4 ms·
This is the kind of thing that the CFAA is supposed to be for. If a fired employee broke into the office and welded the HR department's door shut, they'd end up
by josephcsible 5y ago
This is the kind of thing that the CFAA is supposed to be for. If a fired employee broke into the office and welded the HR department's door shut, they'd end up in prison, and what these people are doing is just as bad.
- wayoutthere 5y agoIf this is illegal, the law is wrong. This has become the case in enough places that the law is losing relevance in our lives.
- josephcsible 5y agoWhy do you think it should be legal to sabotage your employer's systems in response to a labor dispute?
- wayoutthere 5y agoBecause they are sabotaging labor’s ability to negotiate fairly. Turnabout is fair game.
- josephcsible 5y agoIf you try to buy a car, but you and the seller fail to reach a deal, is it okay for you to let the air out of their tires, since they sabotaged your ability to negotiate fairly?
- wayoutthere 5y agoBuying a certain car at a certain price isn’t a requirement to feeding your family. Making enough money to buy food is.
- gruez 5y ago>Buying a certain car at a certain price isn’t a requirement to feeding your family It isn't? In many parts of the US a car is needed to hold a job, or to even get to the grocery store (which might be miles away). Moreover, grocery stores do provide the means to "feed your family". Does that mean looting/vandalizing them is fair game after failing to "negotiate" with them?
- wayoutthere 5y agoLet’s play word games, that’s really productive.
- gruez 5y agoI fail to see how my comment is "play[ing] word games".
- saas_sam 5y agoWorking a specific job at a specific price isn't a requirement for feeding your family either. Neither is living in a specific location for a specific rent price, for that matter. The idea that you are entitled to whatever job you want to work at a price that you think is fair is just as absurd as insisting you are entitled to a specific car at a specific price. If you have somehow gotten yourself into a position where you are supporting a family based on knowing how to do one thing that you can only do for one company, sorry but you either massive screwed up your life (unlikely) or you are afraid to step outside your comfort zone and work elsewhere (likely).
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoWhy is it somehow less fair than a company required to keep overpaid general laborers?
- slothtrop 5y agoAnti-union laws would be, but firing everyone isn't tantamount to that. Future applicants still have the ability to organize.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoWhy is the law wrong? By what principle does a group of striking employees have some intrinsic God-given right (or right conferred by some other source of truth, outside the law) to sabotage the company that they are protesting? Is the company their property, that they have veto power over hiring? Is the labor force their property? If there is some property-like interest that grants these rights, then under what circumstances would that interest became their property rather than the original worker's? Is it strictly first come, first serve? Is there a vesting period during which this right accrues? Are the striking employees as a group to be considered a form of government, that they may regulate hiring and firing? What elevates this right or interest over other cherished principles, such as free association? Or do the strikers simply wish to subjugate such principles to serve their own self-interest? I believe that you propose mob rule. It is no surprise, then, that you are in conflict with a nation ruled by laws, rather than by mobs and strongmen.
- tedivm 5y agoThese are strikers, not fired employees, and what is happening is a protest. It's no different than mailing in a bunch of applications, it's just digital instead. They aren't burning down the offices (although I think it's fair to point out that most of our labor rights do come from unions threatening- and in some cases doing- things exactly like that).
- bhhaskin 5y agoExcept they are fired employees. Kellogg fired them. Wether you believe that's right or wrong, let's not distort reality.
- sdfjksbdf 5y agoThey haven't fired them. They're beginning to attempt to start to replace them. "Rutgers University professor Todd Vachon, who teaches classes about labor relations, said he's not sure the company will be able to hire enough workers to replace the ones who are out on strike in the current economy, and Kellogg's may have a hard time finding people willing to cross a picket line." https://www.cbsnews.com/news/kelloggs-will-replace-striking-workers-after-offer-is-rejected/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/kelloggs-will-replace-striking-...
- bhhaskin 5y agoIf they are permanently replacing the old workers that pretty much means they no longer have a job. So yes. They have been fired. Kellogg has announced that.
- gremlinsinc 5y agoIn an economy where finding workers is really tough, where target, walmart, etc have had to raise min wage to 15+ and add free college tuition.... They cannot fire the employees in question, they can only replace them 1:1 and w/ the amount of publicity, and the striking it's bound to deter a lot of potential applicants, and with people using automated and manual methods to spoof applications --some presumably locally even going through the entire application process, going through training, and quitting day one on the floor... seems to me like it'll bleed Kellogg's dry long before they ever find the employees they need to continue. They're more likely to fully automate 100% of the plant before they find the staff they need for permanent replacements. I'm seriously betting Kellogg's does a full reversal, esp when profits start to fall, and revenue expectations get dwarfed by the boycotts that are ongoing. Personally, I can do without ever buying poptarts, eggo waffles, or any of their cereal. There's plenty of alternative junk food out there to fill the gap.
- aaomidi 5y agoImagine having this stance on employees striking for a better compensation. Yeah fuck it if this is bad, then I definitely don't want to be good.
- cwkoss 5y agoCFAA is a bad law: it's excessively broad and can apply to almost anything. However, Kellogg's is soliciting job applications from the public. Automating the submission of a single application is clearly legal, but submitting many with the intention of overloading digital systems is clearly illegal. IMO, this case is legally ambiguous because they are using a digital system to overwhelm a human system. The public is 'authorized' to submit one application, so it's hard to say submitting many applications is unauthorized, unless done with intent of crashing servers.
- confidantlake 5y agoDoes this mean that spam is illegal? I get so many emails that they overwhelm my ability to process the legitimate ones.
- scollet 5y agoIt's not the same and I don't see why we would need to put someone in jail for your analogy.
- josephcsible 5y agoYou don't think there should be jail time for breaking into and vandalizing a building?