3 ms·
“Drive Pilot enables the driver to turn away from the traffic and focus on certain secondary activities,” the luxury carmaker said in a statement. “For example,
by vanusa 5y ago
“Drive Pilot enables the driver to turn away from the traffic and focus on certain secondary activities,” the luxury carmaker said in a statement. “For example, to communicate with colleagues via the in-car office, to write emails, to surf the internet or to relax and watch a film.”
This can't possibly be a good thing. Nevermind if it works as advertised or not -- just from the very definition of what's claiming to do.
I know it certainly sounds like a good thing -- it will relieve the stress and fatigue of these slow-moving situations, leading to better reaction times, etc.
But just think about for a second. When you're at the wheel, the most you should be doing on the side is talking to people, and occasionally checking your GIS. You just should not be engaged in other attention-demanding activities like reading emails, surfing the internet, or watching movies. Period.
What's going to happen is: someone's leg's are gonna get crushed, because (foolishly or not) they walked between cars in a slow-moving traffic situation (like they always do). Because, you know, a human driver would have seen them. And then the same debates will start up all over again, completely missing the point. It's not the overall statistics of this happening, or that the driver didn't respond to the flashing red light that must have gone off in time (because they were zoned out, of course).
It's that they're pushing this inherently risky technology out there (which by definition cannot be fully validated until subjected to extensive real-life conditions), not to save us from drivers who are temporarily incapacitated at the wheel, not to warn us from approaching objects we might miss ... but to let us watch Netflix while driving.
- ashtonkem 5y agoDefinitionally, L3 is not ready for the human to stop paying attention. I would argue that you need at least L4 automation before you can explicitly advise users that they can do distracting things in the car, and even then only in good weather and on specific roads (e.g. highways).
- ctdonath 5y agoAutomated driving is safer. Offering to let you watch a movie is a way to get you to not drive for two hours.
- jgilias 5y agoI may be wrong, but I think it's not legal to be walking on an Autobahn, irrespective of how slow the traffic moves.
- vanusa 5y agoThe thing is, they test things things out in one environment, they get approved ... and then used in another.