4 ms·
Shocking as it was, the Collateral Murder video was nothing exceptional. It didn’t reveal any secret truth or grand conspiracy. The unfortunate fact is that thi
by jl6 5y ago
Shocking as it was, the Collateral Murder video was nothing exceptional. It didn’t reveal any secret truth or grand conspiracy. The unfortunate fact is that this is just what war is like.
War means high-stakes decision-making using low-quality information by agents who are human and therefore fallible. War means chaos and brutality and unjust death on a grand scale. When you vote for war, this is what you get, no matter how good your intentions. It happens every day in every war. The only difference here is that it was caught on camera and released.
So what did Assange achieve by releasing this video? We already knew war is bad. The existence of the video just evidences that the US military is good at record-keeping, which if anything points to an institution that cares about the actions of its soldiers and is capable, in principle, of holding them to account, rather than just unleashing men with guns to do random unsupervised violence, which is what war looks like in many corners of the world.
The people to get angry with are the politicians and media pundits who who rush other peoples’ kids to war for trumped up jingoistic reasons, not the kids who inevitably fuck up the operation on the ground.
- pessimizer 5y agoWhy report on, or even prevent war crimes? You can't help but commit war crimes, and you can't help but cover them up, even if your intentions were wonderful. What's important is that we're theoretically capable of holding people to account, even if in practice we're burning videotapes of torture.
- peppermint_tea 5y ago100% agree on everything you said. I would just add that all this violence should be shown without any kind of censorship to (in this case) the american people at supper time. I wonder how fast the public opinion would change then...
- the_optimist 5y agoA pretty smart guy once said, “if wars can be started by lies, perhaps peace can be started by the truth.”
- busymom0 5y agoFor those unaware, that was said by Assange.
- frabbit 5y agoThose kids don't just fuck operations -- they fuck up other people. Then they get home and become cops. When are the suppressed Abu Ghraib tapes coming out? It's all terribly sad isn't it? Best thing we can do it sweep it under the carpet and make sure it's easy for all the people who might be upset by it to not see it.