3 ms·
> [Even at] 3 meters of social distancing ... it takes less than five minutes for an unvaccinated person standing in the breath of a person with Covid-19 to bec
by mdp2021 5y ago
> [Even at] 3 meters of social distancing ... it takes less than five minutes for an unvaccinated person standing in the breath of a person with Covid-19 to become infected with almost… certainty ... if the infected persons have the high viral load of the delta variant of the Sars-CoV-2 // Even so ... if both the infected and the non-infected person wear well-fitting FFP2 masks, the maximum risk of infection after 20 minutes is hardly more than one per 1,000, even at the shortest distance. If their masks fit poorly, the probability of infection increases to about 4%. If both wear well-fitting medical masks, the virus is likely to be transmitted within 20 minutes with a maximum probability of 10%. [Such] infection probabilities ... indicate the upper limit of the risk [in the extreme assumption the expired is undiluted: i]n daily life, the actual probability of infection is certainly 10 to 100 times smaller
FFP2, both, fitting: max 0.1% at 20min; FFP2, both, loose: 4% at 20min; surgical, both, fitting, 10% at 20min - exaggerated theoretical values.
The study is accompanied by a video demonstration showing the motion of expired vapour from a dummy in thte different cases (no mask, surgical, FFP2 loose, FFP2 tight) at https://youtu.be/uuvruHuob7s https://youtu.be/uuvruHuob7s
There is also an article on MedicalXpress, https://medicalxpress.com/news/2021-12-maximum-covid-infection-masks.html https://medicalxpress.com/news/2021-12-maximum-covid-infecti...
> In their calculations of the risk of infection, the Göttingen team considered a number of factors that had not previously been included in comparable studies ... The team also considered that droplets that people spread when they breathe or speak dry while in the air and become lighter. This means that they remain in the air longer but also have an increased virus concentration as equal size droplets directly after release. When inhaled, the opposite happens: the particles take up water again, grow like a drop in the cloud and therefore deposit more easily in the respiratory tract
Original research article: Gholamhossein Bagheri et al, An upper bound on one-to-one exposure to infectious human respiratory particles, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (2021) http://dx.doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2110117118 http://dx.doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2110117118
@Dan: title: the specification 'from COVID' is required to make the title meaningful ("protection" from what); that of 'MaxPlank' is to discriminate this study (also through the timeframe of this post) from assumedly a large number of others on this very general topic.
- karmakaze 5y agoThe addition of (from COVID) in the title actually made is mean something different than what the details say--I interpreted the revised title to mean 'masks worn protect against getting COVID', as 'from' indicates a direction, where all our data has historically been protects against transmitting it. Discussions about masks in headlines in this period is implicitly COVID-specific or related without having to say from/to/or-anything-else.
- mdp2021 5y agoFirst of all, it is the original title itself to create the doubt: it is «Masks protect...», and I am not sure it is a primary interpretation to understand 'protect' as "protect from doing harm". What would work to that interpretation is 'protect others from COVID' - but then, that is still "protection from COVID", hence the ambiguity is intrinsic. About the timeframe: the post is not meant to be an occasional drop-and-forget. HN is not the Soviet Pravda, or its successors Reddit and Twitter, a frantic magma of imprisoning present where the past (dystopically and horrifically) is largely unattainable. We have functions and direct enough ways to retrieve by period and explore the corpus, of submissions and comments, as a navigable block. Post 1 is the submission 'YCombinator' on Oct 9, 2006 - and it's the directmost query one could do. This only increases the weight of the already given value of clarity. This given, about the content and meaning: it seems the idea of the article in fact is, that 'Masks protect from COVID' in general, not just in one direction; only, the (extremely important, I would say) detail does not appear so clearly: > We find ... that social distancing alone [... etc]. If only the susceptible wears a face mask with infectious speaking at a distance of 1.5 m, the upper bound drops very significantly; that is, with a surgical mask, the upper bound reaches 90% after 30 min, and, with an FFP2 mask, it remains at about 20% even after 1 h. When both wear a… mask... -- Typical conversation of yore: Armageddon. -- Distancing, 3 meters: 90% risk in "just minutes". -- Infective no-mask vis-a-vis surgical: 90% risk in 30 minutes. -- Infective no-mask vis-a-vis FFP2: 20% risk in 60 minutes. [etc. This is how I read it.] This did not appear in the divulgative article (unless - it is clear from having written MaxPlanck without a 'c' that the writer is fighting falling on head bricks while trying to achieve decent posting), and I missed it completely from the abstract of the research article. Abridgements are a help, not a certified document - collaborative verification would be highly valuable.