4 ms·
“Just Switch to Linux” Is the Loser's Game (2019)
- bazhova 5y agoRunning Linux desktop is slightly sadistic. I've wasted days trying out the hottest distros, the latest wm, configuring drivers, etc. It's just ... not worth it. All claims of increased productivity are noise. It's not the brush you choose - it's the art you make. Just use whatever you already have and get on with it.
- jqpabc123 5y agoJust use what works best for you --- all things considered. Not everyone has the same set of priorities. For example, it seems you decided to place more value on your time.
- BenjiWiebe 5y agoAs a counterpoint, you don't have to switch distros and wm's. I'm still using the first distro I ever tried (Fedora). I did switch to KDE when GNOME 3 came out, cause I hated GNOME 3. That's the only time I've changed anything in the distro/desktop/wm combo.
- fargle 5y ago> All claims of increased productivity are noise That's a far-fetched and overly broad statement. Just as the universally quantified "all users will have increased productivity" would be an invalid and overly broad statement, as you would be right to complain about. But for my use cases, for example software development and engineering, specifically in the field of embedded, server, system, and other software that is not related to web, android, mac, windows, etc., the productivity increase is absolutely enormous - 20:1 probably. For me windows is just trash - it's impossible to properly configuration control, it changes all the time for no reason, it's horribly insecure, and needlessly difficult and inefficient to use. Command line and text rules for what I do. For me to use windows would be severely masochistic. When I'm inevitably forced to logon to windows in a corporate network, it's pure torture. To me. To abuse your analogy, sometimes it is the brush you choose, or better yet how you choose your brush. I would not want to paint my house with a 1mm fine-tip, nor a tiny detail with a industrial paint spray rig. So I won't tell other people what will work for them, but it is absolutely worth supporting and introducing people, who perhaps have similar use cases as you and for whom it might also be beneficial, to things like UNIX and Linux.
- eloeffler 5y ago> There is absolutely no good rationale to favor a private product in a school setting (at least in public schools, private schools can do what they want) and Linux should be the obvious solution to teach computing in a neutral, non partisan way. Yes! Thank you. There should be a need to justify any deviation from this, too. There can be good reasons to use a private tool here and there. But the reasons should be evaluated clearly and alternative approaches should be considered.
- jqpabc123 5y agoThere should be a need to justify any deviation from this, too. Hello, reality calling. The world is not neutral and non-partisan --- and you can't make it so without introducing your own non-neutral bias, priorities and partisanship. Nothing reflects this better than the universe of Linux distros. Which one should a neutral and non-partisan school choose? Be sure to justify your answer.
- eloeffler 5y agoIt would be absolutely sensible to make a justified decision on this. For the context of Germany, I would imagine that this would be done by full-time employees of the ministries of education in the individual federal states. There could also be public spending to develop a fork of a popular distribution to provide tailored features for schools. The basic idea of making Open Source a requirement for selecting software solutions would just be a criterium added to the existing processes of selecting software/services.
- jqpabc123 5y agoThe basic idea of making Open Source a requirement ... Please explain how this decree is neutral and non-biased.
- alexvoda 5y agoIt is at least neutral in terms of not favouring one profit making entity instead of another. The Document Foundation and contributing developers are not better off or worse off if a public school district uses LibreOffice or not. It simply does not matter. They rely on donations for revenue instead of using monopoly powers to extract revenue by permitting the use of their software. Same goes for OnlyOffice and other FLOSS office suites. On the other hand, if a public school district chooses for example Microsoft Office, this is to the direct detriment of Apple iWork and StarOffice and Lotus(does it still exist?), etc.. This of course becomes a subject of public acquisitions which should be handled through transparent auctions. How often should the choice be made? Once a year, once 2 years? Should there be a round-robin strategy to switch from one provider to another in order to not favour one through network effects? All large software corps rely on the network effects of schools and piracy to further solidify their grip on an industry. Even if you claim that choosing the FLOSS option is non-neutral due to the network effect, in this case the network effect does not have the same ramifications it does for proprietary offerings. So even if the FLOSS choice may not be absolutely neutral, it is MORE neutral than any proprietary option.
- usrbinbash 5y agoI have long since given up trying to convince people to switch to Linux as their Desktop OS. There are many reasons, but the most important one is: I no longer care, and I have no reason to. So what if they don't switch? Does that impact me? No. Linux Desktop is awesome, is only getting better, and this will remain true wheter or not the masses switch over. The question which OS "won" has been decided long ago...the world runs on Linux, everything from our internet backbones to our phones and everything in between. If companies want to waste money on licences, who am I to say no? And if a company doesn't allow Linux to be used in the workplace, well, I'm an engineer, I have options, thanks for your time & offer, please don't call me. If people want Linux, it's right there, ready and waiting, available for everyone. And if they don't, I don't care.
- simonblack 5y agoHell, no! We Linux people just couldn't bear another case of "Eternal September" - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September - with millions of new lusers wanting a dumbed-down Linux. If you want to move away from Windows, go somewhere else! Linux doesn't want you! Go Away!! Go and buy a Mac instead!
- phendrenad2 5y agoThe problem is, half of the Linux community is like you, actively encouraging people to go elsewhere, and the other half of the Linux community is the opposite, actively trying to CONVERT Windows/Mac users to Linux.
- simonblack 5y agoFor about 5 years, I actively sought to convince people that Linux was better or safer than what they were using. Then I remembered Heinlein's proverb: "Never try to teach a pig to sing. It only wastes your time, and annoys the pig." So I stopped 'wasting my time'. If others are using MacOS or Windows, it's their choice and NMP. I also no longer help out people with computer problems. "Sorry, I don't know anything about Windows. I use something else." You can call it "actively encouraging people to go elsewhere" I suppose, but it's more a philosophy of actively discouraging the "Linux Isn't For Me" articles, also saying to them 'Don't come complaining to me that you're not willing to learn something that's not what you're used to. Just go back to working with whatever it is that you are used to working with."
- phendrenad2 5y agoTrue, there are some people in-between. Mostly those who have been far to one side or the other.
- Nginx487 5y agoI gave up battling with half-baked GPU drivers, buggy desktop environments, zero backward compatibility in 2012, when I switched from Linux to Mac, and all my problems vanished at once. Remarkably, MacOS is POSIX-compliant, so basically a well-designed desktop environment over Unix derivative, something that Linux failed to reach in 30 years. In the same time, I develop server-side software for Linux for the last 15 years, and feel like it's just on the right place - on the server.