4 ms·
> that kind of does sound excessive I don't know about you, but I'd have to compare it to cost of living references and public employee's per capita to begin
by kelseyfrog 5y ago
> that kind of does sound excessive
I don't know about you, but I'd have to compare it to cost of living references and public employee's per capita to begin to have an understanding. Even if I had that, there are many other factors I'd want to explore: what's the impact of CoL and commuting? What's the impact of employees not living in the jurisdictional area? What are the structural systems which function to determine salaries, both as an interaction with labor markets and those that have been institutionalized? If I was hired as a consultant to make judgements on SF public spending, in short, I'd do my due diligence.
- rkk3 5y agoIs this the bureaucracy defense? I need to be certified, have 30 years experience, and do a 10,000 page analysis before I can have a "legitimate" opinion.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoNo, but you presented a false dichotomy.
- rkk3 5y agoThey are saying my process isn't "rigorous" enough and needs to follow their complicated rules and ways of doing things, I don't think calling that bureaucratic is a false dichotomy.
- bobthepanda 5y agoNo, they're saying you're making purely gut judgements that are rash. For any employer, private or public, slashing salaries and benefits is a great way to start trending towards 100% turnover, which is a pretty negative outcome if you want to maintain any semblance of operation.
- rkk3 5y agoAll I said is that it might be excessive to pay 40% of public employee's individually [1] 40k more a year than the median household income [2] in the area. Don't equate that with arguing for Austerity. https://www.openthebooks.com/forbes-why-san-francisco-is-in-trouble--19000-highly-compensated-city-employees-earned-150000-in-pay--perks/ https://www.openthebooks.com/forbes-why-san-francisco-is-in-... [1] https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/sanfranciscocitycalifornia https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/sanfranciscocitycalifornia [2]
- all2well 5y agoAre you not arguing that public sector employees in San Francisco should get a pay cut?
- rkk3 5y agoNot really, all I did was question the OP scoffing that an 150k salary is not a lot of money. My mother is a public school teacher.
- kesselvon 5y agoIt's not a lot of money in San Francisco, where you're fighting with every tech company employee for housing
- rkk3 5y agoDo you have a quantitive way of making the distinction of what "a lot" is? 150k is substantially more than the average SF household, and is about 83 percentile for individuals. https://dqydj.com/income-by-city/ https://dqydj.com/income-by-city/
- bobthepanda 5y agoAverage home prices in SF is 1.3M, so a household of two teachers would give them a P/E ratio of 5. The P/E ratio for the average US home is 4.4. Are teachers overpaid, or are people in SF underpaid relative to the value of a house?
- czhu12 5y agoIs it not enough to just say that we should pay people market rates? If the true cost of a firefighter in California is indeed 190k then thats what they should be paid. If its lower then they are overpaid and if its higher than they are underpaid. This is not to say that firefighters are not essential workers, of course they are. We can make an argument that every firefighter should be paid 500k or 1 million. Heck, they save lives, so why not 10 million? Ultimately, the vast majority of people not in public sector work doesn't get to make these kinds of arguments, and are simply forced to take market rates.
- lupire 5y agoCA uses nearly unpaid prison labor for firefighting, making the huge salary for paid firefighters even stranger.
- kelseyfrog 5y agoKind of? Do you think the market for firefighters is a monopsony and if so, how does that shape the firefighter labor market?
- czhu12 5y agoMaybe so, but this is always going to be a problem with unionized government work. We can try to approximate a free market by reducing the power of public-sector unions. Ultimately it has to come down to tax payers to hold government accountable. More transparency is a step in that direction.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThese markets are monopsonies. The market rate is much lower than the actual value these jobs are worth. Even so, we do not have enough firefighters and teachers. This is a price signal that the current compensation is insufficient.
- austhrow743 5y agoNot enough firefighters in that there are open positions and no one is interested? Or open positions only for the already trained/experienced? If it’s the latter then that’s an argument that compensation is too high if anything. It should be rebalanced such that some of it is used for training. If the former then that’s just alien to me. Here in Australia firefighting is a prestigious job with a lot of competition. People volunteer to do it for free or do it part time while working another primary job, for years, in the hopes of being able to become a full time firey.