3 ms·
> The money goes to doctors and to hospitals. For doctors, that pay is well deserved given the exorbitant student loans that doctors carry, and the ridiculous
by mschuster91 5y ago
> The money goes to doctors and to hospitals.
For doctors, that pay is well deserved given the exorbitant student loans that doctors carry, and the ridiculous shift length and other work related issues.
For hospitals? Here's the real deal where costs can be saved - 25% of hospital expenses is administration expenses [1], and 8% is profit margin [2].
Convert hospitals to non-profit operations owned by a single-payer insurance and immediately save a lot of costs across the entire board.
[1] https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/journal-article/2014/sep/comparison-hospital-administrative-costs-eight-nations-us https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/journal-articl...
[2]: https://www.americanprogress.org/article/high-price-hospital-care/ https://www.americanprogress.org/article/high-price-hospital...
- munk-a 5y agoHaving seen the working conditions of testers in the video game industry I can say that: > For doctors, that pay is well deserved given the exorbitant student loans that doctors carry, and the ridiculous shift length and other work related issues. Is pure BS. Many professions end up carrying student loan repayment for decades and that isn't usually used as an excuse for increased pay - additionally there are plenty of professions (and folks working two jobs) that end up putting in more hours than doctors. These costs aren't describable using either of those causes. Additionally, most hospitals are already technically non-profit organizations - it's just that administrators can end up having purely ridiculous take-homes. A single payer system probably is the solution but mostly because of the price setting and ease of billing - if you compare Canada to the US you'll notice that the Board of Physicians sets procedure and drug pricing provincially rather than being left up to a patchwork of random private corporations. (As an aside, I'm both a Canadian-American dualie (American first - I emigrated to Canada) and I work in a company that tracks US Healthcare insurance information)
- huitzitziltzin 5y ago>> For doctors, that pay is well deserved given the exorbitant student loans that doctors carry, and the ridiculous shift length and other work related issues. Disagree on many, many counts. - do you know many specialists? Ridiculous hours are not part of the picture post-residency! - deserved why? On the basis of what? More than a taxi driver who works long hours? A convenience store worker who works long hours? - student loans are not that hard to pay off at US (medical) salaries! There are surgical specialities where the average pay is north of $500k. Family medicine and pediatrics make a lot less. >> Convert hospitals to non-profit operations owned by a single-payer insurance and immediately save a lot of costs across the entire board - converting hospitals to non profits isn’t going to do much because most are already not for profit. - you save money with single payer (ideally) by paying lower prices… which is my original point. There is administrative bloat and burden in the system but it’s on the order of 10% of spending, not 40%. And, just to be clear, you have to administer hospitals in single payer too so you don’t get rid of those costs entirely. I can support single payer, but I support it to pay lower prices to doctors and hospitals (and pharma, but as I noted above that’s not a big slice of the pie either).