3 ms·
This understanding is something that (pre-pandemic at least[0]) started entering the scientific consciousness. Some (but probably not enough) scientists were s
by kelnos 5y ago
This understanding is something that (pre-pandemic at least[0]) started entering the scientific consciousness. Some (but probably not enough) scientists were starting to realize that fact-based arguments around climate change weren't really winning hearts and minds. Emotional appeals (backed by facts, of course, but still focusing on emotional response) had the most impact on making skeptics understand that climate change is actually an urgent issue. I can't find the article right now, but I was probably reading about this in mid-2019.
This also reminds me of some stories I've read about black people working to befriend racist people. Often it just takes a racist white person to get to know a black person on more than a superficial level, and then they realize their racism is based on bullshit. I say "just", but of course this isn't a trivial thing to do, and it puts the burden of effort on someone who shouldn't have to expend that effort, and potentially put themselves in an extremely vulnerable position.
Something I always try to do when making decisions (don't always succeed, though) is to think about outcomes rather than what seems logical or just, or would make me feel the best. "Taking someone down" with the most logical argument ever might sound amazing in theory, and have some really feel-good vibes, but often that just won't work to persuade someone. What really matters in the end is the outcome: we want to "win friends and influence people"; that should be the driving motivation. Certainly we shouldn't compromise our ethics to do so, but often persuading someone of your point of view might involve more emotion than logic.
I think the big challenge, covered in the article, is that you need to not only appeal to someone's emotions to change their minds, but you need to somehow convince them that leaving their "tribe" (full of close friends and often family who have the wrong idea) is safe and won't result in alienation and ostracization. It's a really tall order. And, frankly, often they will end up being alienated from many of the people they hold dear. It's really hard to get someone to accept that. Sure, you can try to pull them into your tribe, and make them comfortable with that. But what if doing so means they'll lose their closest friends and family, people they have been close with for years or decades?
[0] Efforts to combat vaccine hesitancy and outright misinformation haven't been going so well. I think a big part of the problem is that people are trying to throw facts against emotion. That just doesn't work most of the time.
- mdp2021 5y ago> Efforts to combat vaccine hesitancy and outright misinformation haven't been going so well. I think a big part of the problem is that people are trying to throw facts against emotion. That just doesn't work most of the time Oddly, I have noticed the exact opposite: an incredible and unduly resorting to emotional, sketchy, manipulative language - not only in fact, but also theorized by articles "do not speak to them using rational arguments", and from academicians (e.g. The Conversation) - which of course, had "alarm bells ring up to eleven" in "normal", rational people. Nobody¹ concedes trust when manipulative language is perceived. ¹(finally, a rare almost legitimate universal quantifier) -- > we want to "win friends and influence people"; that should be the driving motivation This probably needed much better expression.