10 ms·
Carolina Gold was once the most popular rice grown in America (2019)
- TedShiller 5y agoIf I’ve never tasted it, it leaves open the possibility that it doesn’t actually taste good
- dang 5y ago"Please don't pick the most provocative thing in an article and rush to the thread to complain about it. Find something interesting to comment about instead." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mlyle 5y agoI'm just curious what you think this adds to the discussion. (I'm aware you were riffing off the title).
- TedShiller 5y agoThe title is click bait
- thomas 5y agoI've had it a few times and it's very good, but not better than most good rice. I think people mostly just don't have nice or fresh rice, they fine Carolina gold which is very well branded and think it's the best. It's not hard to find better than average rice online[0]. 0: https://helpatmyhome.com/buy-rice-online/ https://helpatmyhome.com/buy-rice-online/
- indigodaddy 5y agoAre you sure it wasn’t the Carolina brand that sells a “Carolina Gold” that is NOT the real thing? I’ve had the real Carolina Gold (my parents get it— I’ll have to ask them where/how), and it’s definitely the best rice I’ve ever had (and I eat a lot of rice / all kinds).
- davidjytang 5y agoThe best rice I have had had been Koshihikari[1]. I have never had Carolina Gold, branded or otherwise. How would you compare the two if possible? [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koshihikari https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koshihikari
- indigodaddy 5y agoIs that like calrose rice (eg Nishiki and similar brands?).. ?
- mlyle 5y agoHis link includes a discussion of Anson Mills which is the best source of the real thing. (Yes, Carolina-brand "Carolina Gold" is not the same thing and not great).
- indigodaddy 5y agoAh, my bad for not looking thanks
- cesaref 5y agoAs a UK resident, reading Anson Mills description of their rice products and how they taste, and what you can do with them is really quite bewildering - 'They can also be prepared in the creamy grits style and all the way to congee, if pressed, or as crisp skillet cakes, both savory and sweet.' I cook with a range of rices depending on what i'm doing - Arbori, Carnaroli, Basmati and Bomba, but rarely with what I consider an american long grain. I'll try and track down some of this Carolina Gold and see what I can do with it. Any suggestions for a recipe that shows it off (not knowing what a skillet cake is, for example)?
- monocasa 5y agoAs a southerner, this sounds pretty good: https://www.foodandwine.com/recipes/carolina-gold-pilau-shrimp https://www.foodandwine.com/recipes/carolina-gold-pilau-shri...
- silisili 5y agoSame. I think Carolina Gold is massively overrated, and definitely overpriced. There are thousands of articles hyping the stuff, which makes me curious seeing as Anson Mills seems like a small outfit.
- futevolei 5y agoI agree. I was in South Carolina last week and had Carolina gold rice twice- once in a seafood purloo and again in a broiled seafood combo. Had the menus not made a point of noting it was real Carolina gold I don’t think I would have paid any attention to the rice at all. Since they did I made sure to pay attention and I noticed no flavor difference at all. It might have had a different texture, I can’t be sure. End result is this rice means nothing to me.
- dmoy 5y agoI had good fresh rice in far northeastern China, and man, it ruined other rice for me, somewhat. Heilongjiang, Jilin, etc. It's just... better. Ah now my mouth is unconsciously salivating. Not worth a 28 day quarantine though.
- selimthegrim 5y agoApparently it is essential to Hoppin' John that actually tastes good
- subpixel 5y agoIt’s related to Hoppin John in so far as white Americans have a deep fetish for food that they can tell themselves is similar to what slaves ate. Gullah recipes are the latest incarnation. I think it’s all patronizing, at best. In fact I have a framed, handwritten sign I took from a gift shop in Charleston 30 years ago advertising benne seed wafers as something slaves “brought to the new world for good luck”.
- selimthegrim 5y agoLook I have no reason not to believe you (nor am I a white American) but when I had it at Landry's on New Year's Day they sure didn't market it that way (nor did it taste that great).
- jeffbee 5y agoCan I just mention how charming it is that there is such as thing as a USDA Rice Research Center? People throw bureaucracy around as a bad word but bureaucratic capacity brings us so many positive things. Let's hear it for the deep rice state.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoWhat else does it do and what cost? What is the cost benefit analysis of the rice research center?
- jeffbee 5y agoLet's see, one of the benefits is probably that we're not all starving to death right now. Not sure if there are others. I guess you could get rid of it to save every American 5¢ annually and trade that for a chance of a future rice disease wiping out our crops. That might make sense, in the same way that the Texas electric grid is very efficient.
- dylan604 5y agoJust wait until the populace at large finds out what is happening to their bananas. People will be screaming about why there was no American Banana Bureau Association
- markdown 5y agoGotta give the last President props for doing more than any President before him to try and turn the US into a banana republic.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoWhere is the evidence it prevents starvation? Most of the crops in the US are wheat, soybeans, and corn. The rice crop is negligible. They could use that in other crops.
- Aloha 5y agoYou can find it here: https://www.carolinaplantationrice.com/store/products/Carolina-Plantation-Gold-Rice.html https://www.carolinaplantationrice.com/store/products/Caroli...
