5 ms·
People that advocate this are advocating for lowering the quality of life. Long term it raises the price per square foot and makes it harder to have the space y
by colechristensen 5y ago
People that advocate this are advocating for lowering the quality of life. Long term it raises the price per square foot and makes it harder to have the space you want and need.
- epistasis 5y agoSorry, but that doesn't make any sense. More housing means less sqft per person? The chain of reasoning to get to that conclusion must be long, because it is certainly not obvious.
- ryandrake 5y agoAlmost all "moar housing" discussions, at least on HN, call for building medium-and-dense urban apartments, which tend to be smaller than average sizes of housing. You never hear YIMBY advocates calling for building more 3500 sq.ft. single family suburban or rural homes.
- davidw 5y agoIt's entirely possible to build large and dense. I knew a pretty wealthy guy in Padova whose family had an enormous home that all happened to be on the 2nd floor of a 4 story building.
- spamizbad 5y agoI don't understand how my quality of life will improve if I go from my current 1500 sqft home to a 3500 sqft home. Living near shops, walking around town with my family and being able to ride my bike brings me more joy than a larger home office. I suppose if I had a larger family I would want more bedrooms. But we are done growing our family at this point - and mine is roughly the size of the median, so I don't see why we need to flood the market with homes that are too big.
- _Wintermute 5y agoPerhaps slightly off-topic, but as someone who has spent most of my time living in European cities these house sizes are just mind-blowing to me. 1500 sqft is 140 m^2, my first apartment was 30m^2. I can't imagine what you would put in a 3500 sqft (325 m^2) house, never mind something like answering the door if you were at the other side of your house.
- redisman 5y agoDifferent people like different things
- davidw 5y agoThis is the entire point! Let the market provide the different things people want. No one is telling ranchers in Montana that they have to live in a walkable neighborhood in San Francisco. But most places do have laws on the books preventing more of those kinds of walkable neighborhoods from being produced for those that prefer that.
- colechristensen 5y agoBut it’s not an option when investors buy up and chase away people who want to be where they are the way they are. It’s a race to the bottom for the most density. It isn’t people building what they want for themselves but investors incrementally getting people accustomed to less and less for increasing amounts of money. If you zoned more places to be walkable and lowered rent for the kinds of places people wanted to walk to you wouldn’t have to cram people into a few desirable places.
- davidw 5y agoI get your worry, but I think you have some of the cause/effects backwards. Investors invest in places that do not allow enough housing. The best way to stick it to the investors is to produce abundant housing. https://www.vox.com/22524829/wall-street-housing-market-blackrock-bubble https://www.vox.com/22524829/wall-street-housing-market-blac... > If you zoned more places to be walkable and lowered rent for the kinds of places people wanted to walk to you wouldn’t have to cram people into a few desirable places. Yes, we should absolutely relax zoning! But rents are set by the market, by and large. You drop them by allowing housing to be built to meet market demand.
- allturtles 5y agoThis is a distraction from GP's nonsensical point. How does building more 500-1500 sqft apartments increase the price-per-square-foot of any type of housing, big or small?
- jlhawn 5y agoThere isn't a shortage of 3500 sq.ft. single family homes in suburban or rural areas in the way that there is a shortage of apartments/condos in high-rent urban areas. There isn't much opposition to this kind of new development. The major limiting factor for demand for this type of development is commute times (to everything, not just jobs). This is not the first choice of many people who would prefer to live closer to an urban center if not for higher prices caused by low supply of housing in such high-demand locations.
- Manuel_D 5y agoYIMBY advocates push for medium and dense urban apartments because dense cities are where housing shortages are most severe, and the only way to effect a net-increase in the supply of housing is to replace less-dense housing with more dense housing. Or convert public spaces like parks into more housing, but people tend to like parks. Rural areas aren't experiencing a chronic housing shortage, in fact they're typically experiencing population decline.
- colinmhayes 5y agoIt turns out that plenty of people prefer 1500 sq ft. homes in walkable areas. Building more of those doesn't mean we get rid of 3500 sq ft. homes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoAt a minimum, more housing means some people have more than zero square feet. But I believe that the GP's point is that "more housing" usually means "more, primarily smaller, units". And that may in fact be true. Though, if you can get a small apartment rather than live in your car, you're still moving up, even if the average square feet per unit moves down.
- zbrozek 5y agoI don't follow. How does increasing supply also increase prices?
- davidw 5y agoPlenty of people live quite well in denser environments, and in any event, it should be a choice. Right now, in so many places in the US, it is not. Forcing people to have space is wrecking our environment, causing prices to go through the roof, which in turn contributes to homelessness and various and sundry other problems.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Plenty of people live quite well in denser environments Very few do. > and in any event, it should be a choice. It is a choice, if you can afford not to. That's why the people in those environments are disproportionately both the very poor who can't afford to choose and the very rich who can afford the expense of mitigating the harms; the people who aren't super rich but can afford to choose just tend to choose not to live in dense environments.
- halfmatthalfcat 5y ago>> Plenty of people live quite well in denser environments > Very few do. So the people living in NYC, LA, Chicago, etc are not living well? That's news. Tell me how else I'm not living. Outside of the very core of these cities, you can live, and live well while benefitting off of all the things large urban centers provide (culturally, financially, etc).
- dragonwriter 5y ago> So the people living in NYC, LA, Chicago, etc are not living well? Not the ones that aren't making significantly above national median income, no. High income work (and even more so large acal5 capital ownership) makes it possible for people to afford to mitigate the downsides of dense living, which is why the presence of high wage work and capital returns leads to more people voluntarily accepting sense living conditions. Eliminating the choice of low-density living by reducing availability will force more people who can’t afford to mitigate the downsides of dense living into it. (We need more dense housing in places where it will relieve the problem of people being unhoused; those people already typically experience dense conditions with added downsides; but forcing people who would otherwise choose to be housed in lense-dense conditions into dense conditions is reducing the quality of life.)
- 8note 5y agoLong term, the price per square foot goes up. Even without this building, the price per square foot has gone up. Are you sure that's causation and not correlation?
- driverdan 5y agoQuality of life is not measured per square foot of space.