3 ms·
It's a lot easier of a question when you ask it outright. Men and women are separate, but equal. They are indeed entitled to slightly different things legally
by smoldesu 5y ago
It's a lot easier of a question when you ask it outright.
Men and women are separate, but equal. They are indeed entitled to slightly different things legally speaking, but the differences are so marginal that any perceived benefits would almost certainly never outweigh the cost of transitioning. If you legally feel like you should be acknowledged as a different gender, it makes sense that we offer the faculties to let people do that. There is no risk of "abuse" as there would be with age transitioning, and if there are then it should raise important questions about how we treat men and women in today's society. If you've got any examples of how someone could misuse this or take advantage of the system, I'd love to pick through them with you.
And, I'm sure you've already heard this quite a bit, but sex and gender are still distinct. You can have gender-affirming surgery and hormone replacement therapy, but a true sex change is not really possible or even feasible in many respects. This is important, because it's certainly true that male and female bodies react differently on a medical level, and separating sex from gender allows us to account for that. Age is closer to sex than it is to gender, in that it has biological implications and an overall meaning that can't be separated from who you are. If you want to identify as a different age, it's a free country: very little is stopping you from telling people you're 20 when you've lived for 30 years. But even the few people who do feel dysphoric about their age are probably never going to go through the trouble. That's why self-expression exists: you can live in any way that makes you happy, "be" any age that you want to be, dress with whatever clothes you want and give yourself whatever name you choose, within the confines of the law. This isn't just a good thing, it's a litmus test for freedom.
As I've stated before, age is not arbitrary. We set an age of consent to correspond with sexual maturity and responsibility. We set a legal drinking age to discourage younger people from acting on impulse and inadvertently causing self-harm. We make people wait until they're 16 for a drivers license so that we have a baseline expectation of motor function and risk management. These things are socially decided, but backed with logic. Gender is similarly socially decided, but largely backed on prejudice and history that nobody bothered to challenge. It's important that we revisit these topics as time goes on, and it's important that we bicker about them online: if we don't argue about them, we don't progress as a people. I think the status quo is better than ever though, and the downsides to letting thoroughly convicted individuals change the gender that the government acknowledges them as is an important landmark in that march of progress. Where should it go next? It's up for debate, but trying to draw up a false dichotomy only buries the lede and makes it harder to engage people on the subject. I'm glad you were able to ask your question in a straightforward manner though, I hope this helps.