7 ms·
If I was going to write some propaganda to try and whitewash the staggering amount of wealth and power is held by American oligarchs this is what I would do: 1
by pydry 5y ago
If I was going to write some propaganda to try and whitewash the staggering amount of wealth and power is held by American oligarchs this is what I would do:
1) Write an article about income inequality. Wealth inequality is 100x worse than income inequality - http://metrocosm.com/wealth-vs-income-inequality/ http://metrocosm.com/wealth-vs-income-inequality/ but if you just smoothly transition from talking about economic inequality to income inequality, not only is it not as bad, the reader becomes a much bigger part of it and hence you become less of a part of it.
2) Ignore PPP entirely. If a Slovakian gets paid 5x less than you do in New York and also has 5x cheaper haircuts, you should probably feel a bit guilty about that.
3) Focus on personal responsibility. This is an effective technique. It was used to turn jaywalking into a crime in the early 20th century. It was used to make the litter epidemic of the mid 20th century Not McDonalds Or Coke's Fault. It was used to shift responsibility from Oil supermajor CEOs on to suburban white middle class soccer moms and voila - reduced pressure.
Just remember, as the article says: "If you want to reduce global inequality and support poorer people, you do have this opportunity. You can donate some of your money."
- s1artibartfast 5y agoWhy ignore ppp? Why feel bad if two lives are equal in all respects? Non PPP only matters if someone moves countries.
- notahacker 5y agoThe dataset doesn't ignore PPP, it's expressed in "international dollars" which is a standard PPP adjustment to US levels. That's not really discussed because it's an utterly standard thing to do in cross-country comparisons, but the article might have been better if it talked about the fact the data is PPP adjusted so the actual dollar amounts earned in the poorer countries are even lower, and the fact that PPP adjustments aren't perfect so people on $6.70 of imputed US purchasing power can still pay rent
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThe parent post argued that the article would have been more impactful if it ignored PPP. It also said people should feel guilty if they have the same PPP, but higher salary without adjusting. This makes no sense to me. This is the point I am pushing back on.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bee_rider 5y agoThey are describing what they'd do to write a paper to "whitewash the staggering amount of wealth and power is held by American oligarchs," so, a list of things that should appear plausible to the reader, but which are fundamentally misleading. Ignoring PPP is a great way to get numerical differences without QOL differences, as you point out. I haven't gotten to the article yet, but I'm pretty sure this is intended as a criticism or the article.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoBut ignoring PPP does the opposite of whitewash the accumulated wealth. Ignoring PPP makes the disparity greater, not less
- bee_rider 5y agoIncreasing the disparity between countries reinforces the argument "conditions in your country are so great, stop talking about your internal income inequality" which is, I think, what the original comment was implying to be the point here. Looking at the article, it uses the term "international dollars" instead of "PPP adjusted dollars," so I think the original comment just missed that the dollars are actually adjusted. It makes sense if you read the original comment as a criticism of the article ("whitewash the staggering amount of wealth and power is held by American oligarchs" is, I think, pretty clearly a bad thing to do) which just missed that the dollars in the article were adjusted.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoyeah, it sounds like we interpreted "whitewash the staggering amount of wealth and power is held by American oligarchs" in different ways. I took it as minimizing the disparity between rich and poor countries. I don't know how to reconcile your interpretation with the idea that someone should feel guilty for having a higher dollar income but the same PPP income as someone else.
- commandlinefan 5y agoWhat does PPP stand for in this context? I was confused by his example, too - it seems like he's suggesting that if somebody is paid less but has a proportionally smaller cost of living, I should still feel bad about that? Am I being insensitive for not? I feel sorry for people who are living in squalor, not people who have similar lives to my own.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoPPP = Purchasing Power Parity. It is exactly as you described. We have the same purchasing power if in my city I make $10/day and a beer costs me $10, while in your city, you make $5/day and a beer costs $5.
- ahelwer 5y agoI've been thinking - continually I hear the way to help with a problem is to donate money to a charity. But is there a single social ill that has actually been solved (not ameliorated - permanently solved) through a bunch of individuals donating money to a charity to solve it? Is there any track record of success whatsoever?
- shashwat_udit 5y agoYes. The March of Dimes fundraising campaign provided the funding to Salk and Sabin to create the polio vaccine.
- mdorazio 5y agoThis is a good question, but it's also kind of tricky because many (maybe most) social charities aren't really setup to tackle issues that can be solved without continuing money input. Let's take education in poor countries as an example - unless everyone stops having children or the underlying socioeconomic fabric changes significantly, you're going to have an effectively infinite number of children that need to be educated, and the only way to do that is to continue paying for facilities, teachers, materials, etc. Other charities, like those that are setup to cure specific illnesses, can accomplish their mission on reasonable timeframes.
- commandlinefan 5y ago> a single social ill that has actually been solved ... through a bunch of individuals donating money to a charity If not, then one of two things are true: 1) Money can't solve social ills 2) Not enough people who have the means to do so are willing to voluntarily sacrifice to solve a social ill Either way, that suggests that taxation/wealth redistribution solutions is similarly doomed (unless you're willing to do it by force).
- refurb 5y agoSure. Cystic Fibrosis Foundation funded research that resulted in a near-cure for CF patients with particular mutations. https://www.cff.org/node/871 https://www.cff.org/node/871 ”More than 20 years ago, the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation took the pioneering step of providing research funding to Aurora Biosciences (now Vertex Pharmaceuticals, Inc.) to identify and develop the first treatments for the underlying cause of CF. Driven by the relentless determination of the CF community, those investments led to the development of multiple transformative therapies to treat CF.”