6 ms·
Carl Jung and Wolfgang Pauli bridged mind and matter (2017)
- 50 5y agoA bit reminiscent of the discussions between J. Krishnamurti and David Bohm.
- temp0826 5y agoAtom and Archytype was an absolute delight to read, highly recommended. Also fun: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pauli_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pauli_effect
- impostervt 5y agoI've been reading Bernardo Kastrup's "Decoding Jung's Metaphysics". In the book, Kastrup quotes from letters between Pauli & Jung several times in order to try and show how Jung though privately about metaphysics were more mystical than what he said publicly. https://www.amazon.com/Decoding-Jungs-Metaphysics-Archetypal-Experiential/dp/1789045657 https://www.amazon.com/Decoding-Jungs-Metaphysics-Archetypal...
- throwaway47292 5y agoIf you are interested in Jung's metaphysics I strongly recommend ordering a copy of The Red Book (https://www.amazon.com/dp/0393065677 https://www.amazon.com/dp/0393065677) even though it costs 200$, it is worth every penny. It is amazing to read Jung's unfiltered mind.
- richardjdare 5y agoThere is a cheaper "Readers Edition" of the Red Book available. Also, Jung's student Marie-Louise Von Franz wrote a bit about Jung's later ideas in her books, "Number and Time", and "Psyche and Matter".
- catskul2 5y agoCan you say more why you recommend it so strongly?
- throwaway47292 5y agoHmm, this is hard to answer. I have read Jung's CW 9, 11, 12 and 16 and bits and pieces from the rest, but I think when I read The Red Book things really changed for how I see his work. It is extremely raw material, of an alienist on the verge of madness, and yet he managed to extract the deepest reason out of the experience. I think it is really worth reading, but in compliment with the images he drew. Maybe you can still buy the reader's edition and look at the images online, as 200$ is a lot, but if you can afford it i would recommend to get the big book.
- nabla9 5y agoIf you read Jung's autobiography, it should be clear. There is a place for interesting left-field ideas in science and philosophy, and Jung had the most interesting ideas. But if ideas are the only thing, it leads to nothing. Jung is a David Lynch of psychiatry. Jung's work is art and self-expression from a very creative and unique mind. It's best to read him as an artist, unique person. Jung was able to interact with his unconscious. He was discussing with imaginary people while he was completely awake. He wandered in dream-like states and remembered what happened.
- zwkrt 5y agoI’ve heard that jungian analysis works better for creative people who are more frequently living in a world of deep metaphors and inferred meanings.
- nathias 5y agoJung is astrology for men.
- dang 5y ago"Don't be snarky." "Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." "Eschew flamebait." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- tgv 5y agoI agree, although somewhat curiously it isn't based on external influences. But while possibly interesting from a historical point of view, what the article describes is what e.g. Penrose still pursues: here's some psychological effect we don't understand, and here's a physical one that can be described with similar metaphors, hence they must be related!
- akimball 5y agoUnfair to Penrose. His view is more like: Hence testing the range and depth of possible relationships to the limits of their coherence with evidence is a worthwhile enterprise.
- monktastic1 5y agoWhy isn't astrology "astrology for men?"
- EL_Loco 5y agoI think what parent means is that /astrology/, per se, is mostly consumed by women, whereas Jung's work, which can be viewed as similarly unscientific, is quite widely read by males, when compared with astrology texts.
- isitdopamine 5y agoI never understood how Jung is more unscientific than Freud. At least: I don’t see this choir of “but it’s antiscientific!!!” cries when Freud is discussed, but still there’s no evidence whatsoever for the tripartition of self which is at the very base of Freud’a theories. The super-ego is no more scientific than synchronicities!
- plutonorm 5y agoThese kinds of links are becoming more frequent. The Zeitgeist appears to be thinking more deeply on these topics. Perhaps we as a collective are beginning to move beyond brute materialism. I know I have been for a number of years now.
- jarpschop 5y agoThroughout history, people have always avoided naturalism, almost at any cost. I think that this in part has to do with the crude reality it implies, it a very hard pill to swallow to anyone who understands it well. However, time and again, what has been attributed to non-natural, magical entities, has turn out false. If I wanted to avoid becoming the next sun-worshipping, cow-worshipping idolatrous, I would be very wary of any supernatural claim.
- BobbyJo 5y ago(since you are juxtaposing naturalism and magic, I'm assuming by naturalism you mean materialism. If that is incorrect, ignore me.) Yes, but also no. Materialism is a way of looking at the world that itself encompasses the scientific method. Saying that the scientific method always proves materialism correct is a tautology. I think what's different this time around is that we are saying materialism is likely incomplete, as opposed to 'wrong', which seems like a safe bet given our advancing understanding of the universe. Give the materialists that which is theirs.
- Layke1123 5y agoWhat? If anything, over time, science has increasingly shown that a material view of the world is far more accurate. Just because we don't have a complete theory of the universe yet, that does not mean it is likely incomplete. We've only been seriously at this for about 200 years. It took us 50 from the first flight to land on the moon. Why would you think it's more likely to reverse trend suddenly?
- Dudeman112 5y ago>Saying that the scientific method always proves materialism correct is a tautology If, on a hypothetical example, we could come up with an experiment where you removed half of 100 people's nervous system and most of them kept acting like normal then the scientific method would "prove" that materialism isn't correct (unless, of course, someone came and found out that what actually makes people behave like they do isn't their nervous system). There is nothing making the scientific method unable ascertain whether there is more to the universe than the physical things in it. The scientific method just fails again and again at reaching the opposite stance.
- throwaway321678 5y agoI would recommend to anyone to read Jung's - Modern Man in Search of a Soul. It explains a lot of the social phenomena of today. The insight of that man was amazing! And it's more like an essay of 100 pages long.
- dr_dshiv 5y agoI have to admit that I don't get it, although I want to. What is an example of synchronicity/meaning-correspondence that Pauli might have suggested?