cleartext and so if you send one that looks "wrong" to some dodgy middlebox firmware written in 2006 your web site doesn't work?
Whenever the purpose of bypassing middleboxes is explained, there are people who are outraged. How dare we fix the Internet? They were relying on FaultySoft CrapSecurity 0.0.1 from 2006 and now we've ruined everything by bypassing it. No we didn't, by definition if what we did worked, your middlebox already wasn't protecting you. We've shattered your illusion and that's all. Santa Claus isn't real either.
- donmcronald 5y ago> How dare we fix the Internet? Fix it for who? We’re not far off from completely locked down devices, at least on mobile, where the last few options for ad (and tracking) blocking are being “fixed” in the sense they’re being removed. Everything will eventually use DoH, ECH, and CDN IPs and it’ll be impossible to distinguish content from ads and tracking. I wouldn’t be surprised if browsers eventually stop letting addons see hostnames due to “privacy concerns”. At that point we’ll have unstoppable ads and tracking everywhere.
- GoblinSlayer 5y agoIsn't DNS filter easier than SNI-based blocking?
- donmcronald 5y agoOnly until all devices are using DoH. Your TV manufacturer isn’t going to give you an opt out switch for the modern network protocols that guarantee users can’t block ads and tracking.
- Anunayj 5y agoyes it is, but it is also less effective, since users can easily use DNS over TLS to get around these measures. With SNI based blocking their only choice is proxying/VPNing which is much harder and less accessible.
- GoblinSlayer 5y agoYou mean quad nine? How difficult it is to block? That's literally one rule in the firewall.