4 ms·
> election fraud where Republicans have submitted 425 election bills across 49 states because they see the election as fraudulent. Are those misinformation or j
by pjc50 5y ago
> election fraud where Republicans have submitted 425 election bills across 49 states because they see the election as fraudulent. Are those misinformation or just politically inconvenient truths?
Ultimately it has to be determined whether the election was or was not fraudulent. By some process outside of both the political parties, that they are capable of both respecting. If that ceases to happen - once the parties cease respecting court rulings and public inquiries - then the ability to hold free and fair elections starts to collapse and you get power grabs like that.
(IMO the US federal system should simply not let states run Federal elections, they keep having to sue them to ensure fairness)
- sleepysysadmin 5y ago>Ultimately it has to be determined whether the election was or was not fraudulent. That seems to be the problem. We can't seem to say anything that might challenge it. Here's 425 bills in 49 states proving conclusively that the republicans believe it was fraudulent, but literally nobody saying anything >By some process outside of both the political parties, that they are capable of both respecting. If that ceases to happen - once the parties cease respecting court rulings and public inquiries - then the ability to hold free and fair elections starts to collapse and you get power grabs like that. Oh no, we went the other direction. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republican_efforts_to_restrict_voting_following_the_2020_presidential_election https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republican_efforts_to_restrict... So very clearly the republicans believe the election was fraudulent. What is the democrat response? Assert the republicans are attacking democracy. Which is absolutely not the case. Lets just hypothetical this? Lets say the republicans fail to fix the fraudulent election? Lets say 425 bills are failed and nothing changes. Do you believe the republicans just accept their fate? No, that'll be civil war for sure. >(IMO the US federal system should simply not let states run Federal elections, they keep having to sue them to ensure fairness) For example, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Election_Integrity_Act_of_2021 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Election_Integrity_Act_of_2021 Georgia has passed significant changes. Biden calls it racially discriminatory but I fail to see how that's the case. DOJ is suing and I guess will prove how its racist but I dont see how that works. Georgian republicans very clearly believe the election was fraudulent and the cheating party is calling them racists without any legitimatcy to the claim. Its not like the bill says black people cant vote. What's the alternative? It certainly means democracy falls if this didn't become law. What's very interesting and I cant wait to see in 2023. Will georgia flip back?
- mistermann 5y ago> Ultimately it has to be determined whether the election was or was not fraudulent. I honestly think it would be preferable if we changed it to "Ultimately it has to be declared whether the election was or was not fraudulent." To me, this is more palatable as "determined" implies the unequivocal truth is known, something which is plausibly not possible at least under the current design of the system. My intuition is that conspiracy theorists would at least somewhat prefer this as the possibility of inaccuracy is explicitly acknowledged, although I wonder if normal people would find it unpalatable.
- pjc50 5y agoI would accept "agreed", but see the 2000 election: quite possibly it was wrongly determined, but the Democrats agreed to concede and largely haven't mentioned it since. Whereas you can already see Republicans "pre-declaring" that an election that hasn't happened yet will be fraudulent if they don't win.
- mistermann 5y agoSo we have (with my subjective and surely biased interpretations of the meaning & "epistemic status/quality"): 1. [Current Approach] determined - "was 'discovered' to be X, regardless if was actually discovered (as opposed to estimated)" - decision made by bureaucrats/experts &/or courts | Invalid: it is not necessarily possible to discover what is true (under the current system) 2a. declared - "was decided to be categorized as X, regardless of actual(!) ultimate truth" - decision made by courts | Valid: acknowledges that the actual truth is not known, but fr pragmatic reasons a decision is made so we can move on (which is what actually happens now, but we do not speak truthfully about the details, which causes anger, which often has complex, outsized systemic consequences) 2b. agreed - "all parties voted to categorize as X, regardless of actual(!) ultimate truth, with or without (optional) formal complaints*" - decision made by party officials | Valid: roughly, same as "declared", but the decision is voluntary by party officials, rather than decided by courts What do you think of this way of thinking about it? I find #1 fairly repulsive, but the exact same outcome recorded/discussed as 2a or 2b I find much less problematic.