4 ms·
>If picketing IRL factories is allowed, what would the law be on DDOS of an online business by union members? I'm pretty sure union/striking isn't a valid excu
by gruez 5y ago
>If picketing IRL factories is allowed, what would the law be on DDOS of an online business by union members?
I'm pretty sure union/striking isn't a valid excuse to violate laws, and that "picketing IRL factories" doesn't violate any laws (ie. they do in on the sidewalk/public roads).
- g_sch 5y agoPerhaps surprisingly, whether picket lines are lawful is often a matter of legal contention when there's a strike. Company owners argue that they are obstructive (which is at least partially the point), and courts often grant injunctions or restraining orders placing limits on the size, location, or even existence of picket lines. A coal company in Alabama recently won a restraining order that fully prohibited a picket line at their mine: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/judge-issues-restraining-order-against-umwa-in-strike-on-warrior-met-coal/ar-AAQ4hIt https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/judge-issues-restraining-o...
- pc86 5y agoHave any of these restrictions been on people operating entirely on public property? The only ones I've ever seen typically entail trying to block access entirely, something that by definition almost requires access to private property unless you have a ton of people, which most picket lines don't.
- ziddoap 5y agoSubmitting a job application with false information does not violate any law that I am aware of (perhaps if it's a government position there is? I'm not sure). Manually submitting 50 job applications with false information also does not violate any laws that I am aware of. The focus then becomes on automation. But if I automate the job application process at 1 application/day, that's not illegal. So it becomes a balancing act between how fast I am automating, and how shoddily designed the application system is. I don't think it's as cut and dry as "this is illegal" or not.
- lordlimecat 5y agoThe intent to access systems in an unauthorized way in order to disrupt those systems-- the clear intent of this script-- would fall afoul of the rather broad CFAA.
- vageli 5y agoSending a single request to a website is not illegal. Hammering a website with thousands of requests per second with the intent of taking it down or making it inaccessible is. I agree it's not cut and dry but intent matters to some extent.
- ziddoap 5y agoIn the context of this specific scenario, I can agree to that. But in the context of the parent comment ("what would the law be on DDOS of an online business by union members"), there's a valid discussion to be had. If my code submits 1 fake application to each open position, once per hour or once per day (which is well within what I can do manually), and that code is shared between thousands of striking workers (and their supporters), and that results in downtime or inaccessibility, should that be illegal? If so, why? Would it be different if there wasn't code, but just thousands of strikers submitting applications as fast as they manually can and as fast as the website allows? At what point does the responsibility lie with the company who isn't rate-limiting or captcha-ing?
- colejohnson66 5y agoWith the CFAA, it's actual entirely possible that the person who wrote the code is entirely at fault if their intent was that multiple people run malicious code. Courts aren't black and white and take intent and amount of damage into account. There's no hard and fast "number" on how many people makes a DDOS. In fact, the service (site) doesn't even need to be hampered to be considered a DOS. Just having HR have to filter through tens of thousands of bogus applications can be considered a DOS.
- ziddoap 5y ago
- matheusmoreira 5y agoLaws written by the corporations to protect the corporations?
- Hamuko 5y agoI don't think repeatedly hitting F5 on a webpage is illegal.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoIntent and specifics matter; hitting F5 is legal, hitting F5 10 times a second intending to disrupt the site probably isn't. (IANAL, working from American perspective)