3 ms·
> I think California may face a more difficult argument since 2nd Amendment rights are in the Constitution, but Roe v. Wade is just court precedent. That's a d
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
> I think California may face a more difficult argument since 2nd Amendment rights are in the Constitution, but Roe v. Wade is just court precedent.
That's a distinction without justification. Constitutional rights are basically however the Supreme Court interprets them.
With respect to gun rights, there has been a long debate over whether the 2nd amendment applies to any individual, or just to "a well-regulated militia". The only reason it applies to any individual is because that's how the court interpreted it (and more recently than Roe v Wade) - through "court precedent", as you say.
- thesuperbigfrog 5y ago>> That's a distinction without justification. Constitutional rights are basically however the Supreme Court interprets them. Good point. That distinction is more artificial than I perceived it.
- beej71 5y agoAnd I'm not even sure that's in play here. The state isn't banning anything; they're just saying private citizens can sue manufacturers and sellers for up to $10k, right?