3 ms·
This is something all elite universities will need to address in the near future. It will take a growing amount of cognitive dissonance to, on one hand, have mi
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
This is something all elite universities will need to address in the near future. It will take a growing amount of cognitive dissonance to, on one hand, have mission statements that talk about broad goals of improving humanity, and on the other hand serve as one of the primary markers and controller of elite status in the US. I say this as an Ivy alum.
While I don't necessarily agree with abolishing elite universities, the current admissions system is fundamentally corrupt, and the only reason universities don't abolish it is that doing so would require admitting a degree of luck in admissions, which would kill the facade of a strict meritocracy. My proposal would be to have clear, binary criteria for admission (some combination of grades, test scores, perhaps even something for extra academic success if that could be done objectively), and if that resulted in, say, 20000 people being eligible, then use a random lottery to get down to the number of spots in a class.
- melony 5y agoOr they can just scale up with population growth. Funding is hardly scarce at their level. We have more billionaires right now than ever. A few building names and libraries will easily pay for the next decade.
- joebiden2024 5y agoScaling up would still exclude nearly everyone, including the namesake of my username and the most powerful man in the world.
- melony 5y agoAnd you just proved my point, look at the distribution of Congress, the SCOTUS, the majority of elite government executive bureaucracy and tell me that they don't overwhelmingly favor certain institutions. Just ask your namesake's old boss.
- joebiden2024 5y agoYes, this is something that should end.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI totally agree if the solution is just to say "we automatically will admit anyone who hits our bar, and we'll grow the university as needed to accommodate anyone that hits that bar." At some point, though, it seems like you might get into pure physical constraints at a place like Yale.