2 ms·
When the article talks about utility in its examples, it is not talking about some universal objective utility that all would agree on. It is talking about the
by tzs 5y ago
When the article talks about utility in its examples, it is not talking about some universal objective utility that all would agree on. It is talking about the utility that the person making the decision assigns which will depend on their moral values and sentiments.
> What if you don't want to help build a society that neglects the needs of disabled people because of their lesser contribution, and thus your utility function - ie. your desired goal maximization includes helping the disabled son?
Then you'd have a case where utilitarianism and egalitarianism produce the same outcome which is great when you can achieve it, but not very useful in an article that is trying to talk about when utilitarianism and egalitarianism produce conflicting outcomes.
- geysersam 5y agoUtilitarianism can never be in conflict with your preferences whatever they may be. This is by definition. If the utility values would conflict with your preferences, then those were not the correct utility values to begin with.