4 ms·
It is a culture problem, but it goes back before phones and Javascript. Even before that, application design was usually terrible. Apps were almost universally
by jfengel 5y ago
It is a culture problem, but it goes back before phones and Javascript.
Even before that, application design was usually terrible. Apps were almost universally ugly. Developers just aren't very good at it; it's not in their skill sets. They're good at making apps fast and small, but not at making them usable.
Rare companies would hire separate designers, and the apps could be functional and attractive, but they were the exception. It was a lot of money for something generally considered ancillary.
Browser-based apps get to leverage the work done by browser makers, who put in the effort to make toolkits that looked nice by default. They're not small or fast -- though Moore's Law has made them usable anyway. They also favor the things that designers like -- including not overwhelming the user with dense information. You can still use them badly, but by default any programmer can make an app that isn't awful.
There never was a golden age when developers made good, small, fast apps. It was usually a "pick two" situation, except by spending a lot of money. I'm just as happy to let my battery scream and not cringe at every single app that comes up, and so cheaply that they can give it away or cost dollars rather than tens or hundreds. Others disagree, of course, but I think the market tends to show a heavy thumb on one side of that scale.
- rowanG077 5y agoI disagree. Honestly since UI have become the primary domain of designers and "UX" experts they have regressed massively. 15 years ago you opened an application. The feel was consistent. I had a bar at the top which showed me the option in an straightforward manner which allowed to quickly explore and click through to relatively specialized things. Now, every app has it's own UI. And even worse everything is as hidden as possible in the name of being "clean".
- usrbinbash 5y ago>They're good at making apps fast and small, but not at making them usable. I don't know which apps you are talking about, but I use apps built and designed by developers every day, and they all work great. My problems start when Apps are NOT designed by developers, but rather people who have seen 100 videos about color theory, and know all the latest fonts their social media du jour is excited about, but very little about hardware, programming, and the difference between localhost and accessing a server over cheap WiFi from somewhere else on the planet. Because these are the "apps" which do something ridiculously simple, but somehow manage to eat up 2-3GiB of RAM and let the laptops fans spin out of control. >They're not small or fast -- though Moore's Law has made them usable anyway. Moores Law is over however, and there is no justification for an app that, say, plays locally stored mp3s to require 2GiB of RAM and 10% CPU. If an application thinks this is justified, it will get to know my good friend `rm -rf`, beacause I have vlc running in ncurses mode right now, playing my entire playlist, and its eating less memory than the terminal emulator it's running in ;-) The answer to bad software, and overloaded/overused/oversold frameworks is not "built more powerful computers" but "make better software". >There never was a golden age when developers made good, small, fast apps. Good != Beautifully designed. Good means small, fast, portable, reliable, easy to install, easy to learn, easy to remove, does its job.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoI wonder where the notion that productivity software should be “attractive” came from. Were whole businesses not built on VisiCalc? The registers at B&H photo in NYC appear to be some DOS terminal system, but the employees know the keyboard shortcuts by muscle memory and the interface’s reaction time is instantaneous. If that’s not good software I don’t know what is.
- jfengel 5y agoI wonder where the notion that productivity software should be “attractive” came from. From the people who make choices about where to put their money. You can get away with ugly software -- especially if you had something that worked 20 years ago and is still sufficient, and there is no alternative. But if users have the choice of something attractive, they'll pick it.
- usrbinbash 5y agoThat depends entirely on the use case and the user. I have the choice of many many many text editors and IDEs to manage my source code. What do I use? vim. In a terminal(-emulator). Why? Because I like my editor to be ready the moment my finger leaves the ENTER key, I like direct interoperability with the terminal, I like that I can hack together even the most absurd things in .vimrc, and I like that I have the same editor with the same settings on all servers I take care of, even when I connect to them via ssh. I also use vlc for playing audio and video. Are there players that have a more edge UX? Sure. Do they come with builtin-full support for almost all formats, have a tiny memory footprint, can be used to convert stuff, don't spy on me and can be controlled via a terminal (hello ncurses mode!)? Nope.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoVLC is bloated. Try mpv from https://mpv.io/ https://mpv.io/
- usrbinbash 5y ago