4 ms·
Yes it's thriving, but it's also broken. From a tweet[1] cited in the article: > This is the maintainer who fixed the vulnerability that's causing millions(++?
by littlestymaar 5y ago
Yes it's thriving, but it's also broken. From a tweet[1] cited in the article:
> This is the maintainer who fixed the vulnerability that's causing millions(++?) of dollars of damage.
> "I work on Log4j in my spare time"
> "always dreamed of working on open source full time"
> "3 sponsors are funding @rgoers's work: Michael, Glenn, Matt"
[1]: https://twitter.com/FiloSottile/status/1469441487175880711 https://twitter.com/FiloSottile/status/1469441487175880711
- charcircuit 5y agoNo one is entitled to money. There's nothing broken about that. If you want to make money it would be a good idea to make a business plan. Making and maintaining a piece of software and giving it away for free isn't a great business plan, or at best it's an incomplete one.
- thr0wawayf00 5y ago> No one is entitled to money. There's nothing broken about that. If you want to make money it would be a good idea to make a business plan. This attitude totally ignores how hard it is to actually run a software tooling business and collect when you have a free/community offering. Take the Obsidian note app, for example. It's technically free until you start using it for revenue-generating, work-related activity per their license, but how do they go about enforcing that? If they were to dig through customer data to see who is violating the agreement, they'd get roasted on Twitter in an instant and risk losing their user base. Should they hire attorneys to investigate and shake down violators for the $25/mo fee plus damages? Again, major risk of losing the customer base. Software devs have to represent a significant, if not majority share of the user base of Obsidian, and I'd bet a year of my salary that most of them aren't paying for it when they're using it for work. Committing to a business plan is an important step, but software's value is directly correlated with it's use, and more widely used software is inherently more valuable, but achieving that kind of growth without giving it away free is a major challenge. It kinda feels like tipping in the restaurant industry, where folks argue that it's to ensure proper service, when in reality it's often just a way for the restaurant owner to not have to pay minimum wage by offloading that portion of a workers wages onto the customer, who often just doesn't give a tip.
- threatofrain 5y agoI'm not sure that many people are using Obsidian for work, specifically because Obsidian does not have collaboration or any kind of "team" concept. It truly is a knowledge-for-one app.
- thr0wawayf00 5y agoObsidian is largely associated with the "Zettlekasten" philosophy, which is inherently individualistic and doesn't ever encourage collaborative use since the entire idea is based around a personal knowledge base, not a community knowledge base.
- rovr138 5y agoOr just use the honor system in combination with a liability standpoint. They might loose out on smaller companies that abuse it, but teams and people in larger companies that use it will pay. If I want to use something, I can pay for it and submit it to get reimbursed or if it's a bigger purchase, I use a company card. I don't have to worry about putting the company in liability and that's something that's understood by many. Another example, how does Jetbrain make sure that the people paying for their software via personal licenses aren't getting money for it from their companies?
- thr0wawayf00 5y ago> Another example, how does Jetbrain make sure that the people paying for their software via personal licenses aren't getting money for it from their companies? This is a great example, perhaps companies like Jetbrains just assume that a certain percentage of their user base uses their product out of license and they just deal with it, which undermines the original argument. Software inherently wants to be free, but we as a community agree upon the proper way to compensate those make OSS because we're taught that the exchange of money for goods should always happen upfront and there is no other way to conceptualize alternatives, which I disagree with.
- rovr138 5y ago
- pipework 5y agoI also wonder about the futility of the statement that someone could cause millions of dollars of damages when those companies elected to depend and build upon truly free software. Free lunches don’t exist for anyone.
- rboes 5y agoRight, if this is a huge problem for these big companies they only have themselves to blame, they decided to use software from a guy who writes it in his spare time.
- jevoten 5y agoBut what is broken is the disconnect between providing value and being able to earn a living from that value. More often than not, any "business plan" involves providing a worse product, because the product must be compromised to enable the business plan. SaaS for things that could be run locally is a perfect example. Or algorithmic feeds optimized for engagement in social media. Or the advertising panopticon. Or coffee filter DRM. Or smart TV spying. Or ads in the Windows start menu. Or..
- charcircuit 5y ago>More often than not, any "business plan" involves providing a worse produc The question is if you can provide a better product then your competitors. >algorithmic feeds optimized for engagement in social media Isn't this optimal though? If I see something but did not engage with it that site just wasted by time.
- Abishek_Muthian 5y agoYes it's broken, But not because of open-source philosophy itself but because corporations are greedy and general consumers are largely poor.
- eyelidlessness 5y agoAnd you’ve concluded that those things don’t have a causal relationship?
- Abishek_Muthian 5y agoI don't get you, But I hope it's gibe at 'Late Stage Capitalism'.