3 ms·
> Cryptocurrencies are a big part of solving the environmental problems activists identify No, they’re not and it’s shameful to try to promote proof-of-waste u
by acdha 5y ago
> Cryptocurrencies are a big part of solving the environmental problems activists identify
No, they’re not and it’s shameful to try to promote proof-of-waste under the guise of environmentalism rather than just acknowledging that you are trying to find buyers.
There’s no shortage of useful applications for green power. Having constant competition to waste that power has incentivized keeping dirty power online and delays conversion by keeping the prices artificially high. Cryptocurrency mining operations can move quickly so they’ll soak up the cheapest green power which might otherwise encourage industrial users to relocate or accelerate personal electrification by people in the area.
Since cryptocurrency expensively doesn’t solve any real problems, that’s pure waste and obstruction at a time we cannot afford it.
- hdjdjdnbehsh 5y agoKys
- motohagiography 5y agoYou can't afford not to. The only way we reduce our impact on the planet is by managing its resources effectively, and genuine incentives that drive that efficiency are the only way to achieve that. Poverty is what you get when you don't value what you have, and it's practically the definition of inefficient use of resources. Making geothermal plants economical by leveraging demand from crypto mining that scales directly in real time to respond to real economic transactions is probably the most elegant and efficient economic system ever conceived of. The challenge with energy is economic transmission and storage, but by tying currency to it, you don't store or transmit energy, you store and transmit demand for energy in the currency, and this facilitates efficient economic energy production on demand at the time of a transaction for any business conducted in it. If the ideas in these comments are indeed new, someone should inform the Nobel committee. I don't think they are, but a geothermal energy currency solves a lot of problems.
- acdha 5y agoThat doesn’t make any sense — a carbon tax has the positive feedback cycle you’re describing. Cryptocurrency doesn’t have that effect because it doesn’t care about the source of the power it’s wasting — as we’ve seen with coal plants coming online — and the waste has no connection to benefits so the demand is insatiable, and miners will use whatever source is cheapest after exhausting surplus renewables no matter its pollution profile.
- motohagiography 5y agoI will restate that the incentives of making a geothermal cryptocurrency may be the highest positive impact we can have on the planet in our lifetimes. How do you exhaust a renewable? By driving up its price, which creates higher rewards on innovation that brings it down. So you don't exhaust it. Carbon taxes were a farce invented and promoted by academic managerialists with no understanding of human desire, as a way to sell their managerialism, and by politicians too meek to stand on their own and so they deferred to con artist experts. The only reason miners are using coal and nuclear is because it is available, subsidized, and it scales. It's a legacy tech of the past. Geothermal technology isn't available as widely yet, and it requires demand to scale. Miners are that demand. I wonder what The Boring Company is doing these days, as I think I might have a project.
- acdha 5y ago> How do you exhaust a renewable? By driving up its price, which creates higher rewards on innovation that brings it down. This is a naive position: geothermal, like hydropower, have only a few locations where they can be feasibly tapped. If that power is used by cryptocurrency miners, that will drive up the price until it's no longer cheaper than the alternatives and that region will not be attractive to relocating industrial operations. That could be excusable if cryptocurrency was useful but since over a decade and billions of dollars have yet to find a productive application, there's no way it's worth taking capacity away from useful activities. There's no shortage of demand, so anyone who makes a cheap non-carbon electricity source will have customers even without being subsidized by proof-of-waste speculators.