4 ms·
> Gives economies time to adapt while avoiding the severe threat of exponential growth. What if economies had already borrowed from the future expecting expone
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
> Gives economies time to adapt while avoiding the severe threat of exponential growth.
What if economies had already borrowed from the future expecting exponential growth?
- naravara 5y agoAll this means is we’ve built something in the present that someone in the future doesn’t get paid for. We still have the thing we built so I’m not sure what the problem is so long as we’re building something useful (e.g. infrastructure, public services) and not something pointless (e.g. overpriced real estate and other economic rents).
- lotsofpulp 5y agoTechnically, yes, but politically, it does not work that way. If people are sold a certain quality of life, and then they do not get it, they will fight (or vote) for direct as much of society’s resources into accomplishing that quality of life as possible. Even diverting society’s resources from quality of life that were offered generations ago when they were younger. It manifests as reduced investment in infrastructure, higher taxes, lower funding for schools (see US universities getting less money from government and raising tuition).
- jl6 5y agoSome people will be left holding bad debt. That could be bad if it happened overnight, but a fertility rate of 2.0 is a very gentle off-ramp. Either way would be preferable to exponential population growth continuing.
- candiodari 5y agoIt's not really, look at it like this: it takes people 65 years from birth to dependence. That means every generation has to deal with 47 years of fertility decline before getting a pension. Right now there's about 1 dependent per 1 working person in most of the western world. In 20 or so years that'll be 2 dependents per 1 working person, and it'll go over 5 in most of Europe before 2050, less than 40 years, and actually earlier in Eastern Europe. Even in the US it's definitely going to 2 dependents per 1 working person. For one thing that means the current level of tax pays for either the military OR pensions in 20 years, not both, and even 100% tax in the US won't pay for both. https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Fertility_statistics https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php... And this isn't a "print your way out of this" situation. At minimum, every child and elderly person is going to have to do with half as many humans providing services like education or medical services to them. It's real humans that we are short on, not some made up quantity like money. You could print $100 trillion per year and spend it entirely on elderly care, and we'd still have to deal with the reduction of workers per elderly. Anyone working today will not have people taking care of you when they retire at the current rates. Half as much time as today, probably a lot less. We're actually close to the tipping point in Europe: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1251591/population-growth-rate-in-europe/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1251591/population-growt... If someone's paying attention, Europe will need another Syria and Afghanistan soon. Perhaps in North Africa?
- jgwil2 5y agoThat's assuming a lot of people aren't currently working bullshit jobs or things that we can't automate though. I suspect that if we have a real worker shortage we'll find there's a lot we can do without or do more efficiently.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> What if economies had already borrowed from the future expecting exponential growth? They don't. They bother from other economies in the present. And if they borrow things they can repay, it's the lenders that lose out.
- Jensson 5y agoStock valuations are basically just money borrowed from the future. We expect the future workers to slave away and pay those trillions. From that perspective the future generation got many trillions more debt last year.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Stock valuations are basically just money borrowed from the future Stock valuations aren't money at all, nor are they borrowed. Stock valuations are kind of consensus estimate of future value, but if you get money based on them (by selling or borrowing against stock), you aren't borrowing from the future, you are borrowing or being paid with it from someone in the present. (Sure, if you borrow, you’ll have a future obligation to pay; that's not “borrowing from the future”, it's just borrowing.)