4 ms·
I think this is very reductive. The reality is that facts are rarely indisputable, and people have to function in the absence of absolute truth. So, when prese
by tsimionescu 5y ago
I think this is very reductive. The reality is that facts are rarely indisputable, and people have to function in the absence of absolute truth.
So, when presented with a fact that contradicts a preciously-held belief, there are several purely rational actions you can take:
- give up the old belief
- believe that the fact is false (either mistaken or a lie)
- believe that the fact doesn't actually contradict the belief (that there is some missing context that would make the belief compatible with the fact, even if you are unable to see it now)
None of these are irrational, tribalistic, feeling-based reactions, in general. Sure, there are some cases where a fact is simply overwhelmingly obviously true (e.g. it's raining outside), but those are an exception.
The vast majority of facts we have to build our worldview on are not directly confirmable without huge amounts of personal effort - everyone would have to become a world-class experimental scientist, investigative journalist, jurist, l high-level diplomat and many others, to be able to get a true first-hand confirmation of many of the (potential) facts they are presented with. In the absence of such confirmation, we have to choose who to believe based on a complex web of tribalism, perceived history, social cues, emotional intelligence, and priors that have served us well.
- mdp2021 5y ago> we have to choose who to believe based on a complex web of tribalism, perceived history, social cues, emotional intelligence, and priors that have served us well «Tribalism» vs «priors». That family became rich when the curse placed on the husband had him always lose money at gambling: the wife bet double on the complementary option. You do not have close friends you ask for advice in order to help decision - towards the opposite? Some people are more consistently right, some random, some wrong. This includes friends.
- natmaka 5y agoYou describe a tiny fraction of cases. In my opinion most of us are most of the time mostly in tribal mode, therefore "Most people are not rational, they are TRIBAL" is indeed 'reductive'... to most cases. Moreover such a 'tribal mode' mode often impedes the ability to perceive/understand, therefore 'facts' aren't even perceived/understood. You are right: overwhelmingly obviously true facts are very rare, and even less are decisively convincing (only one possible conclusion, without any counter-argument), therefore most facts aren't convincing. This 'tribal mode' seems natural to me because we learn thanks to analogies, and therefore are prone to imitate the most-enforced beliefs/behaviors: our tribe's.
- perl4ever 5y agoRegarding "most facts aren't convincing" - I think that the most productive thing to do, if two or more people strongly disagree about facts, is to drill down into the underlying definitions that provide context for the facts. An analogy is, in effect, a definition. And a definition is not a fact, but which definitions people accept determine which facts they accept.
- natmaka 5y agoIndeed. Many philosophers are pretty clear about it (French ones: B. Pascal, A. Lalande...), however it implies cold (dispassionate) heads and (as pointed out here by KronisLV) plenty of time. Most of us, sadly, lack time and only invest it in whatever we feel some passion for.
- DarylZero 5y agoI have heard that philosophers today have a culture of high toleration for very heated discussions that would be considered beyond appropriate in other contexts.
- KronisLV 5y ago> ...if two or more people strongly disagree about facts, is to drill down into the underlying definitions that provide context for the facts. Except that surely you don't have the time to do that most of the time? What about cases where the other person is being dishonest and shifting the burden of proof about a claim, or trying to offer more and more arguments which detract from making the original point? While drilling down is possibly indeed what you should do, it's also easy for it to derail any average discussion, if done wrongly and either of the participants don't have honest intentions of having a discussion and finding out the truth.
- feoren 5y ago> facts are rarely indisputable Almost all major facts that people disagree on are, essentially, indisputable. It is indisputable that: - The Earth is round - The Earth is at least millions of years old - Evolution occurs - Vaccines generally work - Politicians are not secretly lizard people - Humans walked on the moon These things are all extremely clear and obvious to anyone with a healthy mental model of how the world works. They are all interconnected with tons of evidence from a huge range of disciplines; any one of them being wrong requires a mind-bogglingly huge amount of commonplace and easily verifiable evidence to be flat-out wrong. It's actually very hard (if not impossible) to be self-consistent without being true. How many made-up stories have plot holes? Essentially all of them. Statements that are backed up with thousands or millions of data points and shown (through simple, followable, verifiable logic) to be consistent with the rest of our understanding of how the universe works can essentially be called "facts". Again, this is the vast majority of things people disagree on. > The vast majority of facts we have to build our worldview on are not directly confirmable without huge amounts of personal effort Only if you're persnickety about what exactly "directly confirmable" means. For some definition, literally nothing is "directly confirmable". It's actually extremely easy to confirm most facts that people actually dispute in a political debate. > we have to choose who to believe based on a complex web of tribalism, perceived history, social cues, emotional intelligence, and priors that have served us well Do you have a list of individual humans you have chosen to believe, and you ignore everything else? I don't think you do. I think you have a complex mental model of how the universe works and you constantly try to fit new ideas and concepts into it and see how well they fit. If you're good at it, you keep that new idea quarantined for a long time while you search your mental model in-depth for anything that might dispute that new fact, and then you arrange a contest of ideas where you seek out other information to clarify the situation. Based on the outcome of that contest, you update your mental model appropriately, making an effort to flag pieces of information that may not fit for further review in the future. People who don't do this have chosen not to. They've decided that they don't care about their relationship with truth. And any time we talk about these people, someone comes along with their false equivalency and claims everyone is that way. No. Some of us have decided to care about truth.
- tsimionescu 5y ago