42 ms·
Like the "prisoner" example in the prisoner's dilemma, I feel this example adds a lot of baggage that makes things harder to understand or easier to misundersta
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
Like the "prisoner" example in the prisoner's dilemma, I feel this example adds a lot of baggage that makes things harder to understand or easier to misunderstand.
If we boil it right down then would you give 11 points of utility to a random billionaire or 10 points to a random poor person.
Most people would feel the 10 units would do more good, but I think by the terms of the setup, that's actually impossible since 11 is more than 10. But probably most people would give to the random poor person if we were talking about 100 dollars, not 100 util points, which presumably translates to many more utils for the poor person.
I think many people would also be "prioritarians" because they think it maximise utility but this example confuses matters as there's second order effects on other people's happiness to consider.
I get the feeling people will answer the second question when asked the first, though they're quite distinct, one is easily graspable and the other very abstract.
If you try to convert back from slightly more util points for the rich person to cash then it might translate into "would you give a poor person .0001 of a penny vs give a rich person 100 dollars" where the utility of each is closer and the choice seems kind of irrelevant because neither really benefits.
Once you scale it to something that the poor person would notice, you'd need to give many millions to the billionaire, at which point the diminishing returns kick in and so you end up with something absurd like give a poor person 5 dollars, versus give Billionaire 5 trillion, at which point you'd be creating so much extra utility out of thin air that some of it is maybe going to spill over to others (or lead to the Billionaire becoming King of the World and/or God and then have negative effects).
Which still doesn't really shed much light on things as you're now imagining how all that extra util wealth will impact others in a complex sequence of utility impacts and transfers.
- geysersam 5y agoI think your analysis is correct for many people, myself included. Even though I know the premise of the thought experiment is that the gifted boy receives more utility, that is just too hard to believe to take seriously. Your billionaire example makes the situation more clean and less influenced by my inability to accept the facts of the situation. If choosing between giving Bezos $100 or some dude $0.00001 I would probably just give the $100. The even cleaner version of this problem is the utility monster mentioned in the article.