7 ms·
Yeah, fully agreed. I think trying to quantify such things can sometimes be useful as a tool of thinking, but you're always have to be extremely careful not to
by xg15 5y ago
Yeah, fully agreed.
I think trying to quantify such things can sometimes be useful as a tool of thinking, but you're always have to be extremely careful not to confuse the map with the territory.
If you're making weird calculations with hypothetical utility values, you're making your argument on the map - and you always have to make sure it still makes sense when converted back to the territory.
Numbers can also be used to make wildly unrealistic assumptions seem reasonable or hide additional circumstances that would be required for the argument to apply.
E.g., if you mapped back the utility values from the OP to an actual situation, you'd have a gifted son who is somehow absolutely thrilled to move to the suburbs and a disabled son who is mostly indifferent about whether he has to travel for several hours frequently or not.
The only situation I can think of in which that behaviour seems remotely plausible is if they were already living in the suburbs and the decision is really about moving to the city (and losing their complete social circle) or staying where they are.
If that were the case, the "low additional utility" of the disabled son would more likely be a conflict: The son might appreciate a lot not having to travel so far, on the other hand, he doesn't want to lose all his friends. So, in numbers, a high positive and a high negative utility, which the theory assumes you can simply add up to get a total utility. But that assumption doesn't seem to have merit to me.