3 ms·
The state of game development jobs, with near universal "crunch", lower pay than much of the industry, sexual harassment and discrimination everywhere, suggests
by tsimionescu 5y ago
The state of game development jobs, with near universal "crunch", lower pay than much of the industry, sexual harassment and discrimination everywhere, suggests that the market is not correcting for these things, isn't it?
And, of course, all this while gaming is a booming industry attracting (and requiring) workers in droves.
- Asooka 5y agoDon't extrapolate to the whole sector from a few high profile failures. There are places like e.g. Hello Games, who don't do crunch, and my friends at Ubisoft tell me they do only a little overtime right before shipping. If you watch SIGGRAPH, you can see a lot of good real-time graphics research come out of DICE, Epic, Unity. I doubt those people are doing much overtime either. Not that I would go work there, being a game developer is below my pay grade, but not every place is as bad as ActiBlizz.
- tsimionescu 5y agoSure, but it is much more the norm than in other industries, at the very least. And Ubisoft had their own sexual misconduct and discrimination scandal quite recently[0]. [0] https://kotaku.com/ubisoft-ceo-and-others-blamed-for-institutional-harassm-1847306435 https://kotaku.com/ubisoft-ceo-and-others-blamed-for-institu...
- eru 5y ago> The state of game development jobs, with near universal "crunch", lower pay than much of the industry, sexual harassment and discrimination everywhere, suggests that the market is not correcting for these things, isn't it? It totally is! So first, I suspect crunch time sort-of works. In the sense that it allows you to bring out a product a bit sooner, but burn out your people in the process. The game industry is as bad an employer as it can get away with, because so many people are eager to join. That's why the game industry can mostly get away with low pay and crunch time. Working your standard programming job at Boring Inc is less cool, so people demand more in return. More money, more perks, better treatment. It's all about equilibria. So if you want to 'fix' the game industry, the way to go about this is to make the alternatives more appealing. There are plenty of example where regulation (or similar) tried to fix unsavoury industries by fiat. Eg look at Orange in France. Orange is the former French telecoms monopolist. As such, they employ way more people than current management wants. But firing people is extremely hard in France. As unintended consequence, management has no incentive to make the life of marginal employees bearable, and every incentive to avert their eyes from bullying, etc. Cue the French complaining how 'neoliberalism' causes suicides at Orange. https://www.dw.com/en/france-orange-top-bosses-caused-employee-suicides-rules-court/a-51751140 https://www.dw.com/en/france-orange-top-bosses-caused-employ...
- tsimionescu 5y ago> The game industry is as bad an employer as it can get away with, because so many people are eager to join. That's why the game industry can mostly get away with low pay and crunch time. This is the whole thing, you've laid it bare here. The games industry is exploiting it's workers' passion. If there were game workers' unions, we'd see a lot less of this type of behavior, as has been shown time and time again.
- eru 5y agoThere's already minimal barriers to entry for starting your own game company. So employees already get plenty of choice. I have no clue how a union is supposed to help here. Perhaps they can restrict who can work in the games industry? Just like they keep non-union people from appearing in Hollywood movies?
- tsimionescu 5y agoUnions work by helping employees get leverage so they can actually negotiate working conditions with the company. Any individual developer is easily replaced, but the whole workforce is not. The current state of employee "choice" between companies all colluding to offer the same conditions is no choice at all.
- eru 5y agoHow can they all collude, when entry into the industry is so easy? It's hard to keep big conspiracies alive. You can literally form a new game company in your bed room right now, and any people do. Someone could break rank, hire programmers for a dollar more or an hour less crunch time, and still make a killing, wouldn't they?
- tsimionescu 5y agoNo, they couldn't. There are a handful of companies making almost all traditional games, a handful more of indie successes, and then a terrible morass of companies making gambling traps called "mobile games". If you're not working for EA, Activision-Blizzard, Ubisoft, Sony, Microsoft, Bethesda, Valve, Bungie, Epic, Rockstar, or Riot Games, you are almost certainly not working on a major video game project, and certainly not on a game that will make hundreds of millions of dollars in profit. And conversely, if all of the developers on, say, World of Warcraft were to strike tomorrow, Blizzard would not be able to afford to replace them. That's the power of a union. I have no idea where you got this idea that it's easy to start a gaming company. Unless you plan on making a mobile game, they're a very hard industry to enter, like all other art industries.