- pitched 5y agoThis one seems popular too: https://ansonmills.com/products/23 https://ansonmills.com/products/23
- indigodaddy 5y agoI think that the OP link is actually the supplier for Anson but not 100% sure
- KarlKemp 5y agoIf any of you had read the article, you'd know that these are the two commercial outfits that grow the stuff, and they both grew out of the same university project.
- indigodaddy 5y agoI unfortunately waited too long to pull the trigger on ordering and now the Carolina Plantation website appears to be all sold out… I believe that’s also all she wrote on the year/season, so unlikely that it comes back in stock. I don’t really feel like paying the Anson Mills prices but maybe I’ll have to..
- Aloha 5y agohttps://www.carolinaplantationrice.com/store/products/Carolina-Plantation-Charleston-Gold-Rice.html https://www.carolinaplantationrice.com/store/products/Caroli... This product appears to be substantively the same thing and is still in stock, its just not grown in South Carolina.. Best of Luck!
- ed25519FUUU 5y agoThe story of heirloom fruit and vegetables is sad. People spent their entire lives sometimes creating delicious varieties only to be blown out by produce that was cheap to grow and looked good on the supermarket shelf (taste didn’t matter). Apples are a great example. Almost everything in the supermarket (save for a few varieties) is bland and mealy. It LOOKS great though, and that’s all that matters.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> People spent their entire lives sometimes creating delicious varieties only to be blown out by produce that was cheap to grow and looked good on the supermarket shelf (taste didn’t matter). Why would taste not matter? Surely people take into account taste when purchasing food. But they also decide to make tradeoffs in how much extra money to spend for the additional rate versus other things they could try with the additional money. But given two foods at the same price and nutritional qualities, surely taste is a prominent factor.
- sbassi 5y agoit should be, but it is not the way it works. The same happens with the tomato.
- ed25519FUUU 5y agoHomegrown tomatoes and tomatoes from the supermarket are two totally different fruits. They don’t even taste the same. Same goes with strawberries and probably a lot of things.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoI tasted heirloom tomatoes and they weren’t special
- jcrawfordor 5y agoIt's a pretty widely studied artifact of mass retail that appearance was valued over taste, because appearance is immediately obvious while taste must be remembered and most consumers don't. In other words, it's immediately obvious what produce looks good, while knowing what produce tastes good requires time and attention. Most people don't really remember the difference between varieties of apples, for example, which are currently undergoing a bit of a renaissance as breeders have discovered the value of branding and marketing campaigns similar to those used for manufactured goods. The general perception is that this trend is starting to go away only now, as a largely internet driven food culture has emerged that values unusual varieties. Moreover, for the retailer themselves, durability and shelf life is perhaps the single most important property in today's long supply chains, because produce is subject to rough handling and consumers absolutely do not purchase bruised fruit or wilted greens. Unfortunately it often runs opposite to other metrics of quality for produce.
- walrus01 5y agoIf you really want to see good quality rice, take a look at the quality and selection of product that an expert Pakistani chef will use for a top quality biryani. Or the rice that Afghans will use when cooking a Palaw the slow way. Generally within the category of long grain basmati, but there's a lot of difference between sub-types.
- waqasx 5y agoLong grain basmati that has aged a couple of years. I dont know if you can find aged basmati in the US.
- jeffbee 5y agoSure, In the Bay Area you can get aged basmati at Vik's Market in Berkeley and various markets in Union City. I would guess any place with an Afghanistan-born enclave would have it somewhere.
- walrus01 5y agoIn the Bay area the largest concentration of Afghans is in Fremont, there's at least two specialty grocery stores that stock much the same as what you'd see in Kabul. https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=afghans+fremont https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=afghans+f...
- yumraj 5y ago> Long grain basmati that has aged a couple of years. I dont know if you can find aged basmati in the US. I believe almost all Basmati rice is aged, the length of aging and of course grades of rice can vary. You can find it in any Indian grocery store since Basmati grown in India accounts for 65% of the international trade in basmati rice. At least in the Bay Area it can also be found in several/all Costco. Kirkland Basmati rice claims it is aged at least 1 year.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoAside, take care not too eat too much rice grown in the Carolinas. (Brand names notwithstanding.) Apparently the arsenic used for cotton is easily absorbed by rice grown in that region.
- selimthegrim 5y agoI thought this was more of an Ark-La-Tex problem
- qurashee 5y agoThat's really interesting. In Greece Carolina (Καρολίνα) is the name of a type of rice, but I had never realised it's named after a brand as there's no Carolina brand in the Greek market.
- irthomasthomas 5y agoIs this just an ad for Carolina Gold rice?
- reactspa 5y ago> Unlike grocery store rice, which just smells starchy, the Carolina Gold filled the room with a nutty, earthy aroma that had me craving white rice more than I've ever craved it before. Biting into my first spoonful, I could feel the firm texture of each and every grain in my mouth. It had the satisfying bite Shields told me about, the nuttiness, even a floral quality I hadn't quite expected. Yes, it was exactly what I wanted rice to taste like. Sounds like Basmati tbh.