3 ms·
Also, the entire debate about waste is completely hypocritical. The “nuclear waste problem” is only special compared to other waste because there's a fraction o
by littlestymaar 5y ago
Also, the entire debate about waste is completely hypocritical. The “nuclear waste problem” is only special compared to other waste because there's a fraction of the wastes[1] (the only thing people think about when they talk about nuclear wastes) which are highly radioactive and will remain so for hundreds of thousand of years. they are legitimately scary. BUT we've known for decades how to get rid of them! It's called a breeding reactor, it's more sophisticated than a regular reactor but the technology isn't alien at all: France have built two of such reactors as an experiment. Too bad they where shut down under pressure from environmentalists, because you know they don't want new reactors to be built! And those same guys are now arguing about how wastes make nuclear irresponsible…
[1] As a reminder there are 4 “kinds” of nuclear wastes:
- Minor actinides: the scary ones. Their volume is ultra small, but they live practically forever if you leave them that way and are harmful even at low concentration because they are alpha emitters. They are mostly produced when neutrons are captured by U238 (the non-fissile part of the fuel). Plutonium makes the majority of it, and it's not by accident: the nuclear process was designed this way in order to get plutonium to build atomic bombs.
- Fission products: they are produced when a U235 nucleus is split. They are really radioactive (well it depends, but some are) but they don't live that long. They are the dangerous thing when a nuclear incident happens.
- Activation products: they are produced when neutrons hit something in the reactor (the structure, the water or water additives). They are radioactive but don't live that long, and they are often pretty diluted in the structure. It's dangerous for people working on the decommissioning though, because they can accumulate in specific places.
- Legal products: in some jurisdiction (for instance France), everything in a nuclear plant is a nuclear waste, including the walls of the offices, the pavement, the turbine, etc.
- zahma 5y agoIt is a good thing that France is building more reactors. I for one am glad that Macron has reversed his position on this. It is good for the country’s climate goals as well as energy independence.
- littlestymaar 5y agoWe're a few month before a presidential election, don't take these words for granted… I may have become a bit cynical, bit I actually expect some sort of a “Je ne dirais pas que c'est un échec, je dirais juste que ça n'a pas marché” when these (non-existing so far) projects eventually get cancelled.
- p_l 5y agoPlutonium can be fortunately further burned down in reactors that accept MOX fuels
- littlestymaar 5y agoMOX isn't without issues though. Plutonium is kept until we can use it to start breeding reactors IMHO!
- littlestymaar 5y agobetter kept*
- pfdietz 5y agoPlutonium can only be sent through burner reactors as MOX fuel once. After that, the isotopes left are no longer suitable and have to be buried (or saved for fast reactors.)