7 ms·
California governor to create Texas-like law to ban assault weapons
- mike503 5y agoHonestly I’m not sure why this is flagged. It’s sort of a “hack the system” approach and kind of amusing to see happen. If extreme right is going to do things then left is going to respond. The last few years have proven you can simply laugh in the face of laws, keep stuff locked up in courts and lawsuits and counter lawsuits to block things. At this point let everyone have a stab at the chaos.
- b9be520d93286 5y agoLol. "Assault" weapons. If that is not spreading FUD by itself, I dont know what is. Axios and most mainstream media is complicit in this. Flag this comment. Who cares....
- vmception 5y agoAccredited investor laws and other obscure regimes have long been modeled in a similar way. There is no prohibition or sanction from the state to a non-accredited investor, a US resident can invest in anything if they figure out how to. The way you use your money is a form of constitutionally granted expression in the US, with enforcement relying on the 14th amendment and would not be able to separate or prohibit investors in a form of caste system. But the same outcome is achieved as private businesses raising capital (and the broker dealers) are the ones that face the potential liability from the state, (exacerbated by the much higher likelyhood of poor people complaining about their money to regulators or launching their own private litigation), and so the intermediary therefore enforces the accredited investor prohibition on behalf of the state in a way that is likely much more distributed and effective than the state could ever do itself. The model of law has always has always been an endrun around the constitution, and maintains a durable consensus. It is interesting to see people just now getting inspired by this form of law, due to the less obscure topics they are covering.
- hirundo 5y ago"...as private businesses raising capital (and the broker dealers) are the ones that face the potential liability from the state, (exacerbated by the much higher likelyhood of poor people complaining about their money to regulators or launching their own private litigation), and so the intermediary therefore enforces the accredited investor prohibition on behalf of the state..." As you describe this it is very different in effect from the Texas law, in that SB-8 does not require any particularized injury of the plaintiff. If you don't need to be injured to sue successfully, the litigation pressure is vastly more intense because anyone can pursue it, and the fines are more than sufficient motivation.
- vmception 5y agoAccredited investor laws don't require injury. The injury just creates the likelihood that it gets noticed. But yes the major difference in capital raising laws is that the state regulator is the biggest issue, whereas the executive branch is (mostly) absent in SB-8 and likely will be completely absent.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI'm not familiar with how the accredited investor laws work, but at least from your description, and reporting on the Texas abortion law, there do seem to be crucial differences beyond one just being "a less obscure topic". The Texas abortion law basically deputizes anyone in the state to be an "abortion tattler", except for state officials who are expressly prohibited from enforcing the law. That "innovation" is what is fundamentally new about this law and why some argue it evades federal judicial review, and that seems very different from accredited investor laws.
- golemotron 5y agoYour comment makes me wonder whether SCOTUS could have just nullified the part of the law which forbade state actors from filing suit. That could have given standing to sue the AG, for instance.
- 5y ago
- newaccount2021 5y agoGavin has a tough row to hoe here...Roe v Wade never had the legal weight of the 2A Then again, CA also openly flaunted Federal immigration law, so chances are this may stick Biden will provide tacit cover but he's foolish to do so...an erosion of Federal authority isn't in his interests
- syki 5y agoIf the Supreme Court lets the Texas law stand then I think inevitably the country will break apart. There’s a good chance of that happening regardless but allowing each state to effectively usurp what so far is considered a right negates the concept of federalism. That the Supreme Court did not immediately strike down the Texas law means that in the near future left leaning people will start advocating for states rights as Congress ends up moving to the right. The idea is now out there: each state can impose its own views on what are rights without it being immediately struck down. The divide widens.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- golemotron 5y agoIt's reversion to the mean. The Bill of Rights was put in place to forbid the federal government from infringing on rights, since the states were sovereign already and could make their own decisions via democratic process. It's not a negation of federalism, it's a resurrection.
- annoyingnoob 5y agoWhat about the Bill of Rights allows States to infringe rights but not the 'federal government'? Your statement makes it sound like the Bill of Rights does not also apply to State governments, and it does. In your view, there are no inalienable rights and as long as a State has a democratic process then the State can dictate whatever it wants for your life.
- Majromax 5y ago> What about the Bill of Rights allows States to infringe rights but not the 'federal government'? The grandparent poster is arguing against the doctrine of incorporation (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incorporation_of_the_Bill_of_Rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incorporation_of_the_Bill_of_R...). Prior to the Civil War, the rights guaranteed in the Bill of Rights were read to apply specifically against the federal government. However, the thirteenth amendment (banning slavery) explicitly overrides state jurisdiction. The fourteenth amendment guarantees due process and equal protection of the law, and this is the usual route by which the other rights guaranteed under the Constitution have been extended to apply against state law. In recent decades, this question has been settled so thoroughly that an anti-incorporation stance is a radical reinterpretation of the relationship between the federal and state governments.
- btheshoe 5y agoCulture warring in America has reached an extreme level of hilarity
- not_really 5y agoIsn't it odd calling this form of law Texas-inspired, when Texas got the idea from states working to legalize drugs? Stopping the war on drugs sounds grrat, but it also sounds like the reporting here is biased.
- golemotron 5y agoGotta love California's governor essentially saying "this is terrible, so we are going to do it."
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoThat's a total mischaracterization. It's more of a shot across the bow, a warning along the lines of "you really want to open this Pandora's box?" A big focus of the Supreme Court arguments was that if the Texas law was allowed to stand, then any constitutional right, especially gun rights that are near and dear to conservatives, could be ignored in this manner, and that was the line of argument that appeared to have the biggest impact on more conservative judges like Kavanagh. CA doing this is basically a warning to SCOTUS justices that if they allow the Texas law to stand, it's game on.
- thesuperbigfrog 5y agoIt will be interesting to see what happens. I think California may face a more difficult argument since 2nd Amendment rights are in the Constitution, but Roe v. Wade is just court precedent. That said, it depends on how the law they propose to inact will work. The right to own a firearm is not the same as the right to manufacture or sell a firearm. They might drive firearm manufacturing and sales out of state, but not be able to prohibit someone buying a firearm out of state and bringing it home.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> I think California may face a more difficult argument since 2nd Amendment rights are in the Constitution, but Roe v. Wade is just court precedent. That's a distinction without justification. Constitutional rights are basically however the Supreme Court interprets them. With respect to gun rights, there has been a long debate over whether the 2nd amendment applies to any individual, or just to "a well-regulated militia". The only reason it applies to any individual is because that's how the court interpreted it (and more recently than Roe v Wade) - through "court precedent", as you say.
- enahs-sf 5y agoI think the operative difference here is, it requires a trained and licensed physician to perform an abortion. Anyone can take an 80% lower receiver and make one into an AR-15 in their garage with just a couple of YouTube videos to guide them.
- Ancapistani 5y agoI’m fairly sure that the vast majority of abortions throughout history were performed by people who were not trained and licensed physicians.
- quitit 5y agoReasonably the supreme court shouldn't green light laws which trivially trample preexisting rights, prior test cases or the constitution. This will be a poison pill: should a stacked supreme court effectively reverse abortion rights by allowing the Texan abortion law to stand - then all states can effortlessly clog the system with similar laws for anything they please. It becomes whack-a-mole because the stacked court is certain to find the CA law unconstitutional but the TX abortion law fine - which will just lead to a similar indirect laws being brought on loop.
- sathackr 5y agoThe Supreme Court should not do anything based on any ideology or desired results. The Court should interpret the law and the constitution as it is written. If that enables an undesirable result, then the legislative branch can take corrective action. Either the Texas law is legal or it's not. It's not the Supreme Court's job to fix the legality of an undesirable result just as it's not their job to decide what an undesirable result is.
- tmaly 5y agoThey do this all of the time. They are only human and have their inherent biases.
- rebuilder 5y ago“Interpret” and “As it is written” - pick one, you can’t have both.
- threatofrain 5y agoThe Supreme Court sets its own agenda and relationship with the rest of the branches of government, more than all other institutions. The Supreme Court is traditionally expected to bring clarity to lower courts and follow its own precedence. Sometimes that has meant creating a new legal framework of judgment. To what degree does the Supreme Court fix existing legislation and to what degree do they pass work back to Congress? Also up to the Supreme Court to decide. What textual strategy should the Supreme Court choose to interpret laws? Also up to the Supreme Court to decide.
- sebow 5y ago> “anyone who manufactures, distributes, or sells an assault weapon or ghost gun kit or parts in the State of California.” That's definitely not vague at all.'Good luck to Gavin', personally i think he's delusional if he expects any success from this,besides further polarizing California.Also this is not a Texas-like law for obvious reasons
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoThis article should not be flagged. I realize it's a hot political topic likely to involve some flame-warring, but it also brings up a crucial topic about how a novel legal approach can be an end run around judicial review, this time from the other side of the political spectrum. The first I heard about this was here on HN, and until this was flagged there were good, useful comments that taught me something new (e.g. the accredited investor one for me).
- emerged 5y agoDoes flagging do anything other than alert mods to review? I’ve had a benign comment flagged, which was baffling, but afaik it didn’t actually do anything.
- detaro 5y agoFor submissions, it affects ranking quite severely, over a threshold shows the [flagged] status and over a higher threshold closes the discussion, blocking all comments and hiding it from people not using showdead. For comments, it's binary - over the threshold flagged hides it from people not using showdead and disables replies to it.
- Jansen312 5y agoHe can try. The only problem for him is that the law need to go against 2nd which has been widely intepreted across America as shall not infringed. At best he restricted certain class of arms. Texas-ban didn't have the 2nd-like headwind. RvW was a court created "law" which will not have a stronger test of time vs the constitution bill of rights. He should concentrate on economy not playing politics during this almost-post pandemic era.