3 ms·
> If log4j2 is responsible for your company's success, you have a moral obligation to donate to the person who creates this library thanklessly. This is false.
by sneak 5y ago
> If log4j2 is responsible for your company's success, you have a moral obligation to donate to the person who creates this library thanklessly.
This is false. Free software is given away by those who produce it. When you receive a gift, no moral or ethical obligation is created.
This idea that you can do things with free software that are contrary to the spirit (such as create a profitable company around it and not pay the original author) is a false one. It is free as in beer, too.
You don't owe anyone anything when you receive a gift freely given.
- webmaven 5y ago> This is false. Free software is given away by those who produce it. When you receive a gift, no moral or ethical obligation is created. The ethical obligation is to your own users: you should be making a reasonable good-faith effort to ensure that your software's dependency projects are healthy as a transitive consequence of ensuring the health of your own software project. This has nothing to do with the ethics of accepting a gift, and everything with professional ethics (which raises the debate of whether writing software should be a profession). Arguably, the dependency projects also have a similar obligation, or at least the obligation to make the health status of their project explicit.
- seoaeu 5y agoDoes that also mean that it is morally OK for the author to backdoor their code or sell zero days they discover in it? A direct reading of the license says there's no warranty so they have no grounds to complain, right?
- sneak 5y agoYes, I would say it does. It expressly disclaims even fitness for a particular purpose - if you don't read it, it could very well be example backdoor code.