9 ms·
EU Commission to open source software
- sofixa 5y agoSorry for the highly editorialised title, the original one is very bad and marketingy, and also far too long for HN.
- MayeulC 5y ago> The Commission will make its software available as open source in one single repository Let's hope this is not a git monorepo... I wonder where they will release it? Github would be the easy choice. They could self-host a forge or just a web frontend, publish tarballs, etc. An interesting choice would be to use SourceHut, which is now based in the Netherlands with ddevault. (edit: well, maybe it's still incorporated in Delaware).
- tpush 5y agoA self-hosted Gitlab instance would make the most sense, IMO.
- absove 5y agoThe European institutions run the Atlassian suite internally so if they self-host anything, which they most likely will, it will be Bitbucket because that's what their IT is experienced with.
- nix23 5y agoThat's explains the sluggishness...thanks for the insight ;)
- MayeulC 5y agoWell, given the resource requirements to host GitLab and the number of potential visitors, I think this is unlikely. Moreover, I wouldn't be surprised if they just opened the code, not the development process. And old, frozen projects with no contributing directions are most likely what we'll get at first. However, hosting OSS code like this is a public service. It would be nice to see the EU commission competing against GitHub for Open Source hosting, but that's probably a pipe dream for now. The really promising part is what this will enable going forward: > The dissemination of software under an open source licence will no longer require a Commission Decision. > The Commission now allows its software developers to contribute to open source projects with improvements that they developed as part of their work. So it might become at the team's discretion. The code will probably end up being developed on GitHub or somewhere else, with a mirror of sorts on the EU commission's "repository" website.
- jaywalk 5y ago> It would be nice to see the EU commission competing against GitHub for Open Source hosting Why would you want them to get into that? It doesn't seem like it's something appropriate for a government to get into.
- zdkl 5y agoWhile 'competing' may not be a good word for it, there's an argument to be made that some software belongs in the commons. This sort of signature/certificate infrastructure is a good example. So why not have it hosted by a public entity? Maybe entrust a couple large libraries with operating and cross-mirroring repositories?
- smarx007 5y agoThere a large popular Gitlab instance in Europe already but ofc EC is free to host its own: https://framagit.org/ https://framagit.org/
- rapnie 5y agoExisting Gitea instance for FOSS-only is a nice option. Codeberg is hosted in Germany and contributes to the wholly community-driven Gitea project: https://codeberg.org https://codeberg.org
- la_fayette 5y agoMaybe they first start a 5 year project to create an apropriate vcs infrastructre...
- raffraffraff 5y agoOn a mainframe
- Turbots 5y agoEuropean commission uses Bitbucket afaik, as well as the rest of the Atlassian stack
- Proven 5y ago> A second example is LEOS, (Legislation Editing Open Software), the software used across the Commission to draft legal texts. Originally written for the Commission, LEOS is now being developed in close collaboration with Germany, Spain and Greece. Totally useless. We need less government-generated opressive legislative junk, not ways to make its production easier. Governments doesn't make anything useful that can be useful to companies or citizens. Most of its services have no competition (or competition isn't allowed) and don't operate on sound economic principles, so there's little use for their software outside of government.
- phkahler 5y agoAny idea what license(s) they'll use?
- erk__ 5y agoA good guess would be EUPL which is written to work within the european copyright framework https://joinup.ec.europa.eu/collection/eupl/eupl-text-eupl-12 https://joinup.ec.europa.eu/collection/eupl/eupl-text-eupl-1... It works much in the same way as AGPL Edit: As per decision https://ec.europa.eu/transparency/documents-register/detail?ref=C(2021)8759&lang=en https://ec.europa.eu/transparency/documents-register/detail?... > the open source licence granted by the Commission shall be the EUPL, except in the > cases listed in points (b) and (c);
- tuukkah 5y ago> It works much in the same way as AGPL Interesting. Is this because of how distribution is defined to include "any act of providing access to [the Work's] essential functionalities at the disposal of any other natural or legal person"?
- erk__ 5y agoYeah, I think the meat of it is how they define distribution ‘Distribution’ or ‘Communication’: any act of selling, giving, lending, renting, distributing, communicating, transmitting, or otherwise making available, online or offline, copies of the Work or providing access to its essential functionalities at the disposal of any other natural or legal person.
- j_san 5y ago> It works much in the same way as AGPL I'm not 100% knowledgeable on the topic but wasn't the issue with (A)GPL that even linking libraries in the runtime to your project would mean that your project can't be proprietary? With EUPL this doesn't seem to be the case: From https://joinup.ec.europa.eu/collection/eupl/news/eupl-and-proprietary-commer https://joinup.ec.europa.eu/collection/eupl/news/eupl-and-pr... > This makes no obstacle for linking Code A with another software component (Code B) that could be proprietary. There is no kind of “viral effect” resulting from the EUPL licence, in so far linking is done for interoperability. The portions of Code A that are strictly necessary for interoperability may be reproduced in Code B without copyright infringement. The resulting “A-B solution”, which could be commercial, will include the two modules under their relevant licences. This is resulting from interpreting European law and case law[1].
- Zigurd 5y agoThis should be the norm for software developed as work for hire for all kinds of governments, everywhere, if only for the reason that it would save a lot of redundant development of software used by governments. There are obvious exceptions for weapons technology. But the presumption should be that governments must look to existing open source software before they contract for software development, and they should contribute newly developed software to the pool.
- sofixa 5y agoAbsolutely agreed. Public money, public code. So much software can be shared between various governments it's not even funny how much money was wasted on useless huge vendors like Accenture and IBM.
- MayeulC 5y ago> Public money, public code. That's the slogan of https://publiccode.eu https://publiccode.eu
- lmeyerov 5y agoI like the sentiment, but have struggled on mechanism. Basically, we need to incentivize creating & running good OSS projects: the more direct the incentives, the harder for non-maintainers to game the system. I suspect the current proposal tilts the bias even further to consulting companies who explicitly rather compete on butts in seats writing code vs OSS product teams wanting to build quality code that minimizes servicing needs. On any individual contract, the product team would be more expensive and thus less competitive, and no longer have a proprietary advantage built up over time to defend against that: the services team can hack the same code. My observation is 100% as a product person who sees these bids go out and contractors take either most or all of a contract because of this dilemma. If we open sourced even more, we'd get even less interest, despite writing measurably better code. Instead, I've been thinking something like "X% budget / yr should be grants to SMB OSS project maintainers" based on a few flavors (gov use, commercial use, ...). Incentivize creating popularly used OSS, vs more services. Like take the SBIR budget and make a 20% match to SMB OSS. Maybe a DAO that'd actually help :)
- streamofdigits 5y agoThis is fantastic news at two levels: * the actual code that will be made public (in particular enabling all sorts of things to be built on top of the Commissions policy / legal know-how and rules) * the signalling, encouragement and precedent that this provides to other public sector instances that may have been sitting on the fence, unsure or even oblivious to open source
- disabled 5y agoKeep in mind that the open source projects being mentioned as examples on this press release only tend to affect people established as residents in the European Union. For example, from the press release: > “ An example of the benefits of open sourcing is eSignature, a set of free standards, tools and services that help public administrations and businesses accelerate the creation and verification of electronic signatures that are legally valid in all EU Member States.” In order to use an eSignature, you need to have an eID (electronic ID) card from an EU member state, which is placed in a smart card reader. Some people in the EU do not have eID cards yet. Yes, some countries have apps that allow you to use an eSignature, but generally speaking, your eID is your best bet. Typically, your eID provides the highest authentication level, in terms of security, when dealing with EU or national (country) level services.
- detaro 5y ago> In order to use an eSignature, you need to have an eID (electronic ID) card from an EU member state. Some people in the EU do not have them. This is false. eIDs are a common way of doing it, since they already have a process for verifying identity obviously and are smartcards matching the required security level, but not required, you can just get a generic matching smartcard loaded with the cert.
- sam_lowry_ 5y agoIn practice, countries recognize only eID cards they produced and signed themselves (well, ordered from Gemalto, Giesecke and Devrient or IDEMIA). Now, once the use of eID cards expands, all these use cases will require software. So far, countries do on their own. Belgium writes its own software, Estonia as well. The point is that most of that software could be reused. So far, only open source parts are reused, like opensc.
- kranke155 5y agoThis is great. I've long thought that every line of code developed with govt. money should be open sourced, and that a country that got serious about this would likely get a lot more people interested in working for them.
- pier25 5y agoThis is definitely a good move, but I was hoping the EU would also announce investment into current open source projects. Maybe a program for people to present their OS project and get funding.
- hoffs 5y agoPretty sure they already fund some open source projects
- pier25 5y agoSource?
- patrickmcnamara 5y agoThe EU runs bug bounty programs for open-source software. But I'm not sure if the EU directly funds open-source projects. https://ec.europa.eu/info/news/eu-fossa-bug-bounties-full-force-2019-apr-05_en https://ec.europa.eu/info/news/eu-fossa-bug-bounties-full-fo...
- estaseuropano 5y agoEU also fundsled foss research and security audits, but no idea whether that was one off or regular https://joinup.ec.europa.eu/collection/open-source-observatory-osor/news/eu-funds-open-source-programm-0 https://joinup.ec.europa.eu/collection/open-source-observato... https://www.zdnet.com/article/eu-to-fund-bug-bounty-programs-for-14-open-source-projects-starting-january-2019/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/eu-to-fund-bug-bounty-programs... And they fund lots of projects, SMEs, NGO work, etc https://protonmail.com/blog/eu-funding/ https://protonmail.com/blog/eu-funding/ https://www.ngi.eu/ngi-projects/ngi-zero/ https://www.ngi.eu/ngi-projects/ngi-zero/ And do lots of policy stuff in the space, e.g. annual policy conference https://opensource.com/article/21/3/linux-powers-internet https://opensource.com/article/21/3/linux-powers-internet
- Reitet00 5y agoThey already do that. Check out https://nlnet.nl/ https://nlnet.nl/ and other NGI programs.
- moffkalast 5y ago"EU Commission not satisfied with paying its developers below market rate, but instead would like them to work for free"
- zoobab 5y agoWell, EU Commission hires indians via TCS or Infosys.
- wahlis 5y agoRather that the Commission does not want to pay consultancy companies time and time again for the same code.
- throwaway098456 5y agoOh, well, this is the opposite of how the European Commission works: Managers climb higher in the hierarchy and get salary increase according to how high the budget they manage is. There is therefore a consistent effort in all the units of all the Directorate Generals to ask budget for new projects, and find a plausible excuse about why an existing solution cannot be used, and a new solution needs to be built from scratch. Then, once this is built, it is common practice to initiate a new project to throw away the solution and re-do it from scratch, again using an excuse reason like adapting to more modern technology, or providing better performance. P.S. The European Commission is composed of 33 Directorate Generals (DGs), each of it responsible of a specific topic. One Directorate General, called DIGIT, is in charge of providing IT solutions to all the others. However, each Directorate General has its own IT department (called 'Unit'), developing solutions on its own, rather than using what is commonly available at DIGIT, or already created in other DGs' IT unit.
- dgb23 5y agoThat's a weird interpretation of what is being said here... From the rules[0] that are mentioned in the article: > On 21 October 2020, the Commission adopted a new strategy on open source software1, encouraging the use of open source software by the Commission, the Commission's contribution to third-party open source projects and the sharing of Commission software as open source. In that Communication, it was stated that, wherever possible and appropriate, the Commission would share the source code for any computer programs where it holds the intellectual property rights on behalf of the Union. But: > This Decision should not create any obligation for Commission services to share Commission software under an open source licence nor any right for third parties to require Commission software to be made available under an open source licence. The Commission should remain free to decide whether to share Commission software or to license it under a proprietary licence. [0] https://ec.europa.eu/transparency/documents-register/detail?ref=C(2021)8759&lang=en https://ec.europa.eu/transparency/documents-register/detail?...
- armagon 5y agoThe article says "The recent Commission study on the impact of Open Source Software and Hardware on technological independence, competitiveness and innovation in the EU economy showed that investment in open source leads on average to four times higher returns. " Four times higher returns ... compared to what? It's like an advertisement that says our product contains 30% less fat. 30% less than what? Than other leading brands? Than your previous formulation (and if so, how do we know you didn't artificially increase the amount of fat in said formulation, so it'd be easy to reduce)?
- zoobab 5y agoThe author of the study, Knut Blind of Fraunhofer, is a hardent proponent of software patents. If you read the study, you will find those nonsense things related to patents: "Table 5.16: Impact of OSS Commits on patents on computer-implemented inventions (FE)" "the number of national contributors to OSS has a positive influence on the development of patents on CII as an innovation indicator of the IT sector."
- Normille 5y ago"a hardent" ? Do you mean "an ardent", or "a hardened", or a bit of both ?
- diracistheproph 5y agoNext step. Make sure EU Government paid contractors release source code per LGPL https://github.com/OpenSC/OpenSC/issues/2462 https://github.com/OpenSC/OpenSC/issues/2462
- beebeepka 5y agoSomeone almost made the Bulgarian government do that a few years ago. I think it went nowhere though
- diracistheproph 5y agoHopefully there can be EU supported remedies for GPL violations. It's kind of absurd. The Estonian eSignature software (FOSS) could fairly easily automatically support many countries eSig, IF the drivers are added to OpenSC ...
- t2s 5y agoThey should also open source money.
- Neputys 5y agountypically nice comment