3 ms·
> It becomes whack-a-mole because the stacked court is certain to find the CA law unconstitutional but the TX abortion law fine I disagree with this statement.
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
> It becomes whack-a-mole because the stacked court is certain to find the CA law unconstitutional but the TX abortion law fine
I disagree with this statement. Justices may be ideological, but they aren't idiots. They know that they will lose any possible shred of legitimacy the court has left if they are that open about their hypocrisy. Indeed, the biggest concern that conservative justices expressed during the hearing on the Texas law was whether it would allow any constitutional right, especially gun rights, to be invalidated in this manner.
Justices may be ideological, but they know they need to craft their rulings to appear non-political in order to uphold their legitimacy (Roberts has been especially clear about this).
- quitit 5y agoDefinitely a wait and see on this - because I hope (sincerely) that you are right. Their specific selection for appointment doesn’t give me the same level of confidence.
- SauciestGNU 5y agoMy expectation is that the court will rule abortion bans are legal but the citizen enforcement schemes are not. So the bounty system won't stand but abortion will become illegal in much of the country.
- ykevinator2 5y agoMmm I dunno the latest two seem like idiots